6 ms·
The Stock Market Is Still for Suckers
- karanbhangui 16y agoI stopped reading when the author said everyone wants stocks to go up. You can make money no matter what direction the market goes. A brief skim of the rest of the article finds similar errors. The OP doesn't seem to understand the basics of asset allocation and diversity.
- FreeRadical 16y agoOr dividend income
- revorad 16y agoWhat stocks are paying good dividends now (or likely to in the future)? (honest question)
- larrykubin 16y agoVerizon (VZ) and AT&T (T) have been paying > 6 percent dividends.
- Symmetry 16y agoGenerally, any company that is doing ok and isn't trying to expand quickly.
- whakojacko 16y agokeep up on this blog: http://www.dividendgrowthinvestor.com/ http://www.dividendgrowthinvestor.com/
- jodrellblank 16y agoBP were until the gulf oil leak, and might go back to doing so.
- fanboy123 16y agotechnically he said people buy stocks because they think stocks will increase in value. it is an useless/obvious observation but different from what you stated. like cuban i do wonder why individuals think they can beat the market. well connected and well capitalized groups have access to far more information than is publicly available. with the rise of hft and the like not only are you under attack by players who understand the fundamentals better but also by people who can game the exchange platforms themselves.
- yoseph 16y agoI agree the odds are stacked against the individual investor. However, I'm an individual investor who consistently beats the market. I don't do anything special. I just follow the tenets of value investing. IMHO, this is the only way to invest as an individual. Otherwise, stick your money in an index fund and hope for the best.
- Symmetry 16y agoYou don't need to know more than the other market participants to do well in the stock market, you just need to know one thing that other people don't (assuming your investment is a tiny fraction of the money in the stocks you pick). You should always expect that all the information on a product that is accessible to Wallstreet traders is already factored into a stocks price, but there may be things (does this product really make sense for someone like me who lives in a small appartment, how will this inovation interact with the stuff I learned in all those technical courses I took in college) that you might better information about than the market makers. Of course, it might just be that random chance has caused the author of the post to do badly in the market and me to do well - causing us both to be biased. You should always diversify your investing and its probably a good idea to put most of your stock money into index funds.
- joshfraser 16y agomark cuban is a smart guy & also a billionaire so i tend to listen to his advice. the part i don't get is why we should be putting our money in the bank. our government is printing money at a record pace and our money is being devalued by the minute. as much as i hate having my money in the stock market, at least it has some protection against inflation.
- mikebo 16y agoDespite quantitative easing, we haven't experienced any significant inflation. In fact, we are getting very close to a deflation. If you have a very pessimistic view of the stock market's future, reducing risk by being in cash make a lot of sense.
- joshfraser 16y agothat's partly because the fed plays all sorts of tricks to hide the real amount of inflation they are causing. regardless of whether that inflation is visible now, it's inevitably coming. it's the only option we have to deal with that 13.3 trillion debt that we can't afford to pay.
- mikebo 16y agoInflation will be an issue at some point in the future, but with high unemployment I don't think it's likely for several years. If you're risk averse, broader market decline is a bigger worry than inflation IMO.
- kargdt 16y agoI heard somewhere that Deflation right now is a fact, inflation a belief. One would've lost a lot of money being short long-dated treasuries this year with that belief. If inflation is the answer to this (most likely the case), would you say that it could be hyperinflation versus the milder demand-driven inflation that America is used to?- Specifically, if the Fed devalues the dollar.
- riffer 16y ago
- david927 16y agoI agree. We're about to face a huge liquidity crisis for additional reasons that he missed here. In the very near future, cash (different currencies, precious metals) will be king.
- lzw 16y agoThe indicator that gold, etc is not overpriced is that in 2008 when everyone panicked, gold went down cause they sold it. When everyone panics, and gold goes up, that will be the beginning of the bull market in gold.
