3 ms·
The easiest way to talk about evolution is talking about purpose and desires as if it were a conscious being. Of course this is not true but there just aren't
by colechristensen 9y ago
The easiest way to talk about evolution is talking about purpose and desires as if it were a conscious being.
Of course this is not true but there just aren't words in English for the subtle and specific concepts involved. Correctly communicating the concepts with our clumsy language requires stumbling around and turning concise ideas into difficult to understand monsters.
When you are talking about evolutionary purpose, you're actually talking about the set of cause and effect pressures that lead to the effect.
The human tailbone is less purposeful than the hair because we can reason fairly easily that the loss of hair would decrease fitness in some very believable situations. The loss of a tailbone we can't seem to think of any fitness changes.
We have both hair and a tailbone. There _is_ evolutionary pressure to keep hair, although not extreme pressure as there's quite a bit of variability. There is not much evolutionary pressure to have or get rid of a tailbone. In order for there to be a change there has to be a path of mutations that survives and grows in a population. There probably A) isn't an easy path of mutations to get rid of the tailbone and B) isn't a meaningful cost to grow and maintain one. Those two things put together make lack of purpose. It's there, but doesn't really make a difference and isn't easily changed.