6 ms·
> To be fair, people could also stop thinking gold is worth much. They've already noted that: > people's perception of its value will change But as they say,
by masklinn 9y ago
> To be fair, people could also stop thinking gold is worth much.
They've already noted that:
> people's perception of its value will change
But as they say, a gold bar will remain a gold bar, until and unless it is actively destroyed. Not so for bitcoins, which only remain so as long as they're actively maintained (not just individual coins but the mining networks which allows the creation of new transactions)
- emodendroket 9y agoI imagined that was talking about a certain level of fluctuation in the exchange rate of gold to dollars, not a radical change like happened to, say, aluminum (considered rare and precious at the time it was put on top of the Washington Monument; not so much today).
- egeozcan 9y agoHow do you think the story would end for gold, if it became unpopular and the exchanges closed? You can sell your gold bar, and you can sell your private key. I see them as the same and no, I don't own Bitcoins.
- masklinn 9y ago> You can sell your gold bar, and you can sell your private key. I see them as the same and no, I don't own Bitcoins. If there's no support network for your bitcoins, their value is 0, exactly. Even if you assume people stop caring for shiny imputrescible metals, its intrinsic property (of being shiny and imputrescible) pretty much ensures there will always be some demand for gold, and thus it will keep a non-zero price. Possibly low, but not actually zero.
- Jommi 9y agoBut what does it matter which one has a larger "intrinsic value"? Both prices are determined more by speculation and group consciousness.
- sumedh 9y agoI think the parent comment is implying that in a worst case scenario bitcoin will be 0 but gold will still be greater than 0. During such times you need an asset whose value will be greater than 0.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> But what does it matter which one has a larger "intrinsic value"? It matters a lot of part of the reason to invest in them is as a hedge against general collapse of social institutions.
- Jommi 9y agoBut are you really hedging against the collpase of _everything_ so that we are at a completely primative level. Or do we mean collapse as in another collapse of the world economy? If you mean the former, then yes, gold is a good hedge. But if you mean the latter, then I would argue Bitcoin beats gold 100x.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> But are you really hedging against the collpase of _everything_ so that we are at a completely primative level. Or do we mean collapse as in another collapse of the world economy? The world economy has never collapsed, and if it did, it would be equivalent to the first option. If you mean a short-term market downturn like the one that occurred with the ~2009 financial crisis, why would I even bother to hedge against that—and, if I did, why would I use an asset with high volatility to hedge against short-term market movement?
- root_axis 9y agoIt matters because one is a physical object with static properties and the other is a digital abstraction with characteristics that can change arbitrarily based on network consensus. One is fundamentally a thing that can be looked at and held, the other isn't even a thing you can know you have without consulting a quorum of nodes about the status of the ledger (for all you know, you don't actually own any tokens because an attacker has stolen them)
- egeozcan 9y agoI would say, the intrinsic property of gold is insignificant. Other metals which are naturally more abundant and in a usable shape would have more value, in other words, probably you would get more money by selling your monitor stand than a gold bar, if gold were to lose its scarcity.
- joshuaduffy 9y agoJust look at the gold price over the past 100 years, even the last 10-15 years have seen an modest increase. It will only go up & it is highly unlikely that it won't ever be perceived as the asset compared to other precious metals.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> Just look at the gold price over the past 100 years Or 2,000 years: "the researchers look at pay for a Roman legionary, in the era of Emperor Augustus (27 B.C.-14 A.D.), who was paid a salary equivalent to 2.31 ounces of gold. A centurion was paid a salary equivalent to 38.58 ounces of gold. Compared to modern US Army salaries, a private is making 20% more than the legionary, and a captain is making 30% less than the centurion" [1]. A counterpoint can be found in silver, where unexpected Spanish silver production in the New World prompted inflation around the world [2][3]. TL; DR For historical reasons, gold is grandfathered into our collective consciousness. [1] http://www.mining.com/what-a-roman-centurions-pay-says-about-gold/ http://www.mining.com/what-a-roman-centurions-pay-says-about... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/mar/21/story-of-cities-6-potosi-bolivia-peru-inca-first-city-capitalism https://www.theguardian.com/cities/2016/mar/21/story-of-citi... [3] http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/chinawh/web/s5/s5_4.html http://afe.easia.columbia.edu/chinawh/web/s5/s5_4.html
- mikeash 9y agoI’m not entirely convinced, although I’m partway there. When you “have” a Bitcoin, that means you have the private key to a wallet which the blockchain says has such-and-such amount in it. You can have that even if the miners all disappear. You can still use it to sign transactions, although they won’t get confirmed. You can even confirm them by mining a new block yourself with your transactions in it. (If all the miners are gone, the difficulty has hopefully dropped precipitously. And if not, you could always fork it to have a lower difficulty, since the only thing that stops forks currently is network consensus.) This doesn’t sound super useful, but it sounds about as useful as a bar of gold in a world where nobody considers gold to be valuable.
- masklinn 9y ago> If all the miners are gone, the difficulty has hopefully dropped precipitously AFAIK there is no mechanism for the difficulty of new blocks to fall. And if the only use is creating transactions between yourself and yourself, well you can also collect gravel. > This doesn’t sound super useful, but it sounds about as useful as a bar of gold in a world where nobody considers gold to be valuable. Even in a sub-industrial context and ignoring pretty much all of human history and assuming your gold has lost all of its extrinsic worth, your bar of gold could be molded or cast into plenty of useful things (light reflectors, heat shields, baubles, weights). Bitcoins, not so much.
- clarkmoody 9y agoDifficulty falls when block times exceed 10 minutes over the adjustment period. It's happened plenty of times in the history of Bitcoin.
- mikeash 9y agoThe catch is that the difficulty adjustment only happens every ~2k blocks. If a mass exodus of mining capacity happens really quickly, it could leave the network stranded. But if they leave at a reasonable pace, it will ramp down. That’s why I said “hopefully” before.
- 9y ago
- banku_brougham 9y agoOne of the properties of gold is that it cant be destroyed by chemical reactions. Physical destruction would amount to powderizing and dispersing over an area too wide to re-mine. There are other ways though: http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058150/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0058150/
- banku_brougham 9y agoFYI the link is to Goldfinger.