4 ms·
> #1 is this article's biggest problem I don't know, but I had the same idea years ago, and I later read about an author using the idea in a 2006 book (Daemon,
by lucb1e 9y ago
> #1 is this article's biggest problem
I don't know, but I had the same idea years ago, and I later read about an author using the idea in a 2006 book (Daemon, by Daniel Suarez). I'd say this shouldn't be an issue, and it also solves number two: if we can think of it, so can hostile governments* and mad men.
That said, the article does (after he gets to the point of "weapons of mass destruction") seem to get a little obsessive and, yeah, crank-y. But that has little to do with the concern itself.
* Not "hostile foreign governments" because every government is foreign (and perhaps even hostile) to someone.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoReminds me of Snowden leaks - most of the stuff was pretty much obvious to anyone with any actual understanding of technology, and yet saying it out loud would get you labeled as a crackpot.
- carapace 9y agoTrue. I think you have to be paranoid, really paranoid, to be able to think about this kind of thing. "Normal" humans seem to have psychological stability mechanisms that operate pathologically when confronted with events that are too far outside of their world-view. It's fine to disbelieve Bigfoot. It's dangerous to disbelieve e.g. Stuxnet. Even the author: > It wasn't until I'd read through the code [of Stuxnet] myself that I finally believed that it had actually happened. Is it a failure of imagination? Head-in-the-sand-ism? Just not paranoid enough? To everyone reading this, if this article sounds like a crank, please re-evaluate your world-view. This is the clearest and most well-written description of the problem I've yet read.
- jtbayly 9y agoI'm not sure why this is being downvoted. It seems entirely reasonable to assume that people just can't bring themselves to think about some things logically.
- 3pt14159 9y agoCarapace I’ve been taking the comments here pretty hard. Thanks for this.
- carapace 9y agoDude thank you. You're a freakin' hero. You've identified what I call the "Maximum Overdrive" problem and actually gotten people to take it seriously. That is amazing and I applaud your efforts. Thank you.
- pvg 9y agoThe NSA warrantless surveillance program, something much more egregious than anything revealed by Snowden, was reported in the plain old regular press - the New York Times, back in 2005. James Bamford has made a long and distinguished career of writing about the NSA with his first book coming out in 1982.