3 ms·
>> So I’d like to begin by summarising some of the recent history in the field of artificial intelligence, or machine learning as its now called. To be more pr
by YeGoblynQueenne 9y ago
>> So I’d like to begin by summarising some of the recent history in the field of artificial intelligence, or machine learning as its now called.
To be more precise, the field is still known as AI, but people outside the field only know (and care) about machine learning, presumably because that's what Googe, Facebook, et al are recruiting for.
This is a bit of a sad situation, really. AI, in its drive to solve major hard problems (that still remain unsolved btw), has always contributed powerful programming techniques and even entire language paradigms to computer science (functional programming, object orientation that basically started with Minsky's frames, all sorts of search algos etc).
Machine learning is just one such technique which has gained popularity outside AI. It's powerful, for restricted problems. But if it somehow replaces AI in peoples' mind, the goose that lays the golden eggs might just die.
- thomasahle 9y ago> Machine learning is just one such technique which has gained popularity outside AI. I'd argue the machine learning label can be applied to any AI system that's data-driven in some sense (even self-generating the data using reinforcement learning). Wikipedia lists the following approaches to Machine Learning. Surely you wouldn't call them all 'one technique'?: Decision tree learning, Association rule learning, Artificial neural networks, Deep learning, Inductive logic programming, Support vector machines, Clustering, Bayesian networks, Reinforcement learning, Representation learning, Similarity and metric learning, Sparse dictionary learning, Genetic algorithms.
- regularfry 9y agoAI used to cover Expert Systems, which have nothing we'd recognise as a "learning" phase at all. Hell, it used to cover parsers.
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoLet's say that it's a class of techniques that learn models (or progams, in the case of ILP) from data. My main concern is not about defining what machine learning is, however. Rather, I'm worried about the definition of AI shrinking to "it's what we now call machine learning". Which is at the very least unhistorical.
- breatheoften 9y agoI thought it was common for people to think of AI as largely disjoint from machine learning ... AI covering all the expert/rule based systems, grammars, and search algorithms with ML being pretty strictly referring to techniques for building predictive models from datasets ...
- YeGoblynQueenne 9y agoWell, machine learning arose partly from the need to find a better way to create rule-bases than hand-crafting them, painstakingly and at great cost. You can see this more clearly in the work of early pioneers like Ryszard Michalski, or in inductive inference (the field preoccupied with learning automata from examples). All these have always been well in the purview of classical AI. Then of course there's the connectionist branch that explicitly set out to take inspiration from the human brain. I don't think that anyone ever saw neural networks as anything but AI for the last 50 years or so. In any case, when the connectionist were having arguments, they were having them with other AI folks, not with, say, statisticians, or mathematicians. Then, if you think about the classic tasks that machine learning systems perform, they're all firmly classic AI tasks: classification, game-playing, machine vision, speech processing, etc etc. I mean, the fact that models are "predictive" on its own doesn't tell you that machine learning is separate from AI. After all, an intelligent agent must be able to make predictions about its environment and the outcome of its actions on this environment.
- davesque 9y agoIsn't it kind of reaching to say that the field of AI contributed the entire functional paradigm of computation? Can you say more about why you think that's the case?