7 ms·
It seems almost a given that whenever the term "smart" is applied to anything, it's something that tries to monitor, monetise, or otherwise resist your attempts
by userbinator 9y ago
It seems almost a given that whenever the term "smart" is applied to anything, it's something that tries to monitor, monetise, or otherwise resist your attempts at controlling it --- instead, it attempts to control you.
There's enough dystopian science fiction out there that the only thing I think when I hear "smart" is "No thanks."
- TeMPOraL 9y agoRegarding "smart devices" and IoT, honestly, I don't qualify it as dystopian. To me, it's just pathetic. A "smart", unnecessarily Internet-connected kettle or lightbulb or juicer isn't going to usher the second coming of fascism to the Western world. Even data breaches connected to those devices aren't going to have any meaningful impact on an average person's life. But it's sad, because it's wasteful. It's ugly. It's bad engineering. And all of this is motivated by greed and sociopathy of people putting it on the market. With each everyday item that gets attached to my butt, I lose faith in people a little more.
- jstanley 9y ago> A "smart", unnecessarily Internet-connected kettle or lightbulb or juicer isn't going to usher the second coming of fascism to the Western world. Each individual one isn't, but in aggregate they start transferring more and more control over your daily activities to faceless corporations thousands of miles away. That is dystopian.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThing is, most of that isn't dystopian. I can sort of buy people feeling orwellian about Alexa or Google Assistant - but as it is now, most IoT is just random startups hoping that if they abuse some users through a SaaS, they'll get to be the next Google. It never works out, and we're left with tons of electronic junk, that shouldn't even exist in the first place.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago>most of that isn't dystopian Remember that time a city in CA sent Cointelpro-esqe letters to the registered owner for vehicles their plate readers recorded going down a particular street? There's nothing that prevents similar bad behavior from HOAs or cities/towns that have access to other data sets. I don't want a HOA sending me brochures about recycling because my smart house reports that my ratio of trash to recyclables doesn't meet some arbitrary value. What goes on within the privacy my home is my business and mine alone to the fullest extent possible. You can't abuse a data set you don't have. The value to society vs the potential harm of many datasets is so low they shouldn't exist at all.
- alsetmusic 9y ago> Remember that time a city in CA sent Cointelpro-esqe letters to the registered owner for vehicles their plate readers recorded going down a particular street? No, I don’t. I’m guessing others might not, as well. Can you please supply a link?
- dsfyu404ed 9y agohttps://www.computerworld.com/article/3011394/security/las-plan-to-scan-license-plates-and-send-dear-prostitute-seeking-john-letters.html https://www.computerworld.com/article/3011394/security/las-p... It was the first result so it might not be the best article.
- imgabe 9y agoIn what way is control of your daily activities transferred away by a smart kettle? Is it not going to boil the water when I want to boil the water? If it doesn't, I'll throw it away and get a regular kettle. That's pretty much the only daily activity my kettle is involved in and no amount of Internet connection is going to remove my control of it.
- mamon 9y agoBut what if smart kettles would became so popular that regular kettles would not be produced anymore? How would you replace it then? Or, more importantly: how about "smart" lightbulbs, door locks, refridgerators? Those are much harder to replace.
- KozmoNau7 9y agoHow would they? What value does being "smart" add to a kettle or fridge?
- dvtv75 9y agoImagine this: you're on your way home, it's a cold and wet winter night, you're dashing from the bus stop to your home and you want a hot cup when you get home. Just trigger the kettle to fill and boil enough for you with the app on your phone, and you'll be warm that much faster when you get in the door. Maybe there's an autocoffee model, which makes your coffee to your preferences, and you get it to pre-boil while you're heading for home. Using the GPS on your phone with your average walking speed, it calculates when you'll be home so your coffee (or tea or hot chocolate) are just cooling to the perfect temperature when you walk in the door. You may think it won't happen, but how many would use an autokettle? I wouldn't, as I don't often drink hot drinks, but my mother might because she won't have to hobble around. A blind person might, too, for a similar reason. People who prefer consistent drinks would - I have one particular friend who hates Starbucks but drinks there anyway, because it's always exactly the same.
- KozmoNau7 9y ago
- toss1 9y agoyup, I just want a thermostat that I can remotely access -directly- and not through someone else's server. Just keep track of my IP addr myself, and yes if the ISP swaps it out for another I'll have to update it when I get there again... blah, blah, blah, yes' it'd be fine with me. Yet I cannot fine one. Every single 'smart' thermostat has some corporate service I have to negotiate through for access, and of course if that is down, well, I'm outta luck. and, they're surely accumulating all of my data. Anybody know of one?
- mcpherrinm 9y agoIf you check out Home Assistant's climate control category, you can look for devices with IoT class "local polling" and "local push". There are a number of options there. Scroll to the bottom of this page for the listing: https://home-assistant.io/components/climate/ https://home-assistant.io/components/climate/
- toss1 9y agolooks quite interesting - thanks!
- ryukafalz 9y agoNot sure about IP thermostats, but if you're willing to get a USB stick to interface with the network, a thermostat that speaks Z-Wave might be your best bet. This one seems highly rated on Amazon[0], but there are lots to choose from. From there I'd recommend using something like Home Assistant[1] - it's an open source project that provides a UI for a ton of different smart home gear. I use it at home to control some smart lights and automate things based on whether I'm home or not. (There's also OpenHAB, but in my experience configuring that is much more involved.) [0] https://www.amazon.com/GoControl-Thermostat-Z-Wave-Battery-Powered-Amazon/dp/B00ZIRV40K/ref=sr_1_1?s=hi&ie=UTF8&qid=1516730758&sr=1-1&keywords=z-wave+thermostat https://www.amazon.com/GoControl-Thermostat-Z-Wave-Battery-P... [1] https://home-assistant.io/ https://home-assistant.io/
- jstanley 9y agoIt's relatively easy to build one yourself. I did it, it works great. I used 2 ESP8266's - one in the temperature sensing and control box in my office, and one controlling a relay inside the boiler. When it's too hot the relay is opened to switch the boiler off, when it's too cold the relay is closed to switch the boiler on.
- Aleroniponi 9y ago> that gets attached to my butt Wait a minute, I don't have that extension installed at work...
- TeMPOraL 9y agoI have it installed on all desktop machines and had it for so long now, that I keep forgetting about it. Must have edited the post, that's usually how it sneaks into comments ;).
- Waterluvian 9y agoThat's how I feel about smart house stuff. I love my stupid thermostat. It just does its job. Others have added house temperature to the growing list of things in their mind on a regular basis because they have an app or emails or notifications. I set it once and haven't thought about it in years. I'm not saying it's universally bad. Getting a notification that your front door has been open for more than a minute sounds super useful. But I personally find huge value in simplicity. I guess I'll be onboard when those things are entirely invisible to me.
- dylan604 9y agoI'm almost in total agreement, except for the fact that I have a fairly flexible work schedule. Using a "dumb" programmable thermostat is nice for someone with a fixed schedule/routine. The only thing that attracts me to a remote accessible thermostat is that I can remotely adjust to the new value as I'm walking out the door from work. In the 10-15 minutes it takes to get home, the temp should be closer to where I want it. However, not enough to make me want it to managed via 3rd party company.