3 ms·
This has beautiful explanatory power for leftist opposition to market-rate housing development. It explains the arguments I tend to see very well: - The effect
by closeparen 9y ago
This has beautiful explanatory power for leftist opposition to market-rate housing development. It explains the arguments I tend to see very well:
- The effect of supply and demand on price (“trickle down economics”) is an oversimplification or outright fabrication pushed by real estate and tech interests to fool you. Those technocrats are funded by monied interests and can’t be trusted.
- We cannot depend on the market to provide something as important as housing; it must be a human right. Therefore block all market rate development. (With no follow-up policy prescription, or no concern for the feasibility, implementation details, or side effects of any housing-as-a-human-right policy prescriptions).
- We should continue to block development because YIMBYs and their backers are bad people and our class enemies who want luxury condos for themselves and don’t care about the poor.
- Even if some YIMBYs are well intentioned, it’s stupid that they want to debate supply and demand with affordable housing activists when they should be allying against their mutual enemy, rich suburban homeowners. This is most interesting because it’s a direct exhortation to abandon mistake theory and engage on conflict theory’s terms.
I like this a lot. It may be what I needed to stop arguing with these people on the internet.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>I like this a lot. It may be what I needed to stop arguing with these people on the internet. Why would it cause you to stop arguing with them? It enables you to argue with them more effectively, not opt out entirely.
- dibujante 9y agoDo you live in Vancouver, perhaps? This is exactly what our housing debate is.