9 ms·
I would caution commentators not to make false dichotomies here. It is not necessarily a choice between Assange committing a crime and Assange being framed. Bot
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
I would caution commentators not to make false dichotomies here. It is not necessarily a choice between Assange committing a crime and Assange being framed. Both may be true. Neither may be true.
I understand that this fits a narrative, and perhaps it turns out he was framed. Or perhaps it turns out he is has criminal tendencies and the west used those tendencies to frame him. Or he's innocent. Or he's innocent and nobody framed him.
Simply because it fits easily into a narrative does not mean that the most likely scenario is the narrative. You could make a case that having a criminal trial would be a terrible thing for intelligence agencies. It'd just give him a bigger microphone and also put the agencies at risk of being discovered. In fact, if it is a setup, it's one of the most bone-headed setups I've ever seen. Better to just kill him. If this is discovered as a frame-job, it'd be a god-awful PR disaster. The risks don't merit the rewards.
- jacquesm 16y ago> If this is discovered as a frame-job, it'd be a god-awful PR disaster. The risks don't merit the rewards. That's the strongest argument against this being a frame-up so far. On the other hand breaking in to the Democratic party's offices wasn't very smart either and that definitely happened, and I can think of a few more cases like that. Government agencies are definitely not above doing really stupid things that turn in to PR disasters.
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoWhich is the strongest counter-argument. :) But really, trying to frame some guy that a hundred-million people think is some super-hero? It's crazy. They certainly may be doing it, but it's really beyond-stupid crazy. I'd just shoot him. Easy enough to whack somebody, and without evidence people can spend their lifetimes pointing fingers at each other. Might even make a great series of books and a movie. But with real, live people making criminal allegations that aren't true? Lots of little loose ends dangling around. Too many. In fact, I'd bet you that even if he was guilty and was not framed, there'll be a series of investigative articles and blogs "proving" he was framed anyway. The narrative is simply too hard to ignore. Which -- if you think about it -- would give him a free hand to commit any crime he wants. After all, no matter what he was accused of, he was framed, right? Welcome to the hall of mirrors.
- MisterWebz 16y agoSo killing the guy who has a hundred million fans is a good idea? When compared to false accusations, someone getting killed by a hitman who was hired by the government would far more likely create chaos amongst the public when the truth comes out.
- jacquesm 16y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_F._Kennedy_assassination http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_F._Kennedy_assassination A hundred million fans (or more if you count the rest of the world), a couple of thousand witnesses, plenty of time has passed and we're still waiting for the truth to come out.
- MisterWebz 16y agoGood point, but that was more than almost 50 years ago.
- jacquesm 16y ago> but that was more than almost 50 years ago That makes it a stronger point, not a weaker one. Imagine the journalistic coup if you could conclusively prove who did it and why. The fact that to date nobody has in spite of the size of the prize means that such things can happen and can be kept secret.
- Qz 16y agoShooting him wouldn't do anything...
- jacquesm 16y agoMr. Assange might disagree with you.
- Robin_Message 16y agoA hundred-million people don't think he is a super hero. I doubt a hundred million know him by name. And the fact is, it won't be too hard to convert most of the people who do know of him and like him into disliking him. This could be the first part of it. Combine it with the first solider to die which is linked to the information released, and any goodwill the public feels towards him is going bye-bye. In the next year, he can probably look forward to going from a modern day Robin Hood to some weirdo, introverted, odd male hacker who is trying to disrupt our ordinary lives.
- Robin_Message 16y agoIt could just be some mid-level person, US spook say, who has done this, since they would not be worried about the longer term consequences or getting found out. Someone could easily take some of the leaks personally.
- jacquesm 16y agoThat's as good an explanation of how that could have happened. What bothers me is how fast this was leaked to the media. Normally the privacy of both the victims and the accused is well protected in Sweden, especially in rape cases.
- lmaonade 16y agoA "US spook" is not a "mid-level person". Nor does a "US spook" have the authority to make the swedish government issue a warrant. Nor is a "US spook" above the law. It is within the means of an American intelligence agency, or military, of course, but the decision would come from and be authorized from the highest levels of command. That being said, it would be an idiotic way of dealing with this situation. It smacks of amateurism, and while I may have qualms with what american intelligence agencies do, they are very good at what they do, and certainly not amateurs.
- lhnz 16y agoThat might be true, but on the other hand considering Assange's paranoia it is difficult to accept that he would put himself in this position.
- mukyu 16y agoJust killing him would not discredit him and might even be seen as increasing his credibility. There is also the 'insurance' file that was released, which presumably would have the key released upon his capture or death, but probably not in this case. Even accusing him of rape discredits or puts a cloud over him and what he is trying to accomplish. It probably does not reflect that badly on whatever wikileaks publishes, but will hamper his efforts to lobby for whistle-blower protections in different countries.
- jacquesm 16y agoOn the other hand if (and that's a very big if) there will be another whistle blower that details (assuming this was a set-up) how it was done with hard proof and that data is released through any outlet but wikileaks it will do damage to the relevant authorities beyond belief. Just taking that risk is bordering on the insane. The best way to get rid of 'inconvenient' people is to have them commit suicide leaving no note or to have them have tragic accidents.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- flog 16y agoAt least they weren't as transparent to go straight to "nazi" or "pedophile". These sorts of accusations seem to stick around, even if the case is dropped.