- c00p3r 16y agoif you were the innovator that was smarter and faster than the other guys, you could make money [on the long and / or short side of the market] before the imitators and then the idiots flooded the market. - That seems to be a market universal. Same shit happens with Blogs, SEO and Internet in general.
- dmillar 16y agoAren't we already closer to "blood in the streets" than "cheery consensus"? Financial people love to say that the stock market grows at roughly 9% historically, and that is money in the bank. But if you look at any historic chart these days, the massive amount of wealth and trading volume that has been generated over the past 10 years has made it obvious that we are in uncharted waters for future equities growth. The Internet has been the game changer here. It has allowed access to equities to a class of investors that really never had access purchase these types of assets. This changed the game. Cuban is probably right when he tells us to be weary of the market, but I think there are different reasons to be weary than those he states.
- mikebo 16y agoI think Cuban is comparing vs the March '09 low when the market was down 40% from now. He made several posts during that time about actual purchasing stocks.
- dmillar 16y agoRight, it was a great time to buy. I do tend to think that we will see DOW 14000 before DOW 7000, barring some unforeseen crisis. And I guess that's market confidence, right? What investors think the chances of something unforeseen popping up are.
- lzw 16y agoOf course because the more the dollar is devalued via inflation, the hugger stock prices will go even though they aren't actually appreciating in value.
- cynicalkane 16y agoEquities have been growing just fine. It's just that their market prices haven't been. The 10-year average earnings of publicly traded stocks--a rough but decent indicator of value--are quite a bit higher (70%, IIRC) than they were 10 years ago. The lesson is not to avoid the stock market, but to avoid overpriced stocks.
- yoseph 16y ago"It is pretty much impossible for some man or woman or child who devotes a couple of hours per week to the market to outperform the professionals who spend 24×7 doing this for a living and when they are asleep, they have a workforce full of people doing more of the same. In this day and age, none of us are smarter than the market." I agree that individual investors can't continue to try and play in the big leagues. When you're competing with bankers, you're going to lose because they're doing it 24/7, like Mark said. However, there is a significant amount of the market (30%? Tried to google the figure and couldn't find it) that Wall Street doesn't cover, analyze or do much of anything about. For the most part, this is the playing field for the individual investor. My only other advice is buy at a profit. Use value investing tenets to buy stocks that are significantly discounted to their fair value. It's much easier to calculate the value of a company than most think.
- kd0amg 16y agoHowever, there is a significant amount of the market (30%? Tried to google the figure and couldn't find it) that Wall Street doesn't cover, analyze or do much of anything about. For the most part, this is the playing field for the individual investor. Is "a couple of hours per week" enough to do the research necessary to perform well in that area?
- jakarta 16y agoThis is a weak article. There are plenty of ways to beat the market averages while being just one individual with a small sum of capital. A while back Buffett said that he thinks he could average 50% annually if he only had a small sum of capital. Here are some of the things he would likely be doing: 1. Go where the big investors can't Many large institutional fund managers cannot go below certain market caps. Typically you can find a rich hunting ground of undervalued and ignored companies below $100M. During the crisis I found it pretty useful to actually screen for negative enterprise value stocks. These were companies where they were trading BELOW the cash they had on their balance sheets. (EV = Market Cap + Debt - Cash). Some of these companies were pretty tiny, $10 to $50M mkt cap, but they worked out well. You have to be willing to deal with illiquidity though. 2. Odd lot tender offers You can find situations where a company wants to go private and delist. To do that they need to buy out shareholders and get below 300 public shareholders. To do that sometimes they will pay a premium for you to tender shares if you have below 100 shares. Again, this is an area where a small investor can do well but where large institutions are precluded from being active. 3. Look for areas where institutions are forced to sell Spinoffs are the classic example. Academic research has shown that spinoffs will in general outperform the greater market. Why? Many index funds are mandated to only hold stocks that are a part of the index. Sometimes an index member will spinoff a smaller unit which cannot make it into the index. The index funds will be forced to sell that company and so its pricing may get below its actual value. That's why spinoffs tend to outperform the market in their 2nd and 3rd year of trading. --- There are plenty of other areas too. These are just a few but it is all pretty well publicized.
