4 ms·
Europe can buy all the yuan in the world and it won’t have any effect. The exchange rate between the dollar and the yuan is set by the rate at which China is b
by dogma1138 9y ago
Europe can buy all the yuan in the world and it won’t have any effect.
The exchange rate between the dollar and the yuan is set by the rate at which China is buying US debt not by the global markets.
China prints money to buy US debt it allows China to devalue its own currency without devaluing its assets and this deal allowed the US to pretty much generate as much currency as they want through cheap debt without devaluing it.
The only thing that would affect Walmart is a tariff war with China, Europe can huff and puff all it wants but it isn’t a relevant player in this specific scenario.
- NicoJuicy 9y agoThat's rude... Source? It's definitely not the CIA Factbook: https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/rankorder/2001rank.html https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/... Takeaway: EU GDP > America GDP ( don't forget, also the Euro vs USD rose since the start of 2018) ;)
- dogma1138 9y agoThe GDP of Europe is irrelevant for this scenario the monetary relationship between the dolllar and the yuan isn’t like most currencies. Until 2005 it was pegged to the dollar completely since then it’s effectively pegged to the rate at which China buys dollar bonds.
- NicoJuicy 9y agoDo you have a source or reference where i can get a deeper information/knowledge about the relationship between the dollar, yuan and bonds?
- dogma1138 9y agoThis isn't something that can be put into a single paragraph, the top 3 results from Google seem to provide decent sources of information https://www.thebalance.com/dollar-to-yuan-conversion-and-history-3306089 https://www.thebalance.com/dollar-to-yuan-conversion-and-his... https://www.thebalance.com/how-does-china-influence-the-u-s-dollar-3970466 https://www.thebalance.com/how-does-china-influence-the-u-s-... https://www.cluteinstitute.com/ojs/index.php/IBER/article/download/3152/3200 https://www.cluteinstitute.com/ojs/index.php/IBER/article/do... However I haven't read them thoroughly, so I suggest you invest some time in doing some research. P.S. I really hate this source/citation discourse that is effectively taken over every debate on the internet opinions can be constructed out of vast amounts of information and experience and even casual observations tend to be the product of much more information that can be distilled into bit size pieces. Just do research and learn, stay away from wikipedia and go for academic and sources and don't shy from even biased opinion pieces as those tend to be some of the most valuable as they expose you to concrete positions and being wrong or right does not change their value.
- ethbro 9y agoUnfortunately, what you suggest is a circular set of actions. Why would I read comment sections if I'd already had the time and been able to find high quality sources to learned about the topic? If you don't feel like citing sources, or don't have any good ones handy, saying so is fine. But even providing the right terms to search can be helpful!
- dogma1138 9y agoThe search