7 ms·
Google started this really annoying habit of including results that don’t have the words you are searching. You can get around this by including the word in quo
by prepend 9y ago
Google started this really annoying habit of including results that don’t have the words you are searching. You can get around this by including the word in quotes but it’s frustrating to spend a few minutes looking items returned by Google to not find what you’re looking for to realize they showed it to you even though it didn’t have your search terms.
I bet this is great for current events like “when is Star Wars 1 playing” when the person probably meant Star Wars 8. But sucks when researching items or searching for a paper or particular product.
I started using Duck Duck Go and it works great. The privacy is an added bonus.
- rlv-dan 9y agoMy experience is that DDG does this too. Very annoying.
- userbinator 9y agoYes, DDG does it too. The other significant difference I've noticed, in my admittedly short-but-intense periods of DDG use, is that unlike Google, it won't block you with a CAPTCHA for "searching too hard"; but sometimes it just runs out of results. Looking through too many search pages, or using queries containing quotes and other "advanced" things like site: or intext: or intitle: operators tends to get you blocked by Google pretty quickly, which is extremely infuriating --- and the point at which I switch to DDG or something else for a while.
- bitL 9y agoThey started doing that recently :-/ I guess the appeal to ape leader is strong, even if leader lost its ways. But I am running out of options for search so have to live with it...
- garyclarke27 9y agoI agree, this is extremely annoying, Google should add an option - for their users who know what they are doing - to always do a verbatim search. I also still detest their mobile first format on iPad, again why on earth don’t they let their users choose Desktop format, if they prefer this. I have to use slower than Safari iCab Browser to get around this.
- fastball 9y agoPerform Google search -> Tools > All results -> Verbatim.
- hrktb 9y agoIt’s not sticky though. And there’s no way to force it on every search on safari for instance
- selllikesybok 9y agoDepends on your browser, but for example, in Chrome, you can set your default search in chrome://settings/searchEngines for the omnibox search. Mine is: https://www.google.com/search?q=%s&filter=0&num=100 https://www.google.com/search?q=%s&filter=0&num=100 You could easily add the verbatim parameter as well. Nothing similar for safari?
- hrktb 9y agoNot on iOS at least (chrome app and safari). Sadly ddg doesn’g have a clear verbatim mode either, but it’s not as bad as google search yet.
- selllikesybok 9y agoAh - yeah, mobile search sucks, right now. I mean, in some ways, it's great. I can get a song lyric or a football score or a movie ticket very easily. But research? Forget it.
- prepend 9y agoI swear that google once supported minus as a search term, but can find no evidence to back up my memory.
- zentiggr 9y agoThe minus option did once filter out results with that word, and could be amazingly helpful to find less used meanings of primary search terms. But it did go away about the same time as the + operator.
- mattlondon 9y agoI use DDG all the time now for personal use, but I still use Google at work. Try this one weird trick to get only what you searched for on Google: Click on the "Tools" link (under the search box) and change "All results" to "Verbatim" and I think (I dont know for sure) that this will only search for exactly what you typed.
- hinkley 9y agoDo googlers hate you?
- prepend 9y agoThanks. This is really helpful. Comically I googled and DDG’d for how to do this to no avail. And last time I checked under tools I didn’t notice verbatim as an option. But tools is different now. The shifting UI should make me recheck. Even though I can’t set this for a default, I can at least choose it when necessary and it’s faster than quote escaping terms.
- beejiu 9y agoI experience the "overgeneralized results" issue multiple times every week for maybe the past year. It frustrates me every time. If I have to click Tools > All Results > Verbatim every time, frankly I am ready to switch search engines. I am afraid to say that Google has really let itself go.
- gkya 9y agoIs search still the core of their business? Or does most of their income come from things like advertising, AppEngine, google apps for business and android-related stuff? I too feel that google search has been decaying, and saw many people here complainin about the same thing. Maybe they don't want to bother that much with it anymore if their focus has moved to stuff that they actually sell.
- Trundle 9y agoSearch isn't an alternative to advertising. It's what generates the advertising.
- chc 9y agoI think there's actually a better example of the usefulness of Google's broad search embedded in there: Somebody writing "Star Wars 1" most likely intends Episode 4 rather than Episode 1.
- dumbfounder 9y agoIt used to be that putting a + in front of a word made it mandatory, but this was dropped too.
- jacquesm 9y agoThat was because of that absolutely awesome social network called google plus
- dumbfounder 9y agoHa, I didn't make that connection... makes sense!
- tomcooks 9y ago+Fravia and the whole SearchLores community began spinning so fast in their graves that a new magnetic pole was born
- Scobberlotcher 9y agoA long time ago they changed it so that using '+' would cause it to search within "google plus" entries. They did this completely silently and the sad thing is it took people quite a long time to figure out that the meaning had been changed.
- mmanfrin 9y agoI hate this so fucking much. Seems like every other search 70% of the top results have one of my necessary keywords removed. And I don't want to switch to verbatim because I do appreciate the fact that they search synonyms and don't necessarily want to remove that.
- hedora 9y agoThis is why I can’t switch back from ddg to google. (Not that I really want to —- the only google feature I miss is the calculator, and I can get that with g! searches.) Ddg has been slowly cranking up synonym search, but it’s much better executed (triggers less often) than google’s implementation.
- lhorie 9y agoIronically, the appeal of Google over competitors when they were just starting out was precisely that you could find what you were searching for without having to add a bunch of symbols to tweak your query.
