3 ms·
Isn't this why people incorporate in Delaware? The article doesn't make it clear how Philadelphia asserts jurisdiction over the blogs. Is it blogs hosted on s
by jrockway 16y ago
Isn't this why people incorporate in Delaware?
The article doesn't make it clear how Philadelphia asserts jurisdiction over the blogs. Is it blogs hosted on servers inside Philadelphia? Is it blogs hosted on servers administered by someone physically located inside Philadelphia? Is it blogs hosted on servers whose business bank account is in Philadelphia? Is it blogs written by authors who live in Philadelphia? Is it blogs whose Adsense are sent to an address in Philadelphia? And so on.
Personally, I feel like they would have a hard time going after someone who works for a company incorporated outside of Philadelphia. The corporation runs the blog and pays you to write it. The business exists outside of Philadelphia's jurisdiction, and you just do some work on the side for it from Philadelphia.
Interestingly, the literal reading is "every individual ... engaged in an ... activity for profit must file a Business Privilege Tax Return". Sounds like this applies to anyone with income. Sounds like this applies to anyone on unemployment (after all, sitting around trying to keep your unemployment checks coming is techncially profitable).
This sounds like exactly the law that someone making $50 in profit from Google ads can safely ignore.
- rwhitman 16y agoAs far as I remember the wage tax applies to anyone who WORKS in Philly (W2's included) or at least it used to. So (as I recall) if you are employed at a company and go to the office in Philly, regardless of where you live you still needed to pay wage tax. Its absolutely ridiculous, unenforceable and by some counts could be illegal. I know other municipalities in Pennsylvania had lawsuits filed regarding similar issues. However because its so impossible to enforce you can basically tear up the letter if you live outside the city.
- dangrossman 16y agoIf it's like the rest of Philadelphia's tax laws, then if you come to the city for even a single day, and engage in any business activity, that business must pay the city's taxes. Of course, if you live there, then you obviously meet their condition no matter where your business is registered.
- nicholasjbs 16y agoIsn't this why people incorporate in Delaware? People incorporate in Delaware for several reasons: corporate legal disputes are handled by judges rather than randomly selected juries; one person can fill multiple roles for a company (e.g., he can be listed as the CEO, treasurer, and secretary -- other states don't allow this); since so many companies do it there is more established case law and precedent (= less risk); and, of course, the filing fees are cheap.