4 ms·
I really want to down vote you. You claim that you can accurately estimate usage time from battery capacity in mAh, performance from Ghz number but you are conc
by mrtksn 9y ago
I really want to down vote you. You claim that you can accurately estimate usage time from battery capacity in mAh, performance from Ghz number but you are concerned by the type of the app that plays the video on manufacturers estimates?
What if Apple/Samsung employs you and you look at the battery capacity and inform the rest of the world about usage time? Such a talent should not be wasted. You might be close to disrupt the battery industry or win the "I got a talent" TV show.
If all fails, start selling "Geekbench hates this guy" video series and teach the world to accurately estimating gadget performance and battery time from spec sheets.
You can also bring down Youtube to it's knees as all these test and review videos will become worthless overnight.
I have an app idea for you: The fastest benchmark software on the planet, instead of running intensive tasks just write a code that compares numbers of Ghz, Ram etch. Whichever is bigger that device is faster, obviously. Gone are the days of 12H battery tests, just calculate it from the battery mAh.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoYou misunderstand me. > You claim that you can accurately estimate usage time from battery capacity in mAh, performance from Ghz number I'm not claiming that I can accurately do that, for engineering values of "accurate". I'm claiming that I can estimate the fit of the device for my use cases better with those values than with manufacturer-provided "real-life" benchmarks. Ignoring your sarcasm for a moment; you mention benchmarks providers - yet the reason those third-party benchmark shows and sites exist is because manufacturer-provided benchmarks are usually pulled out of asses of the marketing department and are utterly worthless and usually (by design) not usable for comparison shopping. This comment pretty much circles us back to the original quote I pulled out of the discussed article: "[Japanese] People require a high degree of assurance, by means of lengthy descriptions and technical specifications, before making a purchasing decision – they are not going to be easily swayed by a catchy headline or a pretty image." You seem to be advocating that one should be "easily swayed by a catchy headline or a pretty image". Well, I don't trust marketing departments of consumer-good vendors that much.
- mrtksn 9y agoThe thing is that battery time is a function of capacity AND consumption. I don’t think that you can use average consumption since even software update can make or break your use time as it can drastically alter the behavior of the device. Oh and it’s still the marketing department that choose to communicate these numbers to you, not engineers. If the battery doesn’t last they will choose to slap the mAh of the battery instead of the estimates. but maybe i’m wrong, maybe these days the phones use about the same energy and battery capacity is a useful measure
- lhopki01 9y agoWhy are you attacking him instead of replying to his points? He's saying that with the battery capacity he can estimate how long it'll run for him because he know what his current phone is like. It's a relative comparison. If he's told by the manufacturer that it plays X hours of video he can't try and figure out what that means for him, especially if his phone is from a different manufacture. Also two different manufacturers will use different video players making it harder to compare the two. mAh is a the best we can get. I know that given two phones one with 3000mAh and one with 2000mAh the former will probably have longer battery life under the same OS. If there are different OS's then I need to apply a bit more comparison from knowledge but I still have more information.
- mrtksn 9y agobecause he doesn’t make sense to me, i don’t know how to respond. battery use time is a function of capacity and consumption. battery use time provided by the manufacturer is a better measure as it includes both variables of the function and not just the capacity. he can’t estimate use time of another device from the battery capacity as he is missing the consumption variable unless it’s the exact same device. He will have better shot if compares his actual use time to the advertised time and apply the difference to the device that he wants to predict.
- barrkel 9y agoRelative comparisons don't make sense to you?
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI tried to hint at this point, but let me say it explicitly: devices from the same category, like mobile phones of given "class" and year, tend to have more-less the same power consumption. This "tend to" and "more-less" are good enough for rough estimates and comparison. Of course, I would also include other knowledge like common sense (a phone that holds less than 1 day on average is considered broken; no smartphone will hold for more than 2 days in actual constant use). Also, knowing battery capacity in mAh gives you another funny side effects: 1/ I can ballpark how long it will take to charge it. 2/ I can ballpark how many times I can recharge it with my powerbank (or conversely, what powerbank to buy to have at least two recharges of my phone). That's the nice thing about such "natural" metrics - they allow for further comparison for different use cases.