- Femur 16y agoFascinating. I imagine you are ludicrously rich via these obvious and well-publicized methods? How long did it take you to learn and implement these tactics? I would also love to see pictures of your yacht and/or Mansion.
- Kliment 16y agoYou will notice he/she is quoting someone who did in fact become fairly rich, and not speaking from first-hand experience.
- sage_joch 16y ago"Because people buy stocks for only one reason, they want them to go up in price." Actually I've been buying them for their dividends, with the hope that the stock price itself will just keep pace with inflation.
- richardw 16y agoAgreed. A stock is a business and you're buying into it. It's a pity all the news is oriented around the trading aspect. I both invest and trade, but I consider them different activities. Many don't.
- tkahn6 16y agoWhen I was younger, I could never understand the purpose of stocks that don't give off dividends. I just could not wrap my head around the concept of buying something for the sole purpose of expecting it to increase in value. It still boggles my mind.
- vomjom 16y agoAt least in economic theory, a company does not give out dividends if it believes that it can get a better return on its cash (in terms of profit) than the investor can in the overall market. But, companies must eventually give out dividends. There's a certain point at which the company's cash hoard gets so large that investors become unhappy (see Microsoft).
- afusiak 16y agoStock buybacks are an excellent alternative to providing dividends for a company that wants to return money back to it's owners.
- dirtae 16y agoYes, theoretically. In practice, managements have a long history of buying stock back at inflated prices and buying back stock simply to hide the shareholder dilution that is occurring due to management equity compensation. I prefer dividends to buybacks. Companies tend to announce buybacks when things are going well and their stock is fully priced. How many companies were announcing buybacks in December 2008 when it would have really made sense?
- hop 16y agoBolshevism. An S&P 500 index will crush any bond, CD, whatever, over the next 20 years. When you are investing long term, the ups and downs and whatever volatility traders and hedge funds cause do not matter, you are still owning a piece of the company that on average will grow exponentially in value. With inflation on the horizon, stocks are a way better hedge than cash or bonds. And that said, if you go hunting for value and well priced stocks, you will be way better off.
- jeberle 16y agoLooking back to 1971, for any 20 year period the S&P 500 netted a gain. For the last 20 years, that gain was 6% per year. OK, but not what I would term "crushing" performance. For the last 10 years, the S&P 500 is down 2.5% on an annual basis. You could have done better w/ govt bonds & CD ladders. I think the 20 year plan assumes a greater will power than the greater investing community possesses.
- illumin8 16y agoRight, you can cherry pick 10 year periods of time when the S&P did good, but don't forget about all those times it crashed. The problem with following Wall Streets advice to put all your money in stocks is that they make too much money from trading commissions to trust them for impartial advice. Typical investment advisors tell you to buy stocks and then point out that over the last century stocks have done very well. The problem is that none of us are investing on 100 year long timelines. We are usually investing on 30-40 year timelines and hoping to have a good amount saved when we retire. If you happen to need to retire and start pulling money out in a bad year like 2008, you're screwed. Check out this allocation for returns as good as stocks without the huge downside risk: http://crawlingroad.com/blog/2008/12/22/permanent-portfolio-historical-returns/ http://crawlingroad.com/blog/2008/12/22/permanent-portfolio-...
- Unosolo 16y agoS&P 500 today is not made up of the same companies as back in 1971. The 6% annual growth excludes any companies didn't do well and were delisted or got wiped out (100% loss of investment).
