8 ms·
> You can hire lots of humans to work at a normal pace and give them psychological counseling, and spend so much on their salaries that you'll go out of busines
by mschuster91 9y ago
> You can hire lots of humans to work at a normal pace and give them psychological counseling, and spend so much on their salaries that you'll go out of business, and even then they won't catch everything and will be frequently accused of bias.
Then you should not fucking be in the business at all! What FB does is externalizing the cost onto societies and skimming the profit!
Cost here being two things: first the cost of mentally fucking up the moderators (so an extensive amount of psychological healthcare has to be shouldered by society) and second the cost to society that arises from letting Nazis and jihadists spread their propaganda (including the cost from real-world violence enabled by said propaganda).
- twblalock 9y agoAny online open forum would have the same problems no matter how hard they tried to prevent it. We can either accept that some level of hate speech is inevitably going to slip past the moderators, or we can give up on having open forums altogether. There is no perfect world with perfect moderation of online content. I wish Facebook had the courage to say this themselves.
- ben_w 9y agoIs that provably inevitable for all online forms, or is “nobody knows how to yet”? Governments act like all tech problems are the latter, but I would like to know if this is like encryption that only friends can break (never), or like self driving cars (most people call it impossible until five years after it’s been demonstrated).
- dfox 9y agoFor me moderating what amounts to open communication platform falls into third category: it is impossible and you should not try to do that. Especially in FB's case where it is quite obvious that various opposing "hate groups" have learned how to game the system, and also how to present results of that such that it supports their rhetoric.
- jacquesm 9y ago> it is impossible and you should not try to do that. No, it is merely extremely expensive. But that's something that you need to tackle head on when your business model is to provide a service for free to a large chunk of the planet's population. The 'free' bit doesn't absolve you from your responsibility as an operator.
- jjeaff 9y agoSeems like their recent move to get news off the feeds and focus on family and friends should solve the content issue. If someone is posting or liking hate speech or offensive content, I can just block them. I wouldn't add someone as a Facebook friend that would do that kind of thing anyway.
- ben_w 9y ago> it is impossible and you should not try to do that. Can you prove, or at least demonstrate strong evidence for, either of those two claims? “FB are noobs at propaganda” isn’t sufficient, IMO.
- T2_t2 9y agoThe former, because words are subjective, therefore this is no way to get everything anyone anywhere would ever consider hate speech. It's just an impossible scenario.
- mschuster91 9y ago> Any online open forum would have the same problems no matter how hard they tried to prevent it. Facebook tries to get by with as few moderators as they can, with paying them as low as possible and generally trying to teflon away anything negative from their service (i.e. they negate being responsible for the fake news/hate speech on their platform). I believe that there would certainly be a way to provide fair moderation - for example a ratio of 1 full time CSR (customer services representative) per 1000 users, not the 1 per 20k or worse they are currently trying to do.
- twblalock 9y ago> a ratio of 1 full time CSR (customer services representative) per 1000 users That would require 2 million full-time CSRs, because Facebook has a little over 2 billion active users per month.
- mschuster91 9y agoIf that is the price to avoid externalizing the cost of a lack of moderation to society, then it is 2 million CSRs. I'm sick and tired of Silicon Valley companies thinking they can save money on customer support and have societies pick up the tab. And it's not like Facebook (or Twitter) couldn't get the money: 3€ per user and month should be enough to cover the cost of a properly salaried CSR - and at the same time create a barrier for bots and Nazi trolls.
- ropiku 9y ago> And it's not like Facebook (or Twitter) couldn't get the money What makes you say that ? Facebook barely makes $5/quarter (3 months) in revenue. They couldn't even afford $1/month/user. Meanwhile Twitter has never turned a profit ever.
- eli_gottlieb 9y agoIf you can't make more than $5 per quarter per user, maybe you shouldn't be in business. If you have never, ever turned a profit, then what are you, a charity?
- danjayh 9y agoI'm absolutely gobsmacked that people are starting from the position that hate speech should be censored at all. The determination of what constitutes 'hate speech' is made by whoever happens to be in power at the time. Winston Churchill would have given a much different answer than Adolf Hitler. From my point of view, it's chilling that the mechanism to do this has been built in the first place.
