3 ms·
> Those researchers also designed a simple predictive model using only two factors as inputs: age and number of previous convictions. By comparison, COMPAS uses
by AnthonyMouse 9y ago
> Those researchers also designed a simple predictive model using only two factors as inputs: age and number of previous convictions. By comparison, COMPAS uses more than a hundred. To me, it doesn't sound like those extra factors end up contributing much.
That's the nature of these things. If you use zero factors then you're basing decisions on random chance. Use one good factor and you'll do 60% better than random chance. Add another good factor and you'll do another 10% better. Every factor after that is a single digit improvement.
Because once you have something pretty good, making it even better is diminishing returns. But at the same time, "it's only 1% more accurate that way" when you're dealing with country-sized populations will change the outcome for many thousands of people.
And how does using fewer factors help anything? The underlying "problem" is that people of different races have different outcomes in actual fact, and any halfway accurate predictive algorithm will reflect that difference. It's not as if there is no racial disparity in the number of previous convictions.
If anything, using fewer factors could make the problem worse because it stops considering potential mitigating factors. A young black man with two prior convictions gets the shaft even if he has recently gotten married and bought a house in a better neighborhood.