- whyme 16y ago"Because people buy stocks for only one reason, they want them to go up in price." Indicates the author knows little to nothing. "It is pretty much impossible for some man or woman or child who devotes a couple of hours per week to the market to outperform the professionals who spend 24×7 doing this for a living and when they are asleep" There are so many people performing so poorly - even professionals, that working 24x7 obviously doesn't buy you much "performance". While it's true you're competing against everyone else on the market, that doesn't mean there's a large group of professionals performing so well that you can't compete. In fact it's the opposite. "So what does this mean for you ? It means that I don’t know if the market will go up or down, or by how much." I'm thanking God that what it all means to me is not dependant upon what this author knows. As for the remaining "scarcity of capital" argument - it's like the author can only see one point in time, and not the big picture. There's a reason why all the capital being made available is not being borrowed. It's because smart companies know growing for the sake of growing, without demand is a bad reason to borrow, thus they don't. It's your job to determine who they are, and the fact you can't does not mean that it can't be done. There's more to comment on, but overall - I couldn't find much I could agree with.
- chunkbot 16y agoAfter selling his company to Yahoo for $5.9 billion in Yahoo stock, Mark Cuban personally architected a hedge of his enormous wealth with synthetic indexes, taking a $20 million cut for six months of protection before he could hedge the actual Yahoo shares. Compare this to John Z. Rigos, who sold his dotcom for $42 million and walked away with $8 million of stock. Between the day of the sale until the day when he could legally sell his shares, the stock tanked, and Mr. Rigos was left with virtually nothing. Mr. Cuban came from a poor Jewish family; Mr. Rigos from a poor Greek family. Same story, two outcomes... Today Mr. Cuban's net worth is more than $2 billion. I'd say he knows more than "little to nothing" about the market.
- whyme 16y agoOne would like to think.
- 16y ago
- jeffepp 16y agoThe truth is that most people sell when the market is getting killed and buy when the market is running up. It is human nature to follow the crowd. Savvy investors can make several hundred % returns buying during crashes and bear markets. The main keys to success: 1) Never use margin (market day-to-day is too unpredictable 2) Leverage with Options 3) Try to remove emotion from the investment
- lzw 16y agoGood advice, and while I see people repeating common myths in this thread, I should just be happy that they are there to take the other side of my positions.
- joelhaus 16y agoNassim Taleb comes to a similar conclusion, but with much better examples (one of the best Planet Money Podcasts ever IMO... just posted it here: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1623713 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1623713) Taleb slams Obama & the media, prefers recession over high deficits, advocates clawbacks, slams forecasting models when high debt levels are present and predicts the broad failure of public companies due to fundamentally misaligned incentives. That said, here are two (rather discomforting) counter arguments to both Cuban and Taleb: 1) A warning against credit derivatives (or betting the market will go down): "The market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent." - Keynes 2) In an inflationary environment, high levels of long-term debt can actually be a good thing for the issuers. It's the short-term debt that must be rolled over that creates most of the problems (e.g. ARM mortgages and a majority of commercial loans).
- lzw 16y agoIt is easy to beat the market and invest well because most of thevworld is operating from a position of ignorance. You don't need secret or insider knowledge, you just need to know what you know, and know what you don't know. Buffett calls his a circle of competence. I studied investing, did ok, studied economics and then discovered that the world is full of ignorant or misinformed people who cling to their misinformation. Example- look at everyone bashing gold. The conventional wisdom is you need someone to manage your money for you because you can't beat the market, and because that is such a common belief, I find it easy to beater the market.
- tocomment 16y agoSo what's the truth about gold?
- illumin8 16y agoGold is a good hedge against financial crisis. Whenever the Dow has a day of selling, you'll usually see people buying lots of commodity ETFs like GLD or IAU. The thing I like about gold is that it responds well to all types of financial crisis. Inflation risk? Gold goes up. Deflation/deleveraging risk? Gold goes up as well.
- hristov 16y agoIf you think people bashing gold are ignorant, then you should not be quoting Buffet, he is one of the biggest gold bashers out there.
- chopsueyar 16y ago...says the man who sold a $5.9 billion dollar domain name to Yahoo. Who else here has sold a company for $5.9 billion?
- known 16y agoUnless you're doing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Front_running http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Front_running you cannot make significant money via stock markets.