4 ms·
"It seems we must ask if Google is far less evil than others would be in the same position." No I don't think that's the right question. I think Gruber really
by benologist 16y ago
"It seems we must ask if Google is far less evil than others would be in the same position."
No I don't think that's the right question. I think Gruber really nailed it with this:
"Maybe the question isn't who should hold this information, but rather should anyone hold this information."
- nooneelse 16y agoUnless we presuppose that the answer to the question "is there anything that could be done to stop the mass accumulation of data in this way?" is "yes", then Gruber's question is moot. Why should we make that presupposition in the face of the march of progress in this area?
- benologist 16y agoOf course we should make that presupposition - the US, EU, etc have the power to regulate it.
- derefr 16y agoHow? You're basically suggesting the old "country X will regulate what its citizens can or cannot do on the internet" idea, which fails because country X does not control the internet. Users will still leak information to sites that are not under the control of the US/EU/whoever, and those sites will accumulate these informational profiles.
- benologist 16y agoThe internet's not a free pass, countries regulate a lot of things for people and companies within them. Is it feasible for Google, Facebook or anyone else mining data at massive scale to operate outside the US/EU/a couple other countries? I doubt it. The infrastructure wouldn't even handle their websites, which would be a moot point since they wouldn't find 5 digits of the manpower they need lying around in whatever little country.
- billmcneale 16y agoYou can opt out. Stop using Google's search engine. And if you're not comfortable with Microsoft or Yahoo, stop using search engines altogether. Use encyclopedias or libraries. Ok, can we agree that the answer to Gruber's question is: "yes, obviously, someone needs to hold that information"?
- MWinther 16y agoNo, at least not without you telling me why someone needs to hold on to the information. In what way is that obvious?