4 ms·
Here we go again. Race correlates strongly with socioeconomic background. Insofar as diversity initiatives are actually attempting to improve the lives of disa
by woodruffw 9y ago
Here we go again.
Race correlates strongly with socioeconomic background. Insofar as diversity initiatives are actually attempting to improve the lives of disadvantaged people in this country, arguments like yours amount to relative privation.
Heart disease kills more people than lung cancer, but there's nothing wrong with raising money to research lung cancer.
- simonsarris 9y ago> Race correlates strongly with socioeconomic background. Yeah all he's saying is that socioeconomic background correlates even more strongly with socioeconomic background. And keeping it in economic terms has the additional plus of keeping the correlation consistent as times change.
- woodruffw 9y agoSorry for the late response. > Yeah all he's saying is that socioeconomic background correlates even more strongly with socioeconomic background. This is a reasonable observation, but the ought that's implicit in it is not. Heart disease correlates more strongly with death than lung cancer; does that mean it's wrong in some sense to donate to lung cancer research over heart disease? To make my opinion more material: individuals have the right to make independent decisions within a broad moral framework. It's not wrong for individuals to personalize the good they do (in this case, in the form of racial justice) so long as what they're doing really is good.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- badwulf 9y ago> Race correlates strongly with socioeconomic background. If it correlates strongly, then why not just ignore race and look at socioeconomic background instead? > disadvantaged people in this country They are helping only a specific subset of "disadvantaged people in this country". > Heart disease kills more people than lung cancer, but there's nothing wrong with raising money to research lung cancer. A better analogy would be: smoking increases your chance for cancer, instead of saying smoking is bad in general you say that certain cigarette brands are bad.
- woodruffw 9y agoI'm going to post this as a reply with the poster elided, since they deleted it and I think it's important: >> Heart disease kills more people than lung cancer, but there's nothing wrong with raising money to research lung cancer. > The difference is that face of diversity initiatives are zero sum. No, they are not. Hiring someone from a disadvantaged group does not mean that you have to fire someone from a privileged group. That is what a zero-sum scenario would require. Diversity initiatives level the playing field by increasing opportunities for one group relative to another. That doesn't necessarily mean that the disadvantaged group has more opportunities than the privileged group -- it only means that they have more than they did before.
- cdoxsey 9y ago> No, they are not. Hiring someone from a disadvantaged group does not mean that you have to fire someone from a privileged group. That is what a zero-sum scenario would require. No it requires not hiring the privileged group. If you are hiring 1000 employees, and 10000 applied, and you've ranked them in some way, adding "diversity" to the equation means the ranking comes out different. Ranked potential employee 1307 using the pre-diversity standard, becomes employee 904 under the post-diversity standard. But to move up that ranking, by definition, other people had to be moved out of the way. Maybe potential employee 1000, who only barely squeaked by, is now potential employee 1012, and so doesn't make the cut. This is exactly what happens at universities.
- cobookman 9y agoI just don’t buy that. Not every company has infinite head count. Universities for example only have so many spots they can offer. So if a university keeps 10% of the spots for diversity candidates, then only 90% of the capacity is for diversity candidates. Compounded with non diversity candidates applying in a disproportionately high number to diversity. And the population of non diverse having a better education. You end up making it harder for non diverse candidates and raising their bar.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>You end up making it harder for non diverse candidates and raising their bar. You're right but that's fine. The argument though is that society has already imposed a 'higher bar' on "diverse candidates" (let's just be honest and call them minorities and the poor.) Think of it like this. A poor black girl named Keycia lives at home with her single mother and three siblings. She's studious but attends a bad public school, she works after school to help out at home, she takes care of her little brothers and sisters. Now compare to Chad, a white boy from an upper middle class family. He's also studious and also attends a public school but a good one with AP/IB classes, dual credit and so on. He doesn't work but he does play on one of the best lacrosse teams in the state and also swims. All of which is to say it's two kids both working hard. Now, even with diversity initiatives, who's got a better chance of getting into Stanford? Hell who's got a better chance of getting into Iowa State? Or even being able to attend? Diversity initiatives exist to put these two kids on even ground. That's what equality of opportunity means.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- koheripbal 9y agoI think this misses the point that we are using our dollars inefficiently. Between race and socio-economic status, the later has a stronger correlation to health and so it should be used as the main indicator directing where/how to spend those healthcare dollars. When it comes to people's health, these dollars need to be blind, or we are needlessly throwing some number of lives away each year.