11 ms·
Does Depression Have an Evolutionary Purpose? (2017)
- tw1010 9y agoDoes anything have an evolutionary "purpose"? I mean really. Why, really, is the human tailbone less "purposeful" than our hair?
- jack_pp 9y agoNot having a tailbone has probably not been an evolutionary advantage. Hair is an evolutionary advantage, not a big one but bald women don't mate as successfully as women with nice hair do, on average
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Simon_says 9y agoAnecdotally speaking, it matters for guys, too.
- colechristensen 9y ago>not a big one but bald women don't mate as successfully as women with nice hair do, on average A trait being seen as attractive in a mate is another way that trait evolves. Hair isn't evolutionary advantageous because it attracts mates, it attracts mates because it is evolutionary advantageous. Sexual selection can get weird and select for things that are fairly far removed from what we might think as utility. Part of hair's purpose is just as an indicator of health. If you're very unhealthy your hair will fall out or look particularly bad, if it's long and nice looking that means you've probably been healthy for a long time too. That's probably a good indicator at how good you are at taking care of yourself and likewise how good you will be at taking care of your offspring and how good they will be at taking care of themselves. Sometimes sexual selection is just about how much energy you can spend on doing something to look attractive with no other purpose. Lots of birds exhibit this.
- 68c12c16 9y agoNot necessarily, the real suicides -- not those ones claimed to be but eventually not carried out -- terminate all evolution on the very specific subjects who perform that action.
- milankovic 9y agoWell, think of it like this: Evolution is a process, and the process is the purpose. And sometimes we end up with results that are "wrong". But this is never the end of the path.
- colechristensen 9y agoThe easiest way to talk about evolution is talking about purpose and desires as if it were a conscious being. Of course this is not true but there just aren't words in English for the subtle and specific concepts involved. Correctly communicating the concepts with our clumsy language requires stumbling around and turning concise ideas into difficult to understand monsters. When you are talking about evolutionary purpose, you're actually talking about the set of cause and effect pressures that lead to the effect. The human tailbone is less purposeful than the hair because we can reason fairly easily that the loss of hair would decrease fitness in some very believable situations. The loss of a tailbone we can't seem to think of any fitness changes. We have both hair and a tailbone. There _is_ evolutionary pressure to keep hair, although not extreme pressure as there's quite a bit of variability. There is not much evolutionary pressure to have or get rid of a tailbone. In order for there to be a change there has to be a path of mutations that survives and grows in a population. There probably A) isn't an easy path of mutations to get rid of the tailbone and B) isn't a meaningful cost to grow and maintain one. Those two things put together make lack of purpose. It's there, but doesn't really make a difference and isn't easily changed.
- bhouston 9y agoI think it could.... It is the "do not keep doing the same thing if it isn't working". Of course we are in a novel high stress environment so I think it can be triggered erroneously or we just need to now live through really shitty situations at work, etc. I wonder if antidepressants in some cases encourage an individual to stick out/survive a situation they should really be escaping from?
- jackhack 9y agoI think you're onto it. If an organism is not successful in whatever circumstance, then it is for the benefit of the herd (and species) that the individual drop out and not propagate its genes further. It is a braking mechanism. A psychic-emotional watchdog.
- louithethrid 9y agoI think that is to one dimensional a view. Many organisms come into situations they are not really fit to survive- society is complex, there are lots of dark corners where specialisation is needed. If you are a social party animal and by inheritance suddenly have to become a 24/7 CEO of a company,without any breaks and non stop political power plays - depression is not indicating that you are unworthy or something. It indicates that you want to migrate in society, away from a unhealthy environment- you detach yourself from the people you have to deal with and wait for reattachment with a better crowd. Sort of the eject capsule from bad influence you do not want to adapt.
- mamon 9y agoI don't think that suicide (logicaly following from "not propagate its genes further") is an actual objective of depression. It is probably more about forcing an individual to think their problem through - that's what you do when you are depressed, constantly thinking about all the things that went wrong in your life. Thing is, in primitive, savannah environment all problems were simple enough that they could be solved by just few hours/days of thinking and planning. Nowadays we live in civilized society which poses much bigger challenges, which cannot be easily fixed. That's why depression can extend to weeks/months, and after that time it becomes chronic condition, even when the actual problems that caused it has already gone away.
