10 ms·
Welcome to the neighbourhood, have you read the terms of service?
- pavel_lishin 9y agoKind of hoping Charles Stross finds some time to comment on this. I know he's written a blog post on what happens to cities as microprocessors get tiny and cheap, but I can't find it right now. (Doesn't help that his blog seems to be taking about 15 seconds to load each page.)
- ceejayoz 9y agoHis latest book, Dark State, has quite a bit of scary speculation on this as well. There's a depiction of a SWAT raid in it that's a fun read until you realize it's only a few years off from potential reality.
- pavel_lishin 9y agoOh man, I've been waffling about whether to read it now, or to wait until the final book of the trilogy is written so I can binge the whole series.
- j_s 9y agoLooks like you meant Dark State: https://amzn.com/B072TZC99F https://amzn.com/B072TZC99F
- ceejayoz 9y agoAck, yes! Thanks.
- triplesec 9y agoyou could tweet it to him at @cstross as he's a prolific twitterer.
- ppeetteerr 9y agoYou can have a smart city without assigning a unique identifier to each individual between collections of data (ie by relying on aggregate data instead), or using the equivalent of a session identifier. For instance, a trashcan filling up can correlate to the number of people who use public transport, but you don't have to say person X took the bus then used the trash can.
- ISL 9y agoBut you can correlate the timeseries of crosswalk events that leave from one city block, follow a regular pattern, then a bus boarding, then a bus departure, then a regular trash-can event. Do a thing regularly, or have enough "anonymized" sensors with sufficient resolution, and one can mine a lot from apparently very little.
- vorpalhex 9y agoEven if the system doesn't do this directly, it's easy for a contractor with the data to do as much if the data is highly accurate. I hope that some mitigations are being put in place by limiting data accuracy to relatively wide windows (and the wideness of those windows will need to vary depending on how busy a thing is).
- bo1024 9y agoThis is the kind of thing that the field of "differential privacy" excels at and should be used for!
- userbinator 9y agoIt seems almost a given that whenever the term "smart" is applied to anything, it's something that tries to monitor, monetise, or otherwise resist your attempts at controlling it --- instead, it attempts to control you. There's enough dystopian science fiction out there that the only thing I think when I hear "smart" is "No thanks."
- TeMPOraL 9y agoRegarding "smart devices" and IoT, honestly, I don't qualify it as dystopian. To me, it's just pathetic. A "smart", unnecessarily Internet-connected kettle or lightbulb or juicer isn't going to usher the second coming of fascism to the Western world. Even data breaches connected to those devices aren't going to have any meaningful impact on an average person's life. But it's sad, because it's wasteful. It's ugly. It's bad engineering. And all of this is motivated by greed and sociopathy of people putting it on the market. With each everyday item that gets attached to my butt, I lose faith in people a little more.
- jstanley 9y ago> A "smart", unnecessarily Internet-connected kettle or lightbulb or juicer isn't going to usher the second coming of fascism to the Western world. Each individual one isn't, but in aggregate they start transferring more and more control over your daily activities to faceless corporations thousands of miles away. That is dystopian.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThing is, most of that isn't dystopian. I can sort of buy people feeling orwellian about Alexa or Google Assistant - but as it is now, most IoT is just random startups hoping that if they abuse some users through a SaaS, they'll get to be the next Google. It never works out, and we're left with tons of electronic junk, that shouldn't even exist in the first place.
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago
- jslakro 9y agoAll our efforts on industrialization are targeted to cover our primary needs, one by one. The main objective on industrialized farms and productive chains from rural areas have been to mantain us supplied to keep working on centrilized and populated urban centers. Now, all needs will be covered by automated tasks, we cannot became artificial agents on a flesh and bone network, fulfilling standard protocols and alienating our minds Why not just turn off the machines in farms, keep the city empty and retake our natural environment. Let's Make the robots deal with all required tech tasks, teach them an Anti AI (for avoiding skynet) and then we could have again a real life living in the country side
- walterbell 9y agoNYCLU and Columbia University have a 2016 video (starts at 2:50) about the corporate origins and privacy policy of Google's LinkNYC surveillance kiosks in Manhattan: https://livestream.com/internetsociety/hopeconf/videos/130816888 https://livestream.com/internetsociety/hopeconf/videos/13081... Village Voice covered the topic, https://www.villagevoice.com/2016/07/06/google-is-transforming-nycs-payphones-into-a-personalized-propaganda-engine/ https://www.villagevoice.com/2016/07/06/google-is-transformi... This freedom to opt out entirely is also the last argument that spokespeople for LinkNYC and the city itself fall back upon when challenged with privacy concerns: If you don’t like it, you’re welcome not to use it. It’s a disheartening place to land, especially when discussing infrastructure that’s supposed to be serving people who aren’t served otherwise. To Moglen, it’s simply an unacceptable conclusion. “That’s what they want us to believe, that we have a choice between isolation and monitored connecting,” he says. “Those are not adequate choices in a 21st-century world: We are designing the net to track you — if you don’t like it, don’t use it. The human race is shifting to a fully surveilled and monitored superorganism — if you don’t like that, stop being human. That’s a poor outcome. The United States is a society that was based around the idea that human beings can have liberty. So give us liberty! And don’t tell us that otherwise we can have the death of the net.
- ucaetano 9y agoWhen I read the title I thought the piece was on neighborhoods controlled by NIMBY associations.
