9 ms·
> measurement does not cause the collapse of the wave function. But you provide an example of measurement causing the collapse of the wave function yourself!
by kgwgk 9y ago
> measurement does not cause the collapse of the wave function.
But you provide an example of measurement causing the collapse of the wave function yourself!
"Now let us add a detector at the slits to determine which way the photon went. To describe this situation mathematically we have to add a description of the state of the detector:
(ΨU |DU> + ΨL |DL>)/√2
where |DU> is the state of the detector when it has detected a photon at the upper slit and |DL> is the state of the detector when it has detected a photon at the lower slit. Now the probability density is:
[|ΨU |^2 + |ΨL|^2 + (ΨUΨL <DU|DL> + ΨLΨU <DL|DU>)]/2"
That describes the quantum system formed by the photon and the detector. And when you reduce the density matrix to its diagonal, setting the interference terms to zero in a non-unitary way, you are collapsing it to a "classical" mixture of two states corresponding to the possible outcomes of the measurement (as described by von Neumann 85 years ago).
- lisper 9y ago> when you reduce the density matrix to its diagonal, setting the interference terms to zero in a non-unitary way, you are collapsing it to a "classical" mixture of two states corresponding to the possible outcomes of the measurement (as described by von Neumann 85 years ago). Yes, that's true, but that is not the same thing as "measurement causing the collapse of the wave function". Collapse is not a physical phenomenon, it a a mathematical approximation. When you measure a particle, nothing happens to that particle as a result of the measurement. It does not suddenly "decide" to go through one slit or the other. Anything that "happened" to the particle happened not as a result of the measurement but as a result of the initial entanglement with the ancilla.
- kgwgk 9y agoYou had a wave function for the particle/detector system, you performed a measurement, then you didn’t have any longer the wave function that you previously had. I think that’s what von Neumann would call “measurement causing the collapse of the wave function”.
- lisper 9y agoWhat Von Neumann -- or anyone else -- would or would not call it doesn't change the truth of the matter. Von Neumann also believed that consciousness was required to collapse the wave function. This is a non-falsifiable and hence non-scientific theory (which is the problem with all collapse theories). Von Neumann was a really bright guy, and he very nearly got the right answer, just as Lorentz very nearly got to relativity before Einstein. But just as Lorentz refused to let go of the idea of Galilean invariance, Von Neumann refused to let go of the idea that classical reality is a primary phenomenon. It isn't. Classical physics is an emergent, not a primary phenomenon. There are no particles, only quantized fields. (To be fair, Von Neumann did not live long enough to see Bell's theorem or the Aspect experiment, so he didn't quite have all the information he needed. But he was bright enough that he probably could have come up with Bell's theorem on his own if he'd decided to go that direction.)
- kgwgk 9y agoI really don't understand what you are trying to say. Do you dispute the name or do you dispute whether it happens? From the quantum state of the particle/detector which is a superposition of both possible outcomes, what happens according to you as a result of the measurement? Is there a definite result? What do you mean when you say that "if the detector is working properly then these amplitudes are zero and the interference term vanishes"? Is going from non-zero amplitude to zero amplitude a physical phenomenon? Why does it happen?
- lisper 9y agoDid you actually read my paper or watch my video? Because answering those questions is exactly what they are about.
- kgwgk 9y agoI have not tried the video, but I've read the paper. As I pointed out, your description of a measurement in section 4.1 is a textbook description of wave function collapse. I'm trying to understand how do you think that your explanation is different. Or maybe I'm missing your point completely.