11 ms·
I think High Sierra is the worst Mac OS release yet. I’m sure there’s a cognitive bias partially to blame (since it’s the most recent) but it looks like we are
by tambourine_man 9y ago
I think High Sierra is the worst Mac OS release yet.
I’m sure there’s a cognitive bias partially to blame (since it’s the most recent) but it looks like we are way past that.
- madaxe_again 9y agoQualitatively, it feels like apple’s software quality has been on a slide for several years. What attracted me to move to Mac OS in the first place some 15 years ago was the sheer quality. It was thrilling to use a computer that Just Worked, with no BSODs or the endless dependency hell that was Linux at the time. It doesn’t feel like that any more, across either OSX or iOS - it feels fragile. Things crash, behaviours are inconsistent, and it feels like more emphasis has been placed on immediate commerciality than long term retention through quality. For what it’s worth, I’m in the process of moving to Linux on my MBP. The pros of OSX just aren’t as strong any more.
- st3fan 9y agoThank goodness that Linux is consistent and has no bugs :-) Ubuntu still doesn't let me change my IP address to a static one via the UI and video drivers still crash or result in hours of googling and reading contradicting articles on how to change xorg.conf Software has bugs. Operating systems are hard. It doesn't matter where you will go, you will most likely deal with similar issues. Whether it be Linux, Windows or macOS.
- tambourine_man 9y ago>Software has bugs. Operating systems are hard. Sure, but it doesn't help when you are rewriting fundamental parts of the stack like the window server, for instance. And I'm very glad that they did, the move to Metal shows they are committed to the Mac and not standing still. Just don't treat us as involuntary beta testers.
- __david__ 9y agoExcept their window system rewrite actually slowed everything down. Every single os release has added bugs to the graphics layer. I've been maintaining a simple little screensaver since Mac os beta (almost 20 years old now) and the last 3 or 4 releases there's always something that breaks it. Bug reports go unheeded.
- tambourine_man 9y agoMay I ask which screen saver?
- icebraining 9y agoUbuntu still doesn't let me change my IP address to a static one via the UI What do you mean? It doesn't get applied?
- st3fan 9y agoThat is right. I fill in the fields, then submit the change and nothing happens and it jumps back to DHCP. Always have to just edit the network settings manually.
- braderhart 9y agoSorry, but Ubuntu and Gnome NetworkManager issues do not equate to issues with Linux. They are very distro and window manager specific.
- pjmlp 9y agoRegular users see a full distro experience as Linux, they don't dissociate kernel and userland.
- marmaduke 9y agoNot sure why your comment is grayed out. This is very much true, and part of the reason I run CentOS when I want infrastructure to work 24/7/365, but eg Fedora for testing new software.
- nxc18 9y agoThe difference is you pay a huge premium for Apple products, Linux distros are generally free (unless you want enterprise-style support). The same criticism applies to Windows - give it away for free and I might care less about crashes and the huge slide in quality over the last ~5 years.
- st3fan 9y agoI'm happy to pay a premium to never again have to deal with xorg.conf. All platforms come with a cost.
- foepys 9y agoFWIW, X configures itself nowadays and Wayland also just works. But I know where you are coming from. Everything audio related for example is still in very bad shape when you want more than Intel HDA.
- pjmlp 9y agoCanonical is not of the same opinion, they just gave up on Wayland for the next LTS release.
- vurpo 9y agoWayland may be ready for default in Ubuntu and Fedora, but they clearly didn't consider it ready for LTS. They have already said the next non-LTS version will still have Wayland as default.
- sneak 9y agoNow try hotplugging an external display.
- madaxe_again 9y agoYeah, except 15 years ago it was xf86config with xinerama if you wanted multiple heads, and lcds are a walk in the park compared to CRTs - I actually killed a nice 21” monitor by screwing up the frequencies. I even recall the delightful process of having to modify graphics drivers to work with the bizarre Chips&Technologies integrated graphics I had. At that point, OSX was such a breath of fresh air. Xorg.conf is a delightful stroll through a meadow compared to the nightmare fuel that came before, and in setting Linux (Kali,Ubuntu) on several machines of various spec over the last weeks, it has Just Worked.
- pjmlp 9y agoMy Ubuntu 16.04 LTS X-Windows just froze today multiple times, not even changing to virtual terminals was possible, only hard reboot.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoI spent hours last night trying to get Bumblebee to work with my Optimus laptop. Ubuntu is a great plug-and-play distribution, except when it isn’t.
- ensiferum 9y agoOptimus is a piece of shit even on windows.
- ShabbosGoy 9y agoFacing that right now :-( Optimus is one of those ideas that’s cool on paper, but horribly implemented.
