6 ms·
I wonder how much of a writer's success is balanced between being a good writer, and a good marketer. How much give is there? If your prose is excellent but you
by pavel_lishin 9y ago
I wonder how much of a writer's success is balanced between being a good writer, and a good marketer. How much give is there? If your prose is excellent but you're bad at getting your book in front of eyeballs, you'll almost certainly fail - but how bad can you be as an author, while still making money by being a better salesperson?
- runevault 9y agoProse is very little indication of success, sadly. Some of it is marketing, but some of it is just hitting a moment in time. Look at Fifty Shades of Grey, the prose is terrible, but a lot of women needed what it was offering them on an emotional level and so it sold a TON of copies. And then once a book hits a certain critical mass people will start to pick it up who aren't the target audience just to see what the hell the buzz is about.
- ddorian43 9y agoDoesn't that, like, happens frequently with women (movie, book, like fashion or something) ? Or do dudes the same thing. Maybe it just felt natural for me being a dude.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> Or do dudes the same thing. I don't know about you, but I binge read something like fifty Star Trek novels when I was a kid because that's what the library had. That was once I ran out of the other shitty sci-fi on offer, because I'd already read all the Asimov three times over. I think we think of women as doing this more because men tend to be employed more often than women, and once the kids are old enough to become self-sufficient - and/or shipped off to school - homemakers of both genders get more downtime to sit down and read.
- runevault 9y agoYeah a non-trivial portion of the Romance market is stay at home moms who have down time while the kids are at school (obviously not all day with cooking/cleaning/etc) and they will read multiple books a week commonly. And on the guys front, plenty of guys read cheap thrillers that are all about explosions and blood without much prose behind them.
- Spooky23 9y agoDon’t know about you, but 80% of the people on line at 4 am for an iPhone 5 (last time I did it) were dudes. Also, Star Wars.
- munificent 9y ago> Or do dudes the same thing. Motor vehicles (muscle cars, Japanese sport bikes, Tesla, etc.), programming languages (JS, Lisp, Rust), liquor (vodka, whiskey, Moscow mules), electronics (hi-fi audio, pagers, TVs, smartphones), web frameworks (too many to list), beer styles ("imports", stouts, IPAs, Pilsners), grooming (sideburns, beards, mustaches), etc. As far as I can tell, the main difference between men chasing trends and women doing is that dudes sink way more money into it and take it way more seriously.
- ryanwaggoner 9y agoAnd about half of our hobbies have health or injury risks.
- akamaozu 9y agoNot a female, but growing up I read every Hardy Boys, Nancy Drew and Goosebumps book I could get my hands on. In my opinion this trait exists for all genders.
- matt_s 9y agoSame could be said for programming regarding prose. You can write beautiful code (modularized, great exception handling, proper form, etc.) that doesn't solve the problem properly or write ugly code (huge monolith, repeated code, meh error handling) that solves a large business problem. An ugly monolith that solves pain is going to be worth more than a beautiful piece of software that doesn't solve the pain. I'm not saying you can't have both, just that writing beautiful code by itself doesn't help, much like very good prose in novel writing.
- runevault 9y agoSure, but I'm saying even something that is beautiful and does offer a decent amount of emotional impact still isn't guaranteed success, either from simply not being found or not hitting the right emotion that impacts a wide swath of people. And trying to do that is mostly guesswork, since it is a regularly moving line.
- bambax 9y agoWell okay, but there's a big difference between code and literature, which is that the end user of software doesn't read the code: the code isn't the product, it's what the code does. It could of course be argued that in literature what is said is more important than how it is said, but at least it has to be understandable. You don't have to have a wonderful prose to be a great author, but at least people need to be able to figure out (some of) what you are saying.
- ghaff 9y ago>but at least it has to be understandable And then there is James Joyce :-)
- CM30 9y ago> It could of course be argued that in literature what is said is more important than how it is said This could be said about most things to be honest. What something says or does is generally more important than how exactly it does, regardless of whether the thing is a book or a piece of tech or anything else in between. It's one of the reasons so many startups and projects struggle, because they think their work is going to be about solving a programming problem while it's actually about solving a marketing/network/human one. So many people all programming community software to become the next Facebook or Reddit or whatever else. So many losing to some guy setting up a forum script because the latter actually focused on the community and the former were interested in the shiny tech.
- crdoconnor 9y agoA friend of mine used to do marketing for a romance novel house and she told me how they used to do stuff like sending small gifts with book club subscriptions and A/B test their effectiveness. It might just have been her bias but she gave me the impression that sort of stuff mattered quite a lot.
- klenwell 9y agoHaving a good headshot probably helps, too. I guess it would count as a key component of one's marketing package. I'm reminded of this Adam Gopnik article on a discovered Shakespeare portrait: And that Shakespeare was good-looking as a young man, before he lost his hair and puffed out from home-cooking, seems at least likely, on the fixed general principle that writers who become very celebrated in their youth, as he did, are, to a first approximation, almost always good-looking. Byron and Shelley, Mailer and Updike and Salinger, Fitzgerald, Dickens, Tennyson, Lowell, Ted Hughes—all celebrated in their youth, all not just O.K.-looking but an oil painting, each and every one. There are many good funny-looking writers, but it’s hard to think of good funny-looking writers who get famous young. Funny-looking writers, at least funny-looking male writers, get famous late—Samuel Johnson and Sinclair Lewis and John Milton and Philip Larkin all come instantly to mind—or else they don’t get famous. They get read, but they don’t get celebrated. https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/adam-gopnik-look-here-upon-this-picture https://www.newyorker.com/books/page-turner/adam-gopnik-look...
