5 ms·
Yeah, could be a smear. Could also be true. Let's not have senstional titles on HN.
by jgrahamc 16y ago
Yeah, could be a smear. Could also be true. Let's not have senstional titles on HN.
- jacquesm 16y agoAssange is more than likely aware that he is a 'target of opportunity' to many institutions, which would make him very circumspect about doing stuff that could endanger either his reputation or the reputation of wikileaks. The timing of this is just too convenient to ignore. For now, until there is some hard evidence I'm in the 'smear' corner. But I still agree with you about the title, that's an opinion.
- todayiamme 16y ago>>>would make him very circumspect about doing stuff that could endanger either his reputation or the reputation of wikileaks.<<< Exactly. He is just too smart and just too obsessed about the cause to do something as stupid as that. Let's assume he did it once in a fit of mental incapacitation under the pressure, but then he walks out and does it again a few days later in another town? Even the average wannabe Criminal Joe would lie low for a while unless he was on a Bonnie-&-Clyde-esque rampage, which is a bit of a stretch to imagine with him. I am willing to bet that he has been through far worse strain in the process of fighting against the Australian govt. for his son (see: http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/06/07/100607fa_fact_khatchadourian?currentPage=all http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2010/06/07/100607fa_fact_...). It's unlikely that this would be the straw that broke the camel's back. Distantly possible, yes. Likely. No.
- wallflower 16y agoThat New Yorker article linked above was fantastic. Who is he? How did WikiLeaks arise? Julian did not come out of nowhere, he's always been somewhere. > Soon enough, Assange must confront the paradox of his creation: the thing that he seems to detest most—power without accountability—is encoded in the site’s DNA, and will only become more pronounced as WikiLeaks evolves into a real institution.
- rue 16y ago"Clinton/Hurd/Any number of politicians/civil servants/CEOs is more than likely aware that he is a 'target of opportunity' to many institutions, which would make him very circumspect about doing stuff that could endanger either his reputation or the reputation of <whatever>."
- jacquesm 16y agoI see that sort of comment trotted out here frequently, but Clinton/Hurd/and any number of politicians/civil servants and CEOS were not about to release a massive set of secret documents. The timing is just too convenient. Assange would have to have reasoned that a charge against him at this point in time would be so unbelievable that he could get away with this. And that is something that I find unbelievable. Evidence. Not just 'a charge'. So, in the case of Clinton, a dress, in the case of Hurd falsified expense reports.
- rue 16y agoNo, they were about to work on the budget, vote on some important issue, a big merger, celebrate their anniversary, about to have a child... I appreciate that the mind of a philanderer let alone a rapist is a bit alien, but you must understand that the decisions are not entirely rational. As I state above, I find the charges suspect but "he would have known better" is not a convincing counterargument.
- todayiamme 16y agoThat's the thing you see. This man does not know better! If he knew better he would have been running a startup and laughing his way to the bank. This man is obsessed with one idea. Freedom. Or, his version of it and such people are really really unlikely to burn up their cause for something like this. This is a man who spent nights awake working on a cryptographic framework for his baby. This is a man who spent months trying to decrypt files while on the run. This is a man who hardly lives a life of luxury and spends almost every second of his time towards his cause. Do you think that he is rational enough to do anything else? On the other hand, what does the USA have to lose in terms of PR? They're one of the most powerful countries in the world and they can call the shots for now, and unfortunately people know that. The shame of losing their secrets on the other hand... I really wouldn't be surprised that the women would have been chosen for some sexual history with him or something if possible. It's a longshot, but this will become a trial by media. A blot no matter how small will overshadow the leaking of the documents, and the know that. Why? Because it makes for a better story. Think about it. Would you rather see an hour long TV special about 16000 leaked war logs and their statistical correlations to war time deaths? As well as strategic failures that might get a bit dry? Or, the story of an outlaw on the run :flash picture: Out for a cause :cue music: with a dark twist? Did he or did he not? With an exclusive panel to debate it. I think that's your answer right there. Most people don't give a damn and that blot will permeate through and cloud their vision of what's going to follow, and it's not like they were eagerly awaiting it in the first place.
- mseebach 16y agoThere's an option more that isn't smear: that the accusations are real, but that he's innocent. Accused of != guilty of
- ErrantX 16y agoOne thing i have learned in my job is this; generally coincidences happen all the time. The real conspiracies etc. Are much much more infrequent. Occams razor
- jacquesm 16y agoEven the paranoid have enemies. And Assange has more enemies than most, both corporate and governmental.
- varjag 16y agoWell, keep in mind though that being a recognized champion in some field does not guarantee deep virtue of character. Remember Charles Lindbergh, the praised aviator, his boy killed by kidnappers? Same Lindy who turned a fan of eugenics and loudmouthed Nazi supporter. Or as more recent example, Hans Reiser? Am sure that hurt to a lot of fellows here. Let's just reserve our judgement until we get more facts.