- ajeet_dhaliwal 9y agoWhen I saw the title and saw it was cbc.ca I thought the article would be about the maddening state of city by-laws. That was personally a more pressing issue for me when I lived in Canada than potential issues around smart city privacy.
- Shivetya 9y agoa bit like "Oath of Fealty" where everything is watched with it implied "not all the time". Where you have a hint of privacy but none really at all with those who hold the keys. The real threat isn't the promises made today, its what the next guy in charge does with it. in the US there have been concerns already raised over surveillance from license plate scanners to body cameras. The idea they won't have identifiable data flies in the face of the language used to protect law enforcement scanning license plates and its not far behind before body camera recordings are the same.
- shyn3 9y agoThe public should provide a fair exchange here. Allow Sidewalk Labs to build any infrastructure they like irrespective of laws. Once done, hire whitehats/blackhats, and if they are able to access any information, shutdown the project.
- jstanley 9y agoI don't see how that is a fair exchange. There's every chance that Sidewalk Labs would get to build infrastructure that would otherwise be illegal, and collects data that people don't want collected, just because nobody outside Sidewalk Labs managed to get access to the data. Even people inside Sidewalk Labs shouldn't have the data. The data shouldn't be collected in the first place.
- shyn3 9y agoIf they can build a stable, private, secure system which can increase the quality of life, then I am all for it. The data seems to be needed to be able to adapt to the ever changing conditions. Two big issues they can help alleviate, homelessness and addiction.
- dcole2929 9y agoOk I'll bite. How can collecting this data, in any way, help alleviate homelessness or addiction?
- shyn3 9y agoIf you don't try to enact these projects how are you going to know the value they derive. The data collection is a necessary part of optimizing the solution. Edit: The Sidewalks Lab project is building a city. Toronto can move any people who need assistance into the society. It almost sounds like a thought experiment, but with the resources they have access to, they would be better able to assist than the city. For example, Toronto doesn't have enough safe injection sites. The data would help to highlight that if it is collected.
- 9y ago
- SEJeff 9y agoWhen it comes to "Smart Cities" in the US at least, Chicago is leading the pack: http://arrayofthings.github.io/ http://arrayofthings.github.io/
- reaperducer 9y agoChicago keeps trying to be super-technology-world, but it doesn't always work. More than a decade ago, Google promised to bring free wi-fi to the entire city. The idea was to put an AP on every light pole. Lots of press. Lots of TV interviews. No internet. It never occurred to Google that when the light on a light pole goes off, the power to the entire pole is turned off. And not just that pole, but every other pole it's connected to. Big G was counting on powering the AP's off of the light circuit, which is actually turned off miles away. Simple, reliable, century-old "dumb" technology. But Chicago keeps plugging along. There are victories, too. But the failures are more fun.
- SEJeff 9y agoGreat example of failing, but this one isn't. I was worried tbh when I saw the detector go up in my neighborhood (the pole detectors used to only be gunshot mics in high crime neighborhoods, which mine is not!). I did some inquiring and realized it is a university project to make the city better via anonymous data. The idea is absolutely fantastic. What they ultimately do with said data is how we see if this experiment fails or not. So far, it seems to be pretty useful.
- joncrane 9y agoIsn't this the same city that taxes Netflix and other streaming services?
- FilterSweep 9y ago> Generally speaking, the idea is that all of this data — and the newfound insights its analysis could yield — will help cities run more efficiently and innovate at a faster pace than they do today. Is there a source for that claim? Or, do these newfound insights merely help Alphabet provided more specialized services to communities (a net gain, I guess), and provide a substantially larger operating budget for lobbying?
- Animats 9y agoI wonder what Apple would do if you leased some rooftop space in the mall across the street from the entrance to their new HQ and aimed cameras at the entrance, recording every license plate going in and out? Then buy the CA DMV records, which you can do for marketing purposes, and use that to build an employee list to be sold to recruiters.
- donarb 9y agoHow would you correlate an Apple employee's job title with a recruiter's requirements using just a license plate number?
- reaperducer 9y agoYou don't need to. That's the beauty of spam, whether e-mail or paper. If your client wants to target developers at Apple, you've narrowed the mailing list size from several million to just a few thousand. If 30% of those are developers, then you've already improved on the usual mass mailing targeting average, which is in the single digits.
- joncrane 9y agoYear, make, and model of the car would be a good proxy. If not for job title, then for propensity to spend on luxury items.
- Animats 9y agoOnce you have license numbers, you can get names. Once you have names, you can look at LinkedIn, Facebook, and CiteSeeer to see what they're into. You can also gather intelligence on what Apple is working on. More AI people? More voice recognition people? More chip designers? More phone sales people?
- ggm 9y agoIf you read a headline that the national government of a large asian economy was deploying a million cameras you would go to statist surveillence. If you read a more nuanced headline that in a large asian economy, a million privately owned cameras have been deployed, as locals chose to arm up against bad behaviour, perceived threats or nosiness, you might feel different. I am told the latter is actually as common as the former, in the aforesaid large asian economy. The state cameras are on poles and buildings, and are at similar densities to the UK in that regard (within order of magnitude) Whereas the cheap, hackable (crackably hackable, risably simply crackably hackable) IoT IP enabled cameras are being bought and sold for $50 or less, and installed freehand by concerned locals who wonder why their pet cat keeps disappearing. It is now routine for police to ask citizens for dashcam and other static camera footage when investigating crime. The locals with cameras are often very happy to comply. Is this boil the frog slowly?