- always_good 9y agoTo be fair I'm sure this is how it works so well for the vast majority of people. It's a success if only a few power user nerds are the ones using extra syntax.
- arif_sohaib 9y agoThis makes me think. Why not add a Google Science or Google Dev with those features removed. Basically Google Scholar but also showing stackoverflow, blogs and GitHub code/gists?
- distances 9y agoAlso Google without country redirection, my pet peeve. I can't use Google in private browsing mode any more since it insists redirecting to German results (yes, I'm currently physically in Germany), so I've started using DDG too.
- weinzierl 9y agoIf you don‘t want to use DuckDuckGo you can do: http://google.com/ncr http://google.com/ncr I used this as default before I switched to DuckDuckGo completely. For a software developer google.de results are pretty useless. Switching the language to English helps a bit, but ncr results are a lot better for software and tech topics. Also, if you want to break out of your own bubble and get non-personalized results, Google is pretty useless, because of the annoying data protection pop up. Pretty much the only times I use Goggle is for local search , otherwise I’m pretty happy with ddg.
- 9y ago
- rurp 9y agoI recently tried DDG again after reading the quality was approaching Google. I was surprised to find the results are actually much better, for exactly this reason. The results I get from Google are often filled with answers to distinctly different, but much more popular searches; sometimes even after adding quotes around terms. Another nice feature of DDG is that the '-' operator works very well.
- rxhernandez 9y ago> You can get around this by including the word in quotes Not even this works sometimes. Utterly infuriating. I'm still pissed about their removal of searching forums exclusively.
- aplorbust 9y ago"Google started this really annoying habit of including results that don't have the words you are searching." Queried a one word string that is probably in hundreds of pages. Got 5 bogus results. On the plus side, I noticed ddg has apparently fixed an issue they used to have with prefixing result urls with a ddg proxy url, as other search engines are known to do. To disable this, previously the user had to turn on Javascript. I never use Javascript, and I got the urls unprefixed, as they should be. search: test2 (no quotes) 23 results 15 had test2 inurl 3 had test2 intitle 0 had test2 inpage 5 were not found inurl, intitle or elsewhere see below 1. http://www.test.com/ 2. https://dndprojects.anheuser-busch.com/mobile 3. https://www.icardnet.uillinois.edu/public/ 4. https://www.dmv.ca.gov/portal/dmv/?1dmy&urile=wcm:path:/dmv_content_en/dmv/pubs/interactive/tdrive/clc3written?lang=en 5. https://test.salesforce.com/ cname is "test.l2.salesforce.com" Some thoughts from a search engine author: "For most popular subjects, a simple text matching search that is restricted to web page titles performs admirably when PageRank prioritizes the results (demo available at google.stanford.edu). For the type of full text searches in the main Google system, PageRank also helps a great deal. "Our compact encoding uses two bytes for every hit. There are two types of hits: fancy hits and plain hits. Fancy hits include hits occurring in a URL, title, anchor text, or meta tag. Plain hits include everything else." "We chose a compromise between these options, keeping two sets of inverted barrels -- one set for hit lists which include title or anchor hits and another set for all hit lists. This way, we check the first set of barrels first and if there are not enough matches within those barrels we check the larger ones." "Google considers each hit to be one of several different types (title, anchor, URL, plain text large font, plain text small font, ...), each of which has its own type-weight." source: http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html http://infolab.stanford.edu/~backrub/google.html Would the above one word search for text2 perform "admirably" if it only examined title, meta tags and url? Popular searches, fancy hits, type-weight, ranking. And then there is everything else.
- hedora 9y agoYears ago, but years after they launched, I heard they hired a large number (100s? 1000s?) of editors to manually tweak page ranks. Basically, page rank is easy to game and doesn’t really work anymore.
- floren 9y agoMy biggest search wish is an option to eliminate any results from online shopping sites. Hell, I want a "give me the old web" toggle that eliminates shopping sites, social media, and any corporate websites so I can just find the hand-written HTML from the weirdos who'll tell me how to change the clutch on a 1969 MG Midget.
- aquova 9y agoWell, today is your lucky day then, for there is a search engine that does just that. https://wiby.me/ https://wiby.me/
- jen729w 9y agoYeah that doesn’t work so well. https://wiby.me/?q=Change+clutch+1969+mg+midget https://wiby.me/?q=Change+clutch+1969+mg+midget
- hashmal 9y agoWiby is more a work of art than a functional search engine ; it becomes clear when reading the submission rules. https://wiby.me/submit/ https://wiby.me/submit/
- hashmal 9y agoThis is my frustration as well. Today's web (as seen through search engines) is just content marketing. And to reach such a page, you have to go through ads on the results page, then a newsletter popup (sometimes two, these days), then ads all around the content (which is still marketing, remember). This is nuts.
- floren 9y agoI'd like to see a search engine where a trusted/verified set of users are allowed to categorize websites and the categories thus derived can be used by everyone to help filter their searches. So when a categorizing user does a search and clicks on a result that takes them to best-auto-parts.co.uk, they click "Shopping" on their categorization toolbar. After one or two matching categorizations, that site gets excluded from searches which have "shopping sites" turned off. You could also turn the categorizing thing around and decide that you only want to search within web forums (phpBB systems and similar), where you'll often find people posting rather esoteric knowledge about whatever esoteric car you're searching for.
- ryacko 9y agoYes, Google has become the next Ask.com search engine. Which was pretty bad.