22 ms·
The US government is not a PC maker. The goal of the disclosure was to help companies figure out how to patch systems. Why would anyone expect the government to
by phkahler 9y ago
The US government is not a PC maker. The goal of the disclosure was to help companies figure out how to patch systems. Why would anyone expect the government to be notified first?
- achamayou 9y agoThey're a pretty big customer for Intel?
- developerdanny 9y agoSo?
- Sephr 9y agoAs a customer and not an OEM, what would they do with this information other than ask other parties to hurry with updates? The mitigations required OEMs to send firmware, microcode, and software updates.
- microcolonel 9y ago> As a customer and not an OEM, what would they do with this information other than ask other parties to hurry with updates? They could shut down machines for which it is an excessive risk; though honestly I don't think they should be privileged as customers go.
- Radle 9y agoIn some systems the PC maker controls the update path and not the operating system. As such it was important to get PC makers on the Team, otherwise users would have been left undefended.
- Sephr 9y agoOEM doesn't mean operating system, it means original equipment manufacturer (e.g. PC maker). You seem to have misread my comment.
- phkahler 9y agoIn the same way people are customers of Freescale or Infineon because they buy cars? I hesitate to use the car analogy because there are recalls, but you still take the vehicle to the company you bought it from, not the supplier of that faulty part.
- puzzle 9y agoNot only that, Intel produces most of its chips in the US. The one plant they have in China used older processes, had to be approved by the US government and should have been repurposed to make memory chips. If you sense a pattern...
- throwaway7645 9y agoNational security?
- AsyncAwait 9y agoIntel is a multinational corporation.
- mikeweiss 9y agoA multinational American company
- AsyncAwait 9y agoWith the majority of sales outside the U.S. Are you arguing for Intel to employ some sort of "American exceptionalism" type policy when notifying customers of weaknesses? Apart from being a discriminatory position in itself, it is also not a very sound business decision. Also, with all we know about the NSA, I'll be very surprised if the U.S. government didn't already knew and if they did, didn't try to take advantage of it.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PeterisP 9y agoYes, it's headquartered in USA, all the executives are personally liable to USA laws (and not Chinese laws), and it actually is quite possible that they could be required to pursue American exceptionalism in regards to security issues, even if they weren't doing so yesterday. I.e. an order (with due legal process) by USA government to not disclose that vulnerability to any Chinese companies would be possible and binding, but not the other way around. That's what being a USA company means, no matter where your sales are.
- AsyncAwait 9y ago> an order (with due legal process) by USA government to not disclose that vulnerability to any Chinese companies would be possible and binding In that case, sure, but I was talking about a voluntary disclosure, which is the case here.
- Sephr 9y agoNotifying the government early would only serve towards helping the government temporarily exploit this vulnerability for intelligence purposes. It wouldn't make sense to notify them until progress was made with mitigations.
- tree_of_item 9y agoIs this a joke? Why would you not expect such a major American company to notify their government, when the government is one of their biggest customers?
- AsyncAwait 9y agoIntel notified vendors, (such as MS), so I'd assume the U.S. government would get these patches as well, I would also guess that any large customers of intel, (including the Gov), got some level of advanced notice, just probably not before any other large customers, which I do not see a problem with.
- Spooky23 9y agoWho says they didnt? Any such notification to agencies that matter would be classified information. Now given that it’s Intel, the notification may have been “Reminder that our chips are working according to spec”, but I’m sure people knew.
- hishnash 9y agointel want to be able to operate all around the world and not be forbidden form non US markets if it is seen that they directly pass an exploit to the US gov so that US gov can use it to exploit into other nations systems then those other nations will ban Intel from sales. (even US allies would ban intel)
- bllguo 9y agoAgreed completely, this is basically clickbait meant to stir up anti-China sentiment
- tomohawk 9y agoThe US Government has national defense responsibilities. Providing such exploit information to Chinese companies, many with strong ties to the PLA and other government organs, without notifying your own government first, seems irresponsible.
- charlesdm 9y agoIf it was beneficial from a commercial point of view to first disclose to partners outside of the US this makes sense. Intel doesn't exist to serve US national defense responsibilities; they exist to make money.
- jknz 9y agoAny government has national defense responsabilities. With your logic, Intel is a multinational company and should have informed them all, which leads to its own kind of problems. Edit: The only reasonable path seems to inform every government simultaneously, at the same time as the public. How could the EU possibly let Intel sell CPUs, and let Intel inform other governments of vulnerabilities first? So that the other governments have a time window to play with the vulnerability against the EU?
- tomohawk 9y agoOnly if you think there is some sort of moral equivalence between the governments.
- phkahler 9y agoThere is a practical equivalence between governments. If one government could make the case that they should be informed, then any government who bought systems with "Intel Inside" could make the same argument. If you want to split governments into groups based on some notion of morality then you may want to question why a company would be allowed to do business with a country on the wrong side of that morality in the first place. That's actually a discussion I'd like to see.
- 9y ago
- rdlecler1 9y agoThey’re a customer and a very big one. They also need to figure out how to patch their systems. Systems which may be controlling weapons.
- booleandilemma 9y agoWho do you think the Chinese companies told upon learning about the flaws?
- angry_octet 9y agoTheir state security bureau. Chinese companies are inextricably linked to the Party.
- nsainside 9y agoThis place is becoming more and more like reddit...
- kumarvvr 9y agoIt's eminently convenient for China to gather valuable intelligence from countries around the world. No matter who is manufacturing what, it's Intels responsibility to ensure all those who _use_ their chips know of it immediately.