2 ms·
While I agree with your general point, artificial neural networks and biological neural networks are sufficiently different that it's not really fair to compare
by adrianN 9y ago
While I agree with your general point, artificial neural networks and biological neural networks are sufficiently different that it's not really fair to compare them just because they happen to have the same name. A biological neuron does a lot more than computing some affine transformation of its inputs.
Also, humans draw from an absurdly complex pool of inputs, usually called "common knowledge", that so far has given us a hard time when trying to replicate it in computer systems. So while in principle there is, imho, nothing stopping a statistical method to produce decisions at least as good as a human could, in practice this might not be the case.
- noobermin 9y agoTo expand on your point to further strengthen your original argument, these models are trained on a smaller subset of observables and ideas we consider when we decide policy. Even then, the comparison between a matrix and a human brain is poor. Another issue I have is that we don't know is whether statistical bias exists in the metrics they train on, something they discuss in the paper. We already know for example blacks are arrested and convicted harsher than whites for some of the similar crimes[0]. The paper just says that COMPAS predicts likelihood of violent crime, not whether that means they'll be arrested of crime. Moreover while Table 1 talks about a prediction regarding violent crime, Figure 2 talks about recidivism with regards to all crime, so which is it? It still seems nebulous to me what COMPAS actually is for. I'd have to read it deeper than I have, but not sure how I feel about the paper. [0] http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/feb/26/hillary-clinton/hillary-clinton-says-blacks-more-likely-be-arreste/ http://www.politifact.com/truth-o-meter/statements/2016/feb/...