3 ms·
Facebook and Google both have histories of actively shaping user behaviour and directing attention which are very problematic. I definitely agree with that. Par
by simonh 9y ago
Facebook and Google both have histories of actively shaping user behaviour and directing attention which are very problematic. I definitely agree with that. Particularly Facebook, which seems much more aggressive and tone deaf in that regard. It’s a problem that I think is a legitimate area for regulation or at least oversight combined with voluntary restraint, because users are being deceived. They should at least know how their attention is being directed and have some controls over it.
I don’t agree that treating them as utilities is going to foster innovation. Really? Utilities are examples of innovation? Both Google and Facebook are still highly innovative companies, that’s how they created and consolidated their positions. They key is that the future success of their innovations should be based on merit versus other innovative companies, rather than based on leveraging their current market strength in anticompetitive ways.
This is all really hard to do. There is just as much threat that clumsy regulation will stifle innovation, fossilize market positions and increase costs as there is that lack of regulation will lead to abuses by these companies. It’s good that this issue is being debated, but I don’t think anyone has good answers yet.
- gaius 9y agoUtilities are examples of innovation? It’s funny, I take streaming 4k from Netflix totally for granted but I am genuinely impressed by the way natural gas and fresh drinking water appear in my house as if by magic.
- rrmm 9y agoAnd urban life as we know it would be impossible without sewage and sanitation services.
- thisacctforreal 9y agoWe've had that technology since Rome. I think it's fair to say most current internet and cable monopolies have been dragging their feet on upgrades, and even actively resisting innovation.
- vanderZwan 9y ago> We've had that technology since Rome. No, the Romans did, through their government. Then it all disappeared until the last century, when governments brought them back.
- simonh 9y agoSure, but it’s more important that they be reliable than innovative. Remember the 80s when people thought that online services would be provided by information utilities? Imagine if the internet still didn’t exist, and your choice for external connectivity was between AOL and Compuserve. But hey, at least thyou bits and bytes would come gushing into your house right on tap.
- Boothroid 9y agoI've worked with a number of utilities here in the UK and they are pioneering in their use of technology, to the extent that in one example a power company had reached the limits of a particular piece of software that I was supporting, and thus the US creator of the software was forced to patch it - it was originally built for the US market and US networks are smaller, and so when the whole of a UK country was thrown at it it puked. Another example was a multivariate GIS analysis that combined historic weather data with soil type, slope, tree height, type and distance from powerline etc to estimate risk to power supplies from trees falling onto power lines as a consequence of extreme weather events. Yet another example is route planning for national grid interconnects, including analyses of potential sea bed routes based on hydrographic data. There's so much stuff going on in the background that you only become aware of if you have a reason to.