2 ms·
The fungibility point is that it doesn't matter who the helium gets sold to, the price will be affected. It's like oil - it's all pretty much the same, so it do
by gwern 16y ago
The fungibility point is that it doesn't matter who the helium gets sold to, the price will be affected. It's like oil - it's all pretty much the same, so it doesn't matter whether you boycott Venezuela and specify that the oil you buy must come from Brazil rather than Venezuela, since that just means someone in Brazil will buy Venezuelan oil for you or a potential Brazilian customer would switch to Venezuelan. The oil flows where demand is.
> This is especially true when getting more is very difficult. The price is likely to go up in the future, making even more sense to hold on to it.
The price has to go up beyond the opportunity cost and one's discount rate. One doesn't invest in a merely profitable activity - one invests in the most profitable activity, and if that isn't bigger than one's discount rate one just consumes rather than invests.
If helium goes up 2% a year but Treasuries return 3%, then the savvier merchants will sell helium and buy Treasuries, and laugh at you all the way to the bank.
- TheEzEzz 16y agoFrom the article, "But if we do run out altogether, we will have to recover helium from the air and it will cost 10,000 times what it does today." Assuming he's correct, and assuming we are set to run out of helium in the next 50 years, a 3% a year return would be chump change.
- stretchwithme 16y agoThat makes sense. If the US government is selling it cheap, those who purchase from the US and other holders have the incentive to hold on to their helium til later when the price returns to normal. You're right. Oil is a good example. That's why embargoes don't work. The target country just has to buy it through a third party to defeat the embargo. Embargoes can really only work when the country embargoed is shooting itself in the foot with price controls, as we did in the 70s.