- psyc 9y agoPurpose maybe isn't quite the right word, but depression is evolved, and has a de facto social function, albeit a maddening one. It's a bit like chronic pain in that regard. Crudely, winning at social games and conflicts tends to impart hormonal advantages that help an organism win more. Being chronically frustrated tends to make the organism drop out of the games.
- dogma1138 9y agoDepression has a role in our nervous system and technically even lobsters can be depressed but it doesn’t mean that it has the same secondary social effects as with humans. To put it simply purpose of depression can be completely different than the effects we experience it’s just that it doesn’t have any major disadvantages as far human reproduction goes so we didn’t had the chance to fuck it out of our gene pool.
- 68c12c16 9y agoI think the researches described in the article might have over-generalized the concept of "depression" a bit... I feel what we call "depression" is actually a spectrum of symptoms -- although those symptoms might have certain shared common traits (such as strong inertia and not wanting to do anything), they actually could be quite different in other aspects. For instance, when you are not doing anything, it could be that you are ruminating; or it could also be that your body and brain are simply numb, and not thinking about anything. The article says, In this view, the disordered and extreme thinking that accompanies depression, which can leave you feeling worthless and make you catastrophize your circumstances, is needed to punch through everyday positive illusions and focus you on your problems. In a study of 61 depressed subjects, 4 out of 5 reported at least one upside to their rumination, including self-insight, problem solving, and the prevention of future mistakes. Well, I don't know the structure of their sample pool...If the experiment is performed on a campus setting, like many other psychology experiments, then the conclusion actually has a bias towards a certain group of people -- although that group certainly might have its own spectrum.
- arbitrage 9y agoIt's nice that you have feelings, but they're likely using the clinical definition of Major Depressive Disorder, which takes the guess work out of defining who the sample group is.
- 68c12c16 9y agoYes, I remember there is a DSM (Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders)... My point is that, as according to what has been written in the article, "...the disordered and extreme thinking that accompanies depression..." and "In a study of 61 depressed subjects, 4 out of 5 reported at least one upside to their rumination, including self- insight, problem solving, and the prevention of future mistakes..." it seems that the article is merely focusing on the type of depression that involves "thinking" and "rumination"...and there is a certain sub-range of the entire spectrum, of what is called "Major Depressive Disorder" as in the "academic" and "clinical" settings, that does not involve thinking or rumination -- or significantly reduced level of thinking and rumination -- then this subtype of depression is not actually covered in that study, and hence the conclusion of the study has no bearing, for that matter, on what we call "depression" as a whole, but only a subcategory of all the possible depressive symptoms ...
- doctorcroc 9y agoTangential, but this psychologist argues that depression evolved as a behavioral shutdown mechanism to prevent humans from over-investing in tactics or behaviors that did not yield any benefit (from a dopaminergic standpoint) -- https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/theory-knowledge/201604/the-behavioral-shutdown-theory-depression https://www.psychologytoday.com/blog/theory-knowledge/201604.... The reasoning is that we conserve energy by not pursuing "dead-ends". Naturally, this evolutionary mechanism is thrown for a loop in an existence where survival is assured, and meaning becomes the main spectre psychologically.
- danharaj 9y ago> this evolutionary mechanism is thrown for a loop in an existence where survival is assured, and meaning becomes the main spectre psychologically. Most people who suffer from depression because of environmental factors have no real substantial changes they can make to their life that would resolve the root issue of their depression. I could "fix" my depression once I had an independent high paying job that let me live anywhere and choose to live in the way I need to live in order to be happy. My episodes are far between now and, again, caused by things I don't have enough control over. What I'm saying is that we paper over the contradictions of the illusion of self determination peddled to us in rich Western societies by making depression seem like a personal, idiopathic problem.
