4 ms·
It's hard to read those in quite the same way. Jesus, of course, famously got in trouble for associating with "bad" people more than "good" people. Faith vs wo
by majormajor 9y ago
It's hard to read those in quite the same way.
Jesus, of course, famously got in trouble for associating with "bad" people more than "good" people. Faith vs works is an age-old debate in Christianity. And the Old Testament God was angry and violent, and in many ways would qualify as a "bad guy." Look at what he did to poor Job, whose only crime was being faithful. Demanding obedience is somewhat different than demanding moral action.
- sjsbsh 9y agoJesus associates with “bad” people is a gross simplification. Rejects is a better term. Jesus teaches two points. One that “bad” people are bad because they are rejects. Two. You must repent. He never tells an adulterer, tax collector or prostitute “live and let live”. He orders them to sin no more. The ones thrashed in hell (and he’s graphic here) are the ones who don’t repent on time.
- goatlover 9y agoTechnically, Yahweh allowed Satan to test Job as part of a bet that Job was only faithful because Yahweh treated him so well.
- majormajor 9y agoThat's pretty messed up, though, right? "I'm gonna put my relationship with this devil above my relationship with my devoted follower and ruin this poor guy's life and kill a bunch of other people just to win an argument"? It's blurry, at best. However, to the point in the original article, a good-vs-evil interpretation of Christianity is something that goes back a while, and I haven't personally read enough pre-Enlightenment church doctrine to know when precisely it developed.
- goatlover 9y agoSure, but I've read the point of the story was to combat the idea at the time that you only suffered bad things if you deserved it. IOW, it was showing that bad things do happen to good people. The part about Satan & Yahweh was just to provide a theological context for it.
- slededit 9y agoThe idea we aren't mere pawns in games of the Gods is a rather modern idea.