4 ms·
What Von Neumann -- or anyone else -- would or would not call it doesn't change the truth of the matter. Von Neumann also believed that consciousness was requi
by lisper 9y ago
What Von Neumann -- or anyone else -- would or would not call it doesn't change the truth of the matter.
Von Neumann also believed that consciousness was required to collapse the wave function. This is a non-falsifiable and hence non-scientific theory (which is the problem with all collapse theories). Von Neumann was a really bright guy, and he very nearly got the right answer, just as Lorentz very nearly got to relativity before Einstein. But just as Lorentz refused to let go of the idea of Galilean invariance, Von Neumann refused to let go of the idea that classical reality is a primary phenomenon. It isn't. Classical physics is an emergent, not a primary phenomenon. There are no particles, only quantized fields. (To be fair, Von Neumann did not live long enough to see Bell's theorem or the Aspect experiment, so he didn't quite have all the information he needed. But he was bright enough that he probably could have come up with Bell's theorem on his own if he'd decided to go that direction.)
- kgwgk 9y agoI really don't understand what you are trying to say. Do you dispute the name or do you dispute whether it happens? From the quantum state of the particle/detector which is a superposition of both possible outcomes, what happens according to you as a result of the measurement? Is there a definite result? What do you mean when you say that "if the detector is working properly then these amplitudes are zero and the interference term vanishes"? Is going from non-zero amplitude to zero amplitude a physical phenomenon? Why does it happen?
- lisper 9y agoDid you actually read my paper or watch my video? Because answering those questions is exactly what they are about.
- kgwgk 9y agoI have not tried the video, but I've read the paper. As I pointed out, your description of a measurement in section 4.1 is a textbook description of wave function collapse. I'm trying to understand how do you think that your explanation is different. Or maybe I'm missing your point completely.
- lisper 9y ago> I've read the paper. OK, the content is essentially the same. > Or maybe I'm missing your point completely. Yep, I'm pretty sure that's the case. You should probably re-read section 3.
- kgwgk 9y agoI don't see the relevance. My question about the description of the measurement process on section 4.1 (which is supposed to be more fundamental: "Let us begin with the simple two-slit experiment.") stands.
- lisper 9y ago> I don't see the relevance. Section 3 presents an argument for why is cannot be the case that a measurement causes a physical change in the system being measured (because it would result if FTL communications). If you don't see how that's relevant then you are beyond my ability to help. > supposed to be more fundamental You are reading way too much meaning into that introductory sentence. The two-slit experiment is often presented as fundamental because it is easy to describe, and because historically it was done very early in the development of quantum mechanics, but it is not fundamental. Indeed it is this false assumption that 2-slit is fundamental that has lead to the horrible pedagogical mess that QM suffers from to this day. It is simply false that no one understands QM, or even that QM is particularly hard to understand. It's just that the usual pedagogy of QM is based on a false assumption.
- kgwgk 9y agoI don't want to get lost on terminology (what is more fundamental, what do we call a physical change...). I try to understand the consequences of the approach you propose. In 4.1 you look at a couple of similar examples that are quite simple, a particle/detector system in the first half ("measurement") and a particle/particle system in the second half ("entanglement"). The "measurement" part starts like von Neumann's measurement scheme, which is a two step process. In the first step, one assumes that the "target" and the "probe" are composed into a single quantum system (there is entanglement like in the particle/particle system considered later, I agree with that). This system is in principle in a superposition of states, the density matrix does contain interaction terms. In the second step, one applies a non-unitary operator to actually take the measurement at the classical/macroscopic level and the interference terms dissapear. Instead of a pure quantum state we end with a diagonal density matrix representing a mixed state (the system is either in one state or the other, we don't know which one but we know the corresponding probabilities). I still don't understand how the second step works in your approach and why do the interference terms vanish. I understand even less how do you conclude that "the entanglement destroys the interference in exactly the same way (according to the mathematics) that measurement does." The entangled pair looks identical to the pre-measurement target/probe pair, but interference is still present at that point (and vanishes because of the measurement, whether or not we call this the collapse of the wave function). By the way, in the video there is a slide saying that the resulting wave funtion is |ΨU |^2 + |ΨL|^2 but that's not a wave function.