6 ms·
I can think of a dozen reasons for that, but here are a few of the most salient ones; 1. Reading and evaluating code in an unfamiliar context is really £@#&ing
by onion2k 9y ago
I can think of a dozen reasons for that, but here are a few of the most salient ones;
1. Reading and evaluating code in an unfamiliar context is really £@#&ing hard, especially on a complex project. Understanding someone's commits requires knowledge of the project as a whole, the problem space, the environment, etc. That's not possible to do for a large number of candidates. It might not give you a very good insight in to an applicant.
2. Most people's public code is of roughly equal quality (eg 'not great'). You can't really differentiate between people well based on it. What people do in their spare time for fun is rarely commented/tested/documented/etc, so it's a bad way to evaluate their skill level. If you find someone with good public code that's a great sign, but a hiring manager who's looked at 100 Github profiles and found zero good ones might reasonably have given up looking.
Also it could be seen as a discriminatory factor; if you think public code is important you're going to overlook people with little time to write any, eg those with families, care responsibilities, interests outside of coding. Building a great team is about hiring great people more that just great developers.
3. It's hard to trust someone's public code. It's trivial to clone a few open projects and take credit for the work, and a hiring manager doesn't have the time to dig in to everyone's projects to see if they've ripped the work off from somewhere.
Also, you may have dealt with 50 hiring managers who have never looked at your public code in your career so far. That isn't very many really.
I certainly wish there was a better way to evaluate developers skill, and as someone who has plenty of public work on Github I think it'd be great if that was a good starting point, but I don't think it's quite good enough yet. I can certainly see why hiring managers don't look there.
- dvt 9y ago> It might not give you a very good insight in to an applicant. I'd argue pointless whiteboard trivia doesn't give you good insight into an applicant, either. And yet, 90% of companies do it. > Most people's public code is of roughly equal quality (eg 'not great'). I disagree with this. Unless you're looking at a toy or unfinished project, most code that's released (on npm, maven, or something similar) is actually fairly high quality. Certainly higher quality than what I've had to work with in production systems that were making millions of dollars a month. > Building a great team is about hiring great people more that just great developers. I completely agree. So why do we dehumanize potential hires with standard practices that involve (for example) memorizing algorithms you'll never use? I mean, HackerRank is a testament to how awful our culture is. Is there a DoctorRank or SecurityGuardRank or WaiterRank? > It's hard to trust someone's public code. I think this is complete BS. There's people much smarter than me that are getting screwed by these terrible practices. Max Howell, Homebrew's author, was famously rejected by Google for not passing some stupid whiteboard exam, when just about everyone at Google actually uses the software he authored.
- onion2k 9y agoI'd argue pointless whiteboard trivia doesn't give you good insight into an applicant, either. And yet, 90% of companies do it. The fact that some companies use bad practises for hiring doesn't change how hard it is to judge someone's code from their Github repo. I agree that whiteboard tests are horrible, but switching to a different bad idea wouldn't help. Unless you're looking at a toy or unfinished project, most code that's released (on npm, maven, or something similar) is actually fairly high quality. Certainly higher quality than what I've had to work with in production systems that were making millions of dollars a month. You're moving the goal posts from "Has code in public" to "Launched, contributed to, or otherwise involved with a successful open project." That's quite different, and arguably a lot of hiring managers do look at that sort of thing very favourably. I think this is complete BS. There's people much smarter than me that are getting screwed by these terrible practices. Max Howell, Homebrew's author, was famously rejected by Google for not passing some stupid whiteboard exam, when just about everyone at Google actually uses the software he authored. I'll defer to Max's own explanation for that: https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-logic-behind-Google-rejecting-Max-Howell-the-author-of-Homebrew-for-not-being-able-to-invert-a-binary-tree/answer/Max-Howell?share=100e0bb6&srid=x8w https://www.quora.com/Whats-the-logic-behind-Google-rejectin... As he says himself, Homebrew is a successful product but not necessarily great computer science. He 'failed' a computer science question. We can question whether or not Google needed to ask that in the interview, but they clearly thought it was important enough for the role Max was applying for to ask it. So maybe rejecting him for that role was the right decision. We don't really know. We do know that he wasn't applying to Google for the job of "Homebrew Maintainer" so his work on Homebrew, while really impressive, isn't really the whole story in hiring him. Surely you're not suggesting that the author of a successful project should be able to walk in to any developer role regardless of what's needed to do the job?
- collyw 9y ago"As he says himself, Homebrew is a successful product but not necessarily great computer science. He 'failed' a computer science question. " Maybe Google is different but I usually need to do computer cine type stuff about one a year.I have used recursion on maybe 4 different occasions in my carreer, but that's the sort of thing that comes up regularly in coding tests. Why not test for things that are actually being used on the job?
- mgkimsal 9y ago> 3. It's hard to trust someone's public code. It's trivial to clone a few open projects and take credit for the work, and a hiring manager doesn't have the time to dig in to everyone's projects to see if they've ripped the work off from somewhere. A public code repo is more than just code. * It's documentation Is there a decent README or other background info on how to get setup? Sample data? Tests? * It's activity Was this a fork with one patch and nothing since then? Or is it a long-term project with regular/periodic activity? * It's community Is this project getting bug reports, feature requests? How is the owner dealing with them? Ignoring them? Being rude? Actively engaging? Delegating? Honestly admitting they don't have the time and asking for help? There's a whole mess you can judge about someone that goes beyond "code" when looking at a repo. I know someone who was hired at a company a couple years back who was brought in because of a friendship but the "github" profile was referenced as justification. "This person has a lot of projects and stars - they're definitely active!". The person had starred other projects, and had cloned about 40 repos, and made (trivial) changes in about 5 of them. They had no original code. The person had been brought in to lead a team of about 6 developers, and left within 2 months because they had no experience working with actual production code or working with people on a team. That was quite apparent from their github profile.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]