- vinay427 9y agoCould you please rephrase or elaborate on this? I'm not sure if I interpreted it correctly. > What I'm saying is that we paper over the contradictions of the illusion of self determination peddled to us in rich Western societies by making depression seem like a personal, idiopathic problem.
- danharaj 9y agoThere's a particular essay I would like to link to that would better articulate the point, but I can't find it so easily. I'll keep looking and respond when I do.
- schackbrian 9y agoThis reminded me of a Scientific American article from nine years ago about the evolutionary roots of depression. It says that depression is a useful adaptation: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/depressions-evolutionary/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/depressions-evolu... Dr. Stephen Ilardi from the University of Kansas takes the opposite position. In his book, The Depression Cure, he says that depression is a disease of modernity. "[O]ur bodies were never designed for the sleep-deprived, poorly nourished, frenzied pace of twenty-first century life." https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drv3BP0Fdi8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=drv3BP0Fdi8
- 40acres 9y agoSomething about this article reminds of Venkatesh Rao article: We Are All Architects Now "A crisis is too good a thing to waste. Not only should you have as many as you have time for, you should succumb to each as quickly and completely as possible, and then bounce back as quickly as you can so you can have another one. Resistance is not just futile, it is counter-productive. This aesthetically appropriate and functionally necessary response to a crisis is a crash. If you don’t crash, it wasn’t a crisis. A healthy, crisis-ridden life is one that evolves rapidly, one crash at a time. So it stands to reason that navigating such a healthy life well involves crashing early and crashing often (CECO; life is a FEFO in CECO out, or FICO system)." https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2015/12/17/we-are-all-architects-now/ https://www.ribbonfarm.com/2015/12/17/we-are-all-architects-...
- lazerpants 9y agoThis link is amazing. You made my day. Thank you.
- shubhamjain 9y agoThe article reads like philosophical/spiritual bullshit written to overcomplicate a single idea, which I am still not sure what is.
- dragonwriter 9y agoNo, because “evolutionary purpose” is an incoherent concept, since evolution is inconsistent with purpose. Now, asking if it is a trait that contributed to fitness directly in the environment in which it arose (rather than a side effect of the underlying mechanism of some such trait or combination of traits that is not, in itself, a contributor to fitness in the environment in which it arose) may be a useful and legitimate question to ask. OTOH, this article doesn't really seem to have much to offer but speculation that segues into a really unrelated (and poorly considered) argument about treating depression that is about equivalent, borrowing the article’s own broken leg analogy, to arguing that because broken legs ultimately may be caused by, e.g., uneven stairs, that doctors are obligated to fix the stairs before treating the broken leg.
- nicostouch 9y agoprobably to feed the lions
- dschuetz 9y agoDepression and mania as its counterpart are states of the psyche out of emotional balance. Those are emotional struggles which need to be overcome by their bearers. Clinical depression based on endocrine imbalances does count as well, as it has the same impact as temporal depression. Sometimes the struggles are so hard that at times it may seem easier just to give up. If you just let those states continue to persist without any countermeasures you'll never learn how to deal with them as they continue to wreak havoc to your perceptive and reflective cognitive abilities, which work best in emotional equilibrium by the way. So, basically saying that depression in itself might have some evolutionary purpose seems a bit far fetched.
- pron 9y agoEvolutionary psychology reminds me of religious sermons. The axiomatic assumption is that everything happens for a purpose and the cause is always evolution (or God) [1], and so, if something happens it must have a purpose. All that's needed is to interpret reality to uncover it. If something good happens it's because the purpose is to reward us, and if bad something happens, it's because the purpose is to teach us. Or something. Religion, of course, is far superior, because it doesn't pretend to be science. [1]: Nothing we know about biology in general and evolution in particular entails that assumption (except in specific circumstances where the mechanism is understood, but if the mechanism is understood the interpretation is unnecessary), hence it's axiomatic.
- nothrabannosir 9y agoIsn’t it predicated on the notion of heredity and influence on sexual fitness? The assumption here being, somehow, there’s a genetic markup which positively or negatively influences propensity for depression, and that that has a positive / negative effect on procreation (either directly or through survival)? If the original effect of the genetic trait was different (as someone else mentioned) and it had a positive effect on fitness (survival), then that’s still a valid order of cause and effect analysis , and not assumption of intelligent design.
