3 ms·
One problem here: to have it operated by the locals requires a significant training effort and then it's reinforced by doing it for real. You're absolutely rig
by hga 16y ago
One problem here: to have it operated by the locals requires a significant training effort and then it's reinforced by doing it for real.
You're absolutely right about the lack of a direct proliferation problem and the fact that so many people including inexcusably Jimmy Carter when he was President (he was one of Rickover's nuclear engineers) make such a big deal of this non-existent danger says a lot about modern world wide science policy, all bad.
Weapons grade plutonium has to be be bred quickly so that the buildup of the two undesired isotopes is minimized, which required quick fuel exchange, something the RMBK designed used at Chernobyl allows. Taking standard civilian grade plutonium based on the usual infrequent fueling cycles and trying to make a bomb out of it requires refrigeration capable of removing 100kW of waste heat (that's from the plutonium isotope used to power the RTGs used in deep space probes) and results in something that's locomotive sized and that has sub-kiloton yield (we did this as a proof of concept in the late '70s and Jimmy freaked).
That said, while Iran's incompetence at maintaining and expanding their electrical infrastructure means they really do need the power, what's to say they don't use it as an inefficient weapons grade plutonium breeder? It does indeed suck for this purpose, but will they care???
(I suspect they will because the subsequent separation process is so difficult to run in practice (due to how fiercely radioactive what's pulled out of a reactor is) and they're forging ahead on the uranium approach.)
- ippisl 16y agoHow easy it is to convert the reactor itself , into one that can make weapons grade plutonium? i read somewhere it takes 3 months, is this true.