3 ms·
Reagan and Thatcher were conservatives. Why is everyone trying to rebrand their ideology as something called "neoliberalism"? They were the arch enemies of what
by closeparen 9y ago
Reagan and Thatcher were conservatives. Why is everyone trying to rebrand their ideology as something called "neoliberalism"? They were the arch enemies of what most people seem to call liberal, even in economic terms (social safety net, consumer and environmental protection, universal access to healthcare and education, etc). What is insufficient about the term "conservative"? What about their ideology close enough to liberal ideology to conflate the terms?
- rangibaby 9y agoIn politics liberal meaning “left-wing” is a US English thing
- closeparen 9y agoSo “Liberal Democrats” from the UK is a false cognate?
- dragonwriter 9y agoA lot of what is considered “left-wing” in the US is “liberal” (and somewhere on the political right) in the global sense, though, confusing things more.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Reagan and Thatcher were conservatives. Why is everyone trying to rebrand their ideology as something called "neoliberalism"? Neoliberalism in its modern sense is a particular politico-economic viewpoint, a subset of what in modern America is political conservatism. (The term in its current sense is European in origin, where “liberal” has a different meaning, and although there is some overlap in applicability to the 1980s American term “neoliberalism”—both apply to much of the pro-capitalist faction of the Democratic Party that reached the peak of its power in the 1990s and remains dominant in the party but weakening—its a different term that is largely unrelated to the usual sense of “liberal” in the American political context.)
- closeparen 9y agoIs any part of the Democratic Party not pro-capitalist? (As in, “we should have a fundamentally capitalist economy, shaped by some regulation and redistribution to deal with negative externalities and alleviate hardship.”) Maybe some people who believe in total collectivization vote Democratic as the lesser of two evils, but are they really unseating the capitalists?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Is any part of the Democratic Party not pro-capitalist? (As in, “we should have a fundamentally capitalist economy, shaped by some regulation and redistribution to deal with negative externalities and alleviate hardship.”) That particular binary sense is not the sense I was using; I was using it as a relative descriptor within the Party for favoring a relatively more-capitalist version of the modern mixed economy compared to other factions of the Democratic Party.
- mc32 9y agoNeoliberalism is an economic policy rather than a political ideology. Both Dems and Repubs practice neoliberalism. Trump, depending on mood, is not quite a neoliberalist given his view that other countries do not reciprocate our neoliberal economics. It's his opposition to neoliberalism which causes consternation amongst the old right (Bushes). But enamors him amongst traditional unionists who see his policies as more favorable to American workers.
- jebeng 9y agoI think you have it backwards. It's the 'liberal ideology' as you put it that is conflating and rebranding the classic economic liberalism. I think it's fair to say Thatcher and Reagan were proponents of free markets and private ownership, which is at least a basic part of the reason they are considered some of the best examples of neoliberalism last century.
- mezzode 9y agoLiberal in this case refers to economic liberalism as in the "free" in free-market. This does cause confusion though given the modern meaning. For example, the Liberal party in Australia is conservative.