3 ms·
I always took it for granted economists believed people's attitude had a significant influence on the market. In fact, this is probably why they say the opposi
by yters 19y ago
I always took it for granted economists believed people's attitude had a significant influence on the market. In fact, this is probably why they say the opposite, so people don't go crazy. Similar to how telling people they don't have free will makes them more complacent.
Interesting how the feedback loop goes both ways so reality resembles what people say. An argument can seem self fulfilling.
However, this is not po-mo in the sense that reality is what people think it is, though, because people don't really lose their free will.
- nostrademons 19y ago"In the short run, the stock market is a voting machine. In the long run, it's a weighing machine." -- Benjamin Graham There's quite a lot of evidence that people's attitude affects the economy in the short run. The whole investing discipline of technical analysis rests on this, as do the schools of Keynesianism and Austrian macroeconomics. But in the long run, people's basics needs always win out. You may believe that prices are going to fall and so it's better to spend your money later rather than sooner, but eventually you still have to eat. Or you might figure that stock prices are falling, yet companies are now spinning off so much in dividends that it's worth investing just for the dividend stream. These effects tend to put a floor (or ceiling, for bubbles) on any short-term psychological movements. The tricky part is figuring out where the short term meets the long term. If people could do that reliably, they'd be millionaires in short order. But it's very difficult to time the point where "Everybody else expects prices to go down, so they will" meets "But they're really low, so the fundamentals look too good to pass up."
- yters 19y agoThat works as long as a panic attack doesn't cause any kind of irreperable systemic shock. But I guess such a thing is unlikely. Such an event would have to be worldwide, otherwise the equilibrium you mention results.