- Qz 16y agoIf it were Barack Obama then yes, the rape accusation would be the end all be all of the whole thing. But this guy isn't exactly considered by most to be a standup guy to begin with. The accusation of rape just looks out of place and ridiculous.
- thingie 16y agoIf a false accusation can turn into a PR disaster, what about the killing? That'd be a PR apocalypse. And also, your target shouldn't be Assange as an individual, he should be quite expendable if there were other people motivated to replace him, which seems to be a very likely scenario, if he was assassinated.
- Ardit20 16y agoYou can't just shoot him. This is not communism, nor nazism, nor fasicm, this is democracy, where the rule of law is supreme. If he is shot, there would be no people arguing about pointing fingers, everyone would know who dun it, there would be little room for doubt. Here in the UK they are reopening the inquiry into Dr. Kelly's death, and his death, whether a suicide or otherwise, came amides the dawning of the war in Iraq, so perhaps of a different magnitude, but, he was also a relatively little known person. You can accuse him of rape though. Now that would leave you doubting. It is not so hard, pay some person a million, or ten million, and its a fairly good deal. It is tremendously hard to prove an untruth and they might get the result that they want. Otherwise, he would still be the alleged rapist, and fox news would probably just call him a criminal, and the trial can go on and on and during that time he might be kept in prison. As for whether he is a criminal or being framed, both may be true indeed, but that neither may be true is not quite possible. If he innocent, he is being framed, either by the victim, or something way bigger than the victim. "I understand that this fits a narrative" As doctors might say, if the symptom fits the illness no point looking at other things. It might in this case indeed be different as we are not diagnosing an illness, but common, what are the chances that the guy raped someone and molested someone? What are the chances that he did so now, only a week or so after some nutter called for him to be arrested even though then there were no allegations of committing any crime. I hope however that you are right. Otherwise, our society would have arrived at that point where the little child cries, but the emperor has no clothes, and at least we all will stop pretending that our system is brilliant, that freedom of speech is indeed paramount, that in this country the rule of law rules for kings and peasants alike and instead will realise that we need to fight for such things and not take them for granted.
- jacquesm 16y agoDr. Kelly is just about the worst example to trot out to prove that such stuff is investigated properly. http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1302640/Dr-Kelly-investigation-inadequate-Now-NINE-doctors-demand-inquest.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1302640/Dr-Kelly-inv... And Dr. Kelly was very well known, especially because of the whole 'Sexing up' press coverage.
- 16y ago
- swombat 16y agoIf this is discovered as a frame-job, it'd be a god-awful PR disaster. The risks don't merit the rewards. "All this was inspired by the principle--which is quite true within itself--that in the big lie there is always a certain force of credibility; because the broad masses of a nation are always more easily corrupted in the deeper strata of their emotional nature than consciously or voluntarily; and thus in the primitive simplicity of their minds they more readily fall victims to the big lie than the small lie, since they themselves often tell small lies in little matters but would be ashamed to resort to large-scale falsehoods. It would never come into their heads to fabricate colossal untruths, and they would not believe that others could have the impudence to distort the truth so infamously. Even though the facts which prove this to be so may be brought clearly to their minds, they will still doubt and waver and will continue to think that there may be some other explanation. For the grossly impudent lie always leaves traces behind it, even after it has been nailed down, a fact which is known to all expert liars in this world and to all who conspire together in the art of lying." - Adolf Hitler, Mein Kampf "The essential English leadership secret does not depend on particular intelligence. Rather, it depends on a remarkably stupid thick-headedness. The English follow the principle that when one lies, one should lie big, and stick to it. They keep up their lies, even at the risk of looking ridiculous." - Joseph Goebbels
- slim 16y agoHow would you prove there was no rape? Rape has always been the ideal smear, because typically nobody else is in the room. It's a classical. You can do nothing about it.
- todayiamme 16y agoNo there must be checks out there. From the top of my head and stuff I've noticed I would do the following; Ask the victim to describe the assailants crotch area etc. and cross check. DNA tests if the guy was stupid enough not to wear a condom (but this was Assagne). Corresponding physical injuries or bruises as described by the victim on the assailants body (there's almost always a struggle in a rape). Clothing with traces of the victim for example hair samples from a jacket, shoe or clothing unlikely to be rinsed(in case he claims that they have never met). Trace biological evidence on the scene (can be faked though). Interrogation. (even very smart people tend to slip up) Standard investigations (alibis blah blah the entire detective book routine) ---- I think that the real problem is that it takes too long to verify for the 24 hour news cycle unlike a murder.
- Lagged2Death 16y ago"If this is discovered as a frame-job, it'd be a god-awful PR disaster. The risks don't merit the rewards." Once I think I would have agreed. But that's a pre-Rovian way of thinking. All that will really stick in the public mind is the fact that "Wikileaks" and "Rape" appeared together in a single headline. Everything else is a footnote.