4 ms·
The whole thing where people insist on copyright for worship songs has bothered me for years. I understand that composers and artists need to get paid, and I'm
by geofft 9y ago
The whole thing where people insist on copyright for worship songs has bothered me for years. I understand that composers and artists need to get paid, and I'm certainly fine with enforcing copyright for recordings, but the whole idea behind this particular style of worship music is that the songs are easy to memorize and teach orally. It's one thing if you're, say, dc Talk and people learn your lyrics because they're listening to your albums a lot, it's quite another if you're, say, Hillsong and you go out of your way to write melodies and lyrics are easily learnable, and then you (or your agent, I guess) says that you may not distribute written copies of the lyrics.
I've sort of wondered whether writing a bunch of Creative Commons-licensed worship music and trying to make it popular would be a good way to solve this problem.
- peterburkimsher 9y agoPlease write that Creative Commons-licensed music! I'm also looking more into the old hymns, which are probably out of copyright by now, and also have translations. Another thing I noticed is that many worship songs use all the same words [1]. Therefore I'm considering making my own (illegal) translations, and talking about those with my Chinese tutor every week. I could then upload it with Pingtype English (which does English->Chinese translation) as a way for people to learn English. If it's my own translation, at least my friends from the prayer room won't cause trouble for me when I share it - only the original authors. And then I'd just take it down if someone really does send me a DMCA. [1] See this video for a humorous take on this: How to Write a Worship Song (In 5 Minutes or Less) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GhYuA0Cz8ls https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GhYuA0Cz8ls
- analog31 9y agoFortunately, the only worship songs I've ever really enjoyed were out of copyright by at least 200 years, and typically sung in Latin. ;-) But interestingly, people have talked about creating public domain or free use literature for live music performance. A friend of mine tried to do this. He had the idea to create his own book of tunes (it helps that he's a composer with a music theory degree) so he could book a band into venues that didn't have ASCAP/BMI licenses. This was in the jazz genre, rather than worship music. I'm a jazz musician. He told me that despite being completely above board, the venues still received a threatening visit from the performance rights organizations, and were talked out of hosting live music.
- cafard 9y agoI don't wholly disagree with you on the Latin. But indeed everything the Wesleys did is long out of copyright; the American Sacred Harp and Southern Harmony hymns are long out of copyright.
- LeifCarrotson 9y agoI think your problem will be that CCLI is good enough for most people. It would be like producing Creative Commons videos because you can't get Netflix or Youtube. Sure, it will help you and people in your situation...but most of the world already has easy access. I found this bit from Wikipedia interesting: > CCLI has expanded around the world to Australia, Botswana, Canada, Denmark, Faroe Islands, Finland, Germany, Iceland, Ireland, Lesotho, Malawi, Namibia, Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Singapore, South Africa, Swaziland, Sweden, Switzerland, United Kingdom, Zimbabwe, South Korea and as of 2016 can now serve most countries. That's a few countries, and covers most of the big English-speaking ones (yes, India and China are not on the list and have more English speakers than many of the smaller countries) but in what way is that "most countries"?
- loco5niner 9y agoIn 2016, CCLI updated their agreements to allow "most countries" "Our new agreements with the song owners now enable CCLI to make its resources available to churches in every country." From: https://us.ccli.com/ccli-news/giving-honor-where-honor-is-due/ https://us.ccli.com/ccli-news/giving-honor-where-honor-is-du...
- peterburkimsher 9y agoInstead of taking that quote out of context, here's the rest. "Our new agreements with the song owners now enable CCLI to make its resources available to churches in every country. We are currently developing our website to accommodate servicing churches everywhere. And, we anticipate having CCLI Service Centers in India and China over the next several years." What it means is "in every country [where CCLI operates]". There is no CCLI in India or China yet, and no plans for Taiwan (Taiwan is not China! But that's another debate.)
- loco5niner 9y ago> Instead of taking that quote out of context, here's the rest. I don't think my quote is out of context. > What it means is "in every country [where CCLI operates]". The second sentence in your quote references the __websites__ ability to service churches in every country. The new agreement allows CCLI to operate in EVERY country, even if CCLI does not YET operate there. That means when CCLI is ready to operate in a new country the new agreement will allow them to do this.
- natecavanaugh 9y agoIt's bothered me a lot too, given the evangelistic aspect to it. I think focusing on a CC licence could work, but I always loved John Piper's revenue deal: I believe 100% of the profit goes straight to his foundation. I think that creation, when the artist has a patron, can accomplish much more than on their own. But on the flip side, Christians (have a duty to fund work like this that they enjoy, and helps them exist). Maybe something like GK Chesterton's economic theory of distributism: All property is shared (the music), but the means is distribute is wide. Maybe perhaps a 1year exclusivity, the put in the CC to be alternates, made new, etc. Just my opinion though