- posterboy 9y agoThe idea is to ask where a consistent pattern has its beginning, to estimate where it will lead to, etc. Its primary focus is not necessarily focused on genetics, but something that exists has to come from somewhere. > Nothing we know about biology in general and evolution in particular entails that assumption That's a bigger statement than you could probably validate So it doesn't falsify this could-be story.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 9y agoNo, you don't actually need any such assumption. We often use that language, but that isn't really what evolution is about. Evolution is about surviving the winnowing. Strategies that create high survival rates tend to propagate. Proposing a "purpose" for the strategy is just a means to try to understand the mechanism that causes them to foster higher survival rates and thereby propogate.
- wolfspider 9y agoWell I think this research paper is a little too detached from the human condition to add a lot insight into what function depression may serve but is definitely illuminating in the mechanics of how it functions. Really I think depression is the part of the human poker game where you have to put your cards down, fold, or leave the game. It forces the sufferer to finally make an attempt to relate to another human being in order to continue moving forward or at least gain some insight into why things aren't working. Suicide has no definite causal relationship with depression because plenty of people do that when they are angry or even happy (so happy life is complete). Suicide will always be the absurd answer to the absurd question and there is not much worth examining in between there in my opinion. There is higher incidence with depression and intelligent people- so perhaps the function of the depressive state is actually to improve the species. I say this because if intelligent people were able to separate themselves easily from everybody else that would have happened a long time ago. I think there must be a genetic component in there for human beings whom are intelligent to actually get stuck in a rut and inadvertently help those around them. Possibly getting depressed is that mechanism because what else is more effective at getting people to talk about their lives, what they are thinking, and what's wrong with them. If they don't feel like talking and actively resist physical signs develop to the point others take notice. The uglier side of this however is that if the depression goes on long enough it hardens and becomes a psychosis or even psychopathic tendencies. First the silver and then the lead unfortunately. More studies need to be done about the group dynamics of depression instead of focusing on the individual or their direct contacts. Certain chain reactions occur in society and we are very much aware of that but psychological studies tend to ignore that certain members of any population act as a catalyst and maybe this is where the physiological inputs are derived from- the greater population as a whole.
- laretluval 9y agoNow how about an evolutionary purpose for cancer? https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0306987716310246 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S030698771... "A tumor is an organ that has the function of killing the individual"
- henryw 9y agoTry reading "The Untethered Soul" by Michael Singer and/or "Letting Go" by David Hawkins. Depression could be partly due to an acquired habit of always paying attention to fear based thoughts (like lacking xyz), which came from evolution. The cure is to raise the emotional level of thoughts to love for self and compassion for others (by having compassion for others, you give it to yourself). Another cure is to not pay attention to the chattering of the mind. If you wrote down all the chattering of the mind, you may find that >90% of them are useless. Paying attention to the chattering brings more useless chattering. All this sounds new age, but it works.
- narrator 9y agoDoes the evolutionary psychologist serve an evolutionary purpose? It seems to fail the analytical egalitarianism test.
- abol3z 9y agoWell, actually i still didn't get an answer to why humans evolved their brains in the first place to this level. Any creature can live with less than 10% of our level of thinking. I mean humans brains is more of a threat to nature than advantage!
- robbiep 9y agoAnyone interested in the evolutionary basis of psychiatric conditions would do well to read Robert Trivers, an evolutionary psychologist.
- chmike 9y agoI'm afraid that the reason to human suicide is simply, in most cases, to put an end to the pain these human feel. The brain is an extreamly complex "organ" with many many different potential points of failure. Attempts to find a reason for abnormal behaviors by such type of guessing (finding an evolutionary reason) looks to me like our ancestors did when attributing to gods will unexpected natural events. It's not impossible that depressive behavior is a natural brain protective measure (thinking of burnout here), but this reasonning really looks like guessing and as truth seeker, we shouldn't accept the risk to be wrong on this.