5 ms·
So, I personally would consider electric for my next car, due 2025 if my current car lasts 10 years. That's overall my goal for car replacements: once per decad
by dragontamer 9y ago
So, I personally would consider electric for my next car, due 2025 if my current car lasts 10 years. That's overall my goal for car replacements: once per decade (or longer).
However, I have friends who lease cars, because they always want the latest and greatest. Others, who are a bit less savvy with their money, simply sell their cars (for a significant loss) and buy something new every 3 or 4 years. Still others crash their cars and need a new one.
Which brings up the question: if an Electric Vehicle saves $650/year, maybe $800/year once you include 2x oil changes + misc expenses per year, then an Electric Vehicle only breaks even (over a period of 10 years) if its within $8000 of the ICE car.
That's my case: where I hold the car for 10 years. The "big" maintenance items: engine rebuilds or whatnot, don't seem to be necessary in the first 10 years of a modern car's life anymore. Tires are the next most expensive thing, but electric cars also need their tires replaced.
If you're one of my friends who NEEDS a new car all the time (for some... reason...), then even a $2400 premium would be too costly and it'd be better to buy ICE.
- aphextron 9y ago>If you're one of my friends who NEEDS a new car all the time (for some... reason...), then even a $2400 premium would be too costly and it'd be better to buy ICE. It will not be a premium by 2025. EV's right now are where hybrids were at in 2005, and in 2025 they will be where hybrids are at now in terms of market share. It will become a normal, sensible choice for people buying a new small car. Cheap (<$20k) EV's with 200+ mile range will be commonplace within 5 years. Lithium battery prices have fallen by an order of magnitude over the past 10 years, to below $140/kWh, and it's projected to cut that almost in half by 2025. At that price, something with similar capabilities to a current generation Nissan Leaf will sell for around $15-20k new. And with the battery being the only meaningful component which can degrade, cars will now last decades in dry climates with zero maintenance, perhaps needing a battery switch at 10 year intervals.
- singingboyo 9y agoThis only works if EVs can be charged easily, everywhere. That is not currently the case, and given that I currently see no planning around this, I don't expect it to be the case by 2025 either. I briefly (very briefly) considered either a plugin hybrid or a full-electric vehicle. However, I can't charge anywhere - and that's a deal breaker. In 8 years, there will probably be somewhere I can charge, but not easily, and not without thinking about it ahead of time. EVs may reach the point of economic viability, but the lack of infrastructure sure looks like it will drag down their market share.
- dragontamer 9y agoBy "Electric" btw, my current expectation for 2025 is that I'll buy a plug-in Hybrid at that time. I can charge at home / go to work each day, but then use the gas station for longer drives. IE: Volt or Prius have this sort of functionality. And surely newer vehicles (by 2025) will also support a similar use case. Tech probably will get better, but in my experience, long-term predictions tend to be overly optimistic. Fusion has been 10 years away for 50 years, electric cars too have been overly optimistic for quite some time. ($35,000 Model 3 doesn't exist yet. Only high-end ones as Tesla hasn't figured out the kinks yet, despite "launching" last August) Sometimes tech advances more quickly than expected (ie: high-speed internet). So if a very widespread electric network were built (and no, Tesla's supercharger isn't there yet for my use cases), then I might consider a pure electric vehicle at that time. But 2025 is a long ways away, so its something I'll just have to evaluate each year up to that point.
- mywittyname 9y ago> $35,000 Model 3 doesn't exist yet. The Bolt exists! It's not trendy or sexy, but it's an EV for the masses.
- dragontamer 9y agoIf I were to crash my car today and have to buy a new car... I'd probably get the Volt actually. I feel like the design tradeoffs on the Volt are a bit better for "mass market". The Bolt is still a good design though. Of course, I'm not planning on getting a car for another 7 years. So its a bit of a hypothetical. My statement about the Model3 is more about the overall optimism and poor predictions in general. I guess the Bolt is a surprise however: that GM could ramp up a pure electric vehicle so quickly. Its hard to say. 7 years is a long time. But the general rule of Science Fiction remains true: 90% of everything will remain the same. Only 10% of the world really changes per decade.
- rbanffy 9y agoPure EVs will be cheaper simply because they are easier to build. Wheel-attached motors drive costs down significantly, removing hundreds of manufacturing steps.
- mywittyname 9y ago> And with the battery being the only meaningful component which can degrade I don't think this has been proven yet. Starting from a stop causes a lot of stress on electric motors and commercial electric motors operating hours are usually guaranteed when the number of starts per hour are below some threshold. Telsa had a lot of issues with drive unit failures. I imagine they are working on a solution to this, but I don't see any reason to think that EVs are going to be super reliable right out of the gate. That being said, replacing a drive unit seems to be an order of magnitude easier than replacing a drive component in an ICE. So even if they end up lasting 80k miles, it might not be that big of a deal.
- davidgould 9y ago> Starting from a stop causes a lot of stress on electric motors and commercial electric motors operating hours are usually guaranteed when the number of starts per hour are below some threshold. Do you have a source for this that would apply to AC or PMDC motors with variable frequency drives as are applied to vehicles? I think your claim might only apply to old-school designs with starting/running capacitors.
- ZeroGravitas 9y agoThere was a study released in December that suggests EVs are already cheaper over 4 years ownership in the US, UK and Japan. Note this includes government subsidies.