3 ms·
Yeah, getting too far into the weeds is a quick way to make someone feel like they're reading a D&D rule book, especially if many pages are spent explaining rul
by jandrese 9y ago
Yeah, getting too far into the weeds is a quick way to make someone feel like they're reading a D&D rule book, especially if many pages are spent explaining rules that ultimately have no effect on the story.
At worst it turns your exciting adventure novel into a textbook for arcane effects practitioners.
- booleandilemma 9y agoIt sounds like his writing would be better served if he just tacked on an appendix with all of the magical minutiae.
- jandrese 9y agoOr just stuff the rules in a fun footnotes when necessary. I've always been a fan of that technique personally, although I understand it is generally discouraged.
- a_t48 9y agoHe does tack on an appendix, which adds in even more details. I personally like it, but I suppose I was also the kind of kid growing up who would be okay reading D&D rulebooks. :)
- qu4z-2 9y agoBut by Sanderson's First Law, if it were in an appendix he wouldn't be able to use consequences of the rules in the story. Imagine I Robot if the laws of robotics were an optional appendix (although not quite that extreme). FWIW, I didn't find it over-explained, but I tend towards systems naturally.