4 ms·
There is a docking ring on JWST, so it could be reboosted to a proper orbit if there's a problem with the launch. A Dragon spacecraft (which will launch uncrew
by Robotbeat 9y ago
There is a docking ring on JWST, so it could be reboosted to a proper orbit if there's a problem with the launch.
A Dragon spacecraft (which will launch uncrewed with a docking capability sometime this year) or just some satellite bus with an NDS docking ring, should be capable of boosting it if there's a minor performance shortfall like this launch. $150 million, I would guess, would be the cost to address a minor performance shortfall like this. That's not too bad since JWST is a $10 billion spacecraft.
It should be pointed out that the electric-propulsion-equipped spacecraft actually launched will have no trouble reaching the correct orbit, it'll just take 4 weeks longer than planned.
The performance shortfall, based on guesses of the electric propulsion performance and the 4 weeks delay, is probably around 50 to 100m/s. JWST has a budget of around 150m/s, so JWST would, in principle, be capable of moving itself to its planned orbit, but this would signficantly impact its on-orbit lifetime (or require fancy mission planning... I'm always impressed by how clever mission planners can squeeze water from a rock when a problem like this occurs).
So JWST itself may actually have enough propellant in case this problem occurred again, and there is a docking ring on JWST that could, in principle, be used for reboosting it.
It should be pointed out that there was a similar problem with an AtlasV-Cygnus launch in 2016, but the payload was going to a low-energy orbit, so the rocket happened to have enough performance margin that it didn't affect the mission. But if the payload had used the full capacity of Atlas V (like this Ariane 5 launch), it would've been a similar performance shortfall.
Bottom line: no launch vehicle is perfect, not even Ariane 5 or Atlas V. But payload can make up minor performance shortfalls.
- Robotbeat 9y agoNote: based on the actually achieved apogee and perigee and inclination, it seems that the performance shortfall may be closer to 300 to 400m/s, which would make rescue much harder, except if you used electric propulsion. Luckily, the spacecraft have electric propulsion (but JWST doesn't...).
- JshWright 9y ago> There is a docking ring on JWST, so it could be reboosted to a proper orbit if there's a problem with the launch. Is the JWST designed to accommodate thrust along the axis of the docking ring?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoApply less thrust. It survived assembly, transport and launch. Everything costs money to put into space. You don't just attach a big heavy docking ring with scotch tape. You put is somewhere that material and strength can be useful. With the safety factors involved (wouldn't want to brick a billion dollar spacecraft because you came in a few mm/sec too hot) it makes the most sense to put the docking ring somewhere structurally significant.
- JshWright 9y agoIt's not just a matter of how much thrust... It's also the direction of the thrust relative to the center of mass of the spacecraft... (it doesn't do you any good if the thrust you apply just induces a spin)