3 ms·
The most practical, logical, obvious move would to be to reimplement Thunderbird as an Electron app. But of course that would be untenable for Mozilla because
by DonHopkins 9y ago
The most practical, logical, obvious move would to be to reimplement Thunderbird as an Electron app.
But of course that would be untenable for Mozilla because it would be admitting defeat to Chrome.
The problem is that Mozilla has no alternative to Electron. There are a number of false starts and head fakes, but none of them have any buy in or support or future.
- wrinkl3 9y agoWhat would it take for Mozilla to build an Electron-like runtime with Firefox?
- DonHopkins 9y agoWill, commitment, follow through, etc.
- AlbertoGP 9y agoThey tried: "This project is an Electron-compatible app shell for creating desktop apps based on Gecko, the rendering engine used in Firefox." https://github.com/mozilla/positron https://github.com/mozilla/positron but they failed: "As noted in the blog post Positron Discontinued [1], this project has been discontinued. The source remains available, and you're welcome to reuse it." [1] https://mykzilla.org/2017/03/08/positron-discontinued/ https://mykzilla.org/2017/03/08/positron-discontinued/
- DonHopkins 9y agoThat's exactly what I meant by false starts and head fakes. In fact, xulrunner was another much earlier attempt at developing an Electron-like platform, but Mozilla's heart just wasn't in it, and they didn't care about or adequately support third party developers who were trying to develop applications with it, like TomTom Home for example (which I worked on). Xulrunner was never meant to be a platform for desktop or embedded apps the way WebKit was -- its singular purpose was to support the desktop version of Firefox. Which is exactly how Thunderbird got into the hopeless dead-end situation it's in right now. Its best move would be to switch to Electron, which is impossible only because of the obvious political reasons. There's no reason to expect Mozilla to ever support any other Electron-like platform any better than they did xulrunner.
- johnny22 9y agoCan't graphene be used for that in the future?
- nirv 9y agoI dream that someday Mozilla will fully commit into developing a similar platform on the basis of the Servo/Quantum. This would allow to quickly mockup highly parallel and fortunately high-performance applications based on web-technologies, e.g. Rust engine via WebAssembly and HTML5+/CSS3+ layout.
- DonHopkins 9y agoJust like we dreamed that Mozilla would someday fully commit to supporting xulrunner, when we were working on TomTom Home. In the mean time: wake up, smell the coffee, and use Electron. Problem already solved!