- marmaduke 9y agoRe Ubuntu and docs, this something where I find CentOS valuable: it moves slowly but is very stable. I’ve never seen network issues on CentOS on cli or GUI. Red hat also puts out great comprehensive docs so you don’t have to dredge the forums.
- ksk 9y agoYes, all software has bugs. And pretty much all modern operating systems are good. But some are better than others in much the same way as all Olympic 100m runners are fast but some are faster than others.
- Retric 9y agoI found OS X to be incredibly buggy at release. I think 10.2 was fairly stable, but I had a lot of issues before that.
- daxelrod 9y agoAgreed. 10.2 was the first OS X release that felt usable day-to-day without running into too many bugs, annoyingly missing features, or frustrating UI decisions. 10.4 felt like the first version that was a pleasure to use. It felt like the polish had finally caught up with OS 9.
- lemoncucumber 9y agoIMO, 10.6 was still the best release. Wish they would do another “no new features” release one of these years.
- wsc981 9y agoAs long as we are talking about anecdotical evidence: my MBP with High Sierra has been running fine for the last few months. I haven't encountered any issues in my day-to-day work as iOS app developer and neither in my home use. I think it's a pretty decent release, though it didn't add any new features that I feel I really need.
- st3fan 9y agoSame here. My only reboots have been for system & security updates. No kernel panics. Stable as a rock.
- alyandon 9y agoMy 2017 MBP hard locked once shortly after upgrading to High Sierra but it hasn't done it since.
- ascom 9y agoActually, my mid-2014 13" rMBP randomly reboots on High Sierra, even on a clean install. It leaves no trace of anything in any logs. I had to downgrade to Sierra.
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoI hit this bug when using htop
- ksk 9y agoAre you using anecdote to mean 'not factual/confirmed' or simply to mean 'single data point'? I understand that its common to switch between the two meanings. I can usually guess from the context but its unclear from your comment. In any case, I would say that even a single data point of a kernel crashing bug is cause for concern.
- lmb 9y agoThe mach kernels in general are buggy, regardless of the release. e.g. I'm pretty sure they end up delivering SIGPIPE to the wrong thread in some circumstances on Sierra. There is also a problem with recvmsg not returning control messages some time. Another reason they killed OS X Server maybe.
- pjmlp 9y agoTo be fair, the whole story about signals and threads on UNIX OSes is not that clean.
- astrodust 9y agoThey killed server because that was a losing battle: Apple was never going to "win" at servers. Despite all their effort they managed to score only a few modest wins, and the intense competition in that space made it a huge distraction. Remember Apple started down the "server" road decades ago with their A/UX UNIX server (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A/UX https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/A/UX). Throughout the 1990s you could get a high-end Mac spec'd as a UNIX machine if you wanted, though I've only ever seen a handful in the wild. The introduction of a special-purpose server was an anomaly, the Xserve had no specific predecessor, perhaps some kind of "go big or go home" effort on Apple's part. While that system wasn't bad by the standards of the time, it couldn't compete with the likes of Dell, HP and others who offered way more flexibility on configuration and who would seemingly sell super budget low-end servers at a loss to lock people into their product line so they can squeeze them on support costs, a model Apple's allergic to.
- pjmlp 9y agoStill it did fulfil a market, servers for Apple shops. Now there is only Mac minis for it.
- astrodust 9y agoEven then they realized it was a losing battle. Apple is an Apple shop and even they couldn't use their own gear at scale. I'm sure when the Xserve team saw racks and racks and racks of generic kit in Apple's own datacentres they realized they weren't going to win. You're right that the Mini is a very capable workgroup server, and providers like http://macminicolo.net/ http://macminicolo.net/ are hosting Mac "servers" by the thousands, so it's not like they've completely given up. Intel's the only other player in this space with their NUC machines and those tend to cost as much or more. Hopefully they'll kit out the Mini better in the 2018 iterations. That 2012 quad-code i7 variant was an exceptional unit.
- danieltillett 9y ago10.0 was pretty bad - as in unusably bad. Like everyone I really miss snow leopard.
- pilsetnieks 9y ago> 10.0 was pretty bad - as in unusably bad That's why they gave everyone free CDs with 10.1.
- marssaxman 9y ago"Snow leopard" was 10.6, was it not? 10.6.8 was the best OS X ever. I wish I could have stuck with it forever, but that machine eventually died and the replacement wouldn't boot under anything older than 10.9. Someday I'm sure I'll be forced to "upgrade" again, but in the meantime I'm leaving things well enough alone.
- danieltillett 9y agoYes Snow Leopard is 10.6. In retrospect, 10.6.8 was the high point for MacOS X.