4 ms·
Wave function collapse is not observed physical phenomenon. Some interpretations of QM require it to exist, but there is no empirical evidence of that happening
by nabla9 9y ago
Wave function collapse is not observed physical phenomenon. Some interpretations of QM require it to exist, but there is no empirical evidence of that happening.
Apparent wave function collapse happens when a wave function in a superposition of several eigenstates appears to reduce to a single eigenstate. The apparent wave function collapse collapse is mathematically equivalent of quantum decoherence where the wave function never really collapses but the states gets entangled with the observer.
If somebody were able to formulate and experience that would show the difference between decoherence and collapse, that would be new physics and we would be able to rule out some interpretations of quantum mechanics. Until that happens, 'shut up and caluclate' seems to be valid course of action.
As far I understand, the philosophical difference between apparent and actual wave function collapse is that in the apparent collapse probabilities of other states get so close to zero that they don't matter, in actual collapse they are exactly zero.
The assumption that human consciousness has something to do with setting all other states to zero is weird one and can't completely understand the assumptions behind it. I guess the idea is that we would not experience the world as we experience it now if there is just continuing decoherenće.
- akvadrako 9y agoWhat you say is true, except as long as there is no evidence for collapse and it's designed to be undetectable, accepting it in a theory is nonsense. You might as well postulate there are magical pink unicorns dancing on every particle. By your logic that theory also can't be ruled out.
- nabla9 9y agoIt's not my logic. I was attempting to describe the situation. If you know better how the logic in interpretations requiring wave function collapse work, be kind and explain it.
- cygx 9y agoThe philosophical difference is that without collapse, all of the eigenstates contributing to the intial state will get entangled with their own 'copy' of the environment, which is where the moniker many worlds interpretation comes from.
- nabla9 9y agoWhat is unclear to me in the many-worlds hypothesis is the reason whey these 'copies' don't constantly interact with each other and lead to continuous decoherence. How this is justified?
- justinpombrio 9y agoEach of the worlds ends up distinct, e.g. all the air molecules end up in slightly different positions. Worlds that different don't interfere with each other. (This is predicted by the math, the math is the justification.)
- lmm 9y ago> Apparent wave function collapse happens when a wave function in a superposition of several eigenstates appears to reduce to a single eigenstate. The apparent wave function collapse collapse is mathematically equivalent of quantum decoherence where the wave function never really collapses but the states gets entangled with the observer. The problem with this interpretation is the fact that density matrices work: that certain probability-weighted ensembles of states are completely, provably equivalent to other probability-weighted ensembles of states. If you don't interpret collapse as physically real, then it remains to be explained why this should be the case.
- nabla9 9y ago> If you don't interpret collapse as physically real, then it remains to be explained why this should be the case. Explanation is only needed if decoherence is not good enough explanation.
- lmm 9y ago"Decoherence" does nothing to explain it.
- nabla9 9y agoDescribe an experiment that differentiates between decoherence and wave function collapse.
- lmm 9y agoDescribe an experiment that differentiates between a photon that has a 1/2 probability of being vertically polarised and a 1/2 probability of being horizontally polarised, and a photon that has a 1/2 probability of being left circular polarised and a photon that has a 1/2 probability of being right circular polarised. Under "decoherence" those should be different things, and for them to be observationally indistinguishable would be nothing short of magical.
- 9y ago