3 ms·
A key part of that problem is that you can't vote against closure. Only after a question has accrued sufficient votes to close it can you start voting to open i
by barrkel 16y ago
A key part of that problem is that you can't vote against closure. Only after a question has accrued sufficient votes to close it can you start voting to open it again; it's a ratcheting flip-flop.
But it appears Jeff is oddly against this issue:
http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/915/can-we-have-the-ability-to-rescind-a-close-vote-before-it-closes/33949#33949 http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/915/can-we-have-the-...
http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/125/how-about-a-vote-not-to-close-option-to-counter-the-vote-to-close/33950#33950 http://meta.stackoverflow.com/questions/125/how-about-a-vote...
Heavily outvoted by the community, he persists in obduracy.
- AndrejM 16y agoInteresting. I kept seeing some topics opened, closed, only to be reopened again. I thought the admins couldn't make up their minds.
- alextgordon 16y agoI'm not sure I like the present system or proposed solution. You'd then have four ways to vote: * Vote question up * Vote question down * Vote to close * Vote not to close Why not simply close based on downvotes? Or remove downvotes and close algorithmically based on "flags", like we have on HN.
- j_baker 16y agoThe ratcheting flip-flop is the best-case scenario for when a question is popular enough for some people to stick around and keep it open. Most of the time, closure is a death warrant for a question. I've seen some real "diamonds in the rough" closed because of this.