- cgh 9y agoThomas Pynchon is a counter-example. "V." was published when he was 26 and was nominated for the National Book Award. Here is his "headshot": http://pixel.nymag.com/imgs/daily/vulture/2013/08/23/23-thomas-pynchon.w245.h368.jpg http://pixel.nymag.com/imgs/daily/vulture/2013/08/23/23-thom... Of course, he was already becoming famously reclusive by this time so maybe he's exempt from this rule.
- klenwell 9y agoPerhaps that's even why he opted for the reclusive strategy. Anyway, I love that headshot.
- jessaustin 9y agoNo kidding! I've found my new avatar...
- brucephillips 9y ago
- michaelbuckbee 9y agoThe term I see often now is: "Writing to the Market". That it's part formula, part SEO, part trying to fit into "readers who liked X might like Y". In startup terms it's often like "Uber for X". Consider Harry Potter. There are tons of variants around the theme of "Young person with powers goes to school". So you end up with things that are like "Harry Potter for College", "Harry Potter but Superheroes", "Harry Potter but Female lead". None of which is marketing in the sense of placing ads, but more fundamentally about writing/making something that will sell.
- ohjeez 9y agoAs with other things, it's some of each. As well as identifying the elements of your creation that make something appealing. Dan Brown is the quintessential example of a horrible writer who is nonetheless successful. By any measure his prose is terrible. His fact checking is nonexistent. (In the first book, the hero looks out the window of a bathroom in the Louvre towards the Eiffel Tower, and you can't see the tower from there.) ...And yet he is a good tale-spinner and excellent with "and _then_ what happened?" plot, so it works. One very successful fiction writer pointed out to me years ago that fiction can rely on several items: voice, plot, character, setting, etc. So "being a good writer" is just an overall label that obscures those things. Ideally an author is great at all of them, but few are. And as the same author pointed out, if you write (and want to make a living at it), you have to publish, and you have to get noticed. There's an old saying that books don't become bestsellers if they're hidden in a trunk. In the olden days when book publishers ruled the earth, an author could rely on the effectiveness of a good agent or publisher (and the luck involved in finding one). Now, the author has to learn to present herself with confidence, which does not necessarily come naturally. It becomes another relevant skill that has little to do with plot, character, etc. -- rather like the skill of getting your own butt into the chair in the first place. That does indeed map to tech skills. Just as a thoughtful writer (and reader!) identifies the various parts of the novel, so too does a thoughtful developer consider her tech skills (idea generation, debugging, team building, whatever). And the ability to communicate/market is among them.
- ggg9990 9y agoI think that for plot-focused fiction, “terrible” writing is better —- the Count of Monte Cristo would have been worse if it developed the characters better.
- ohjeez 9y agoI see what you mean, but I'd argue that stories succeed when they have more than one of these attributes. (And I'd enjoy the argument. This is a fun two-beer discussion!) Sometimes the absence of an attribute encourages the reader to fill in the blanks; readers' own imagination is an important element. So if the characters are undeveloped but the worldbuilding is superb, the reader supplies what the story lacks.
- acabal 9y agoI've been running one of the largest writing communities online for many years now, and the first thing I always tell writers when they say they want to self-publish, is that after the novel is done, then your work is only just beginning. Marketing is just as, if not maybe even more, important than actually completing a saleable novel. Unfortunately like many of us, writers are usually only interested in their specialty--writing--and so find marketing difficult and tiresome. Lots of great novels have languished due to an author's disinterest in marketing. Likewise lots of mediocre or bad novels have succeeded thanks to clever and diligent marketing. This is one of the many reasons why self-publishing will never overthrow the big publishing houses, like so many people predicted a decade ago. The fact is that going from manuscript to financial success involves lots of different skills that most authors just haven't been trained for, like cover design, copyediting, printing, and marketing. In the traditional arrangement, publishing houses do all of that non-writerly work for the author in exchange for a profit share. One can self-publish and keep all the profits, but most writers don't understand that that also means you must also be a pro-level cover artist, copyeditor, printing expert, and marketer (or have the money to hire them yourself). (There are other good reasons why publishing houses aren't going away anytime soon despite technologist's frenzied predictions, this is just one of them.)
- WalterBright 9y agoThis is true in any endeavor. I see it all the time in software, for example. Great products languishing because the author couldn't be bothered to do marketing, and crummy ones becoming hits because of adroit marketing.
- ohjeez 9y agoNot just disinterest, but competence. The skills that make you a good writer are very different than the skills that make you a good marketer. My brother in law, whom I love dearly, self-published a novel. He's gone to all sorts of local fairs in order to sell it. But when I ask him for the elevator pitch, he can't give one. I've listened to him talk about it, and he can't even get ME interested in reading it.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI was once at a reading by a famous writer, don't remember the name. When asked what the secret was to be a bestselling author he asked people to take a close look at the word "bestseller". There is a reason why it's not called "bestwriter".
- cableshaft 9y agoBecause there's a clear, objective metric you can use measure how well something sells (how many books were sold) but no clear, objective metric you can use to determine the quality of a writer?
- maxxxxx 9y agoI think he meant it in the sense that he didn't just write the book but also sold it.
- exolymph 9y agoHands down it's marketing, with a side of product-market fit. The latter was part of why Twilight and then Fifty Shades of Grey exploded. Product-market fit for a book relies more on engagingness, and pressing the right buttons of a certain demographic, than it does on literary or academic measures of quality (which are subjective, of course).
- CM30 9y agoTo be honest, you can be pretty damn awful as a writer and still become successful if you write what people want to hear. Lots of terrible books sell really well because they were well marketed and offered people a sort of escapism that they wanted at any cost. And if you want a non book example, well just look at many news sites. From those fake news pages complained about in the election to all matter of niche ones and even mainstream publications, there are quite a few utterly terrible stories that have become hugely popular simply because they published at the right time and got the interest of an audience who wanted to hear exactly that.