4 ms·
This study showed that a Tylenol ibuprofen combo was as effective as opioids (and with zero chance of addiction). If course it's likely to vary in effectivenes
by jjeaff 9y ago
This study showed that a Tylenol ibuprofen combo was as effective as opioids (and with zero chance of addiction). If course it's likely to vary in effectiveness by patient and depend on the type of pain. I can't help but feel that pharmaceutical companies probably don't want a lot more studies like this coming out.
https://www.healio.com/family-medicine/pain-management/news/online/%7B0bae033f-14ae-4b2d-b06e-1234ef367cf8%7D/combined-acetaminophen-ibuprofen-produces-similar-amount-of-pain-relief-as-opioids-in-ed-patients https://www.healio.com/family-medicine/pain-management/news/...
- Terretta 9y agoOn the contrary, since nobody in the US is willing to prescribe opioids any more, hospitals are doing Tylenol IV drips, and pharma is now charging 10x for acetaminophen. They’re just fine with the hysteria and the studies, they still get paid.
- dpark 9y ago> since nobody in the US is willing to prescribe opioids any more Since when? I was given opioids when my wisdom teeth were pulled a year ago, far more than I needed. From what I understand, opiate prescriptions are down, but only by 10-20% or so.
- frostburg 9y agoOpioids for wisdom teeth removal is insane to me (and 100% of the medical doctors that I know, and it's a lot of them). This is utterly disfunctional.
- dpark 9y agoIn fairness my wisdom teeth removal wasn’t exactly textbook. I had to go to an oral surgeon and he had to dig into the lower jawbone to remove one of them, breaking it into pieces to get it off the nerve. I had a lot of damage to the gums and quite a few bone fragments migrated out over the next few weeks. I was however even offered opioids for a root canal once (different dentist). I didn’t fill that prescription.
- rincebrain 9y agoHaving had a bunch of dental work done, sometimes it's not unreasonable - I had my wisdom teeth out and was given hydrocodone for afterward, but I was fortunate and didn't have any pain warranting it after. Being given opiates for a root canal seems insane, though - if you have crippling pain _after_ a root canal, I think that means the dentist did something horribly wrong.
- frostburg 9y agoI had this done two time (jawbone cut, tooth extracted in fragments, stitches thereafter) and while the healing process was annoying, it wasn't painful unless I tried eating solid foods with the wrong side of the mouth or something like that (which was a good indication of the fact that it was too early to do so, which helped healing faster, which is why - even discounting addiction issues - taking painkillers for avoidable pain is dangerous). The "quite a few bone fragments migrated out" part sounds pretty bad, on the other hand; that's not really supposed to happen as far as I know.
- dpark 9y agoI agree that the opiates probably weren't needed. I took the recommended dosage at first and just completely passed out for hours, so I have no idea how much pain I would have been in. After that, I cut the dose in half for the next day, until I got really sick of feeling foggy and just stopped entirely. (I found the whole "high" to be really annoying and not particularly pleasant, aside from the pain dulling properties. All I wanted to do was read and I couldn't do that.) I suspect ibuprofen would have been sufficient but I don't really know, either, since I took the surgeon's advice and took the opiates at first. I do still have one wisdom tooth left. If I ever get that one out, I'll see how it goes without the opiates. Bone fragments migrating out are apparently not that uncommon. Any bone piece that breaks off but doesn't get completely removed will eventually migrate out of the gums.
- danieltillett 9y agoThis study is so bad I don't know where to start. Apart from its small size, the other major things is there was no ibuprofen control or ibuprofen with codeine control. There is a vast difference in the effectiveness of ibuprofen over acetaminophen. It is studies like this that have caused us Australians to lose access to OTC codeine this week.
- eropple 9y agoIs there a compelling reason for codeine to be OTC in the first place? It's an addictive opiate.
- syshum 9y agoThis is the wrong question. The question should be is their a compelling reason to make it Rx Only, and people that support making it Prescription only have the requirement to provide evidence to support making it RX only. The fact that is "addictive" is also not enough IMO
- eropple 9y agoPeople are neither medically qualified to evaluate opioid use nor, when in a situation where they may be necessary, personally capable of evaluating their situation. This is why trained professionals exist. This is literally why. Asking whether there is an argument for an addictive opiate with significant health impacts and the opiate-consistent tolerance growth that leads to self-medication and increased dosage to be available without medical consultation is the "wrong question"--to somebody whose posts throughout this thread are unempathic, pull-the-ladder-up-behind-us, so-brave stances that project personal (theoretical and probably wrong) resistance to addiction onto societal policy. I will take that as a compliment.
- syshum 9y ago>>This is why trained professionals exist. This is literally why. Trained Professional exist to advise and recommend. Even in healthcare doctors are not dictators, they advise their patients on the best course of action it is then up to the individual to either follow that advice or not. I assume you oppose that, and believe doctors should have legal authority over their patients who should not be given any choices and should be compelled to do anything the doctor orders So my question to you is why to you hate individualism and individual freedom? Following that how far does that extend, to you believe in a pure technocracy where decisions and public policy are selected on the basis of "trained professionals " in their areas of responsibility, particularly scientific knowledge with out considerations for personal liberty, rights or choices?