- rebeccaskinner 9y agoThis is a common approach by groups who perpetuate hate speech- to exclaim with faux outrage that any limits on hate speech are tantamount to the dissolution of free speech at the behest of ostensibly powerful minority groups. I won't go so far as to accuse you of being a member of hate groups, but your response certainly echoes the propaganda that they spread, especially in forums like HN. The fact is that society has always drawn lines about what speech and behavior is and isn't acceptable in different venues and circumstances. Facebook's choice to censor hate speech is no different from a bar, restaurant, or department store asking someone to leave for shouting the N-word at fellow shoppers. It's a private non-governmental entity making a choice about how they want their users to act on their platform. Furthermore, free speech claims in favor of hate speech ignore the real material costs in human lives that facilitating hate speech incurs. While I greatly value free speech personally, I also greatly value human lives and the ability of all people to meaningfully participate in society without facing systemic oppression, violence, and hatred. Tolerance must inevitably come face-to-face with intolerance, and if we don't act to stop the worst kinds of hatred and intolerance they fester and decay the ideals that allow tolerance to flourish at all.
- programmarchy 9y agoYou’re drawing a false equivalency. Social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter are more like a public squares rather than restaurants or stores. It’s a space where free speech should be defended. Because free speech protects our society from authoritarianism and violence. It’s authoritarians who want to limit free speech, because their ideas have no merit and can only be enforced by violence.
- naasking 9y ago> Any online open forum would have the same problems no matter how hard they tried to prevent it. Then don't make it open. Make it auditable and tied to your public identity, not to an email address you can invent at any time. The OP is right, FB is making huge profits by punting the costs onto society.
- cgmg 9y agoDo you want to forcibly prevent others from engaging in anonymous discussion? Have you given any thought to the implications of that?
- DenisM 9y agoFIDO.NET was a fairly polite society. There’s a lot to learn from then if there is will.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThere's only one way I've seen in which one can reliably make and maintain a polite community: build it around a niche topic and moderate away things that stray too far away from it. The moment you let your community be about anything and everything is the moment the "unwashed masses" come and the whole thing starts catering to the lowest common denominator, which is a pretty shitty level. It's not a complete recipe, but I feel it's a necessary condition. This is a big part of why HN is a polite place, or why most niche subreddits are polite places.
- pferde 9y agoYour forum could still be "about anything", yet not cater to lowest common denominator. It's only when you deliberately want to attract (and retain) as many eyeballs as possible, then the quality necessarily has to go out the window.
- tripzilch 9y agoIt works just fine with medium to large online forums, given they have a good and motivated moderator team. Just not for global online forums like FB.
- cgmg 9y ago> Then you should not fucking be in the business at all! You seem to be venting incoherently. How does that follow from the statement you're replying to, at all?
- amake 9y agoSeems perfectly coherent to me. He's saying that if your business can't afford to solve the problems it creates (and instead pushes the problems onto society at large and/or disposable workers), then he thinks that business should go under.
- twblalock 9y agoThe prevalence of fake news and hate speech on Facebook is caused by problems in society itself, not by Facebook.
- jhayward 9y ago"That house was flammable all on its own, all I did was provide a match".
- mschuster91 9y agoFacebook is a massive enabler for the spread of fake news/hate speech. I do not doubt that there are problems in society, but Facebook needs to be held accountable for its (in)action.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- averagewall 9y agoNazis and jihadists aren't that bad. They're just people promoting their political ideology. That's everywhere. Look at gangsterism - it's a major cause of murders in the US but it's glorified and promoted by rap music. Communism is arguably worse than Naziism but it's not treated with the same horror.
- dang 9y agoWe've banned this account for trolling.
- corndoge 9y agoSo what? Nobody builds social networks? Great idea, let's just all agree not to build social networks or make companies out of them. Because as we all know humanity is great at not doing things we have every capacity as well as a handful of reasons to do. Try thinking about a real solution to the problem next time that isn't "let's not do this".
- lmm 9y agoI'd flip this: if a society is so weak that it's damaged by "letting Nazis and jihadists spread their propaganda" (i.e. by letting people speak freely) then that society should fail. (I do think that if Facebook is employing people to do something that predictably harms those employees then it should bear the cost of protecting them from those harms, and treating and compensate them when it fails to protect them)
- tripzilch 9y agoReally! It's like someone founded a nuclear power startup and people in this thread are basically excusing them from properly dealing with the nuclear waste because, you know, it's really hard.