3 ms·
The other real question with MWI is why you still experience one universe and not a superposition of universes? How exactly, in moment-to-moment physical detai
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
The other real question with MWI is why you still experience one universe and not a superposition of universes?
How exactly, in moment-to-moment physical detail, do these splits happen?
And as for branching - how are observers assigned among universes?
The MWIers will shrug and tell you observer experiences are distributed at random.
Well - fine. So why can’t the collapse experience be inherently random too, without demanding squillions of Occam-busting unobservable universes?
It seems like the least plausible interpretation. Not only does it multiply entities for no good reason, and assume they can never be observed, but it doesn’t even solve the original problem.
“Yes, but the math...” isn’t a defence because there are plenty of situations in physics where technically correct solutions are discarded as unphysical. Why make an exception here?
- FeepingCreature 9y ago> The other real question with MWI is why you still experience one universe and not a superposition of universes? Because the brain is warm and messy? And Occam does not work that way.
- coldtea 9y ago>And Occam does not work that way. Well, Occam is not a physical law, so that's neither here, nor there.
- lmm 9y ago> The other real question with MWI is why you still experience one universe and not a superposition of universes? You experience a superposition of universes. Why do you think you aren't? What would you expect to be different? > How exactly, in moment-to-moment physical detail, do these splits happen? The wavefunction is what's physically real. When you can express the wavefunction as a linear combination of two other wavefunctions, then it makes sense to model this as a split, and think of it as the universe dividing in some process like cell division (a wavefunction that's almost a linear combination of two other wavefunctions, but has a small interaction term, is like a universe that has almost split into two, but the two parts are still slightly attached). Sometimes a split happens at a discrete point corresponding to a discrete physical event - e.g. if a proton and an antiproton in known spin states that sum to 0 collide to generate two gamma rays, then that's a distinct, discontinuous event (and you'll see that in the wavefunction) and after it the wavefunction is expressible a linear combination of two wavefunctions. So we interpret this as "when the particles collided, the universe branched", and like most models that's a simplification of reality, but it's a good one that generally gives correct intuitions. But if you ever want the exact physical detail, just look at the wavefunction. > Well - fine. So why can’t the collapse experience be inherently random too It can, but the collapse is a much bigger assumption than subjective probability. It violates unitarity, it's unclear when it happens, it introduces a notion of observer and a direction to time and all of that - and for what? It doesn't let you get rid of the superpositions (you still have to assume that the superpositions exist before the "collapse", so you still need all the machinery that you would need to implement many-worlds). Occam's razor says we can and should do without it. > without demanding squillions of Occam-busting unobservable universes? By that logic the assumption that the universe is billions of light years across should require a huge pile of evidence, much more than we have. Occam doesn't say we should be parsimonious about the size of the universe we assume, it says we should be parsimonious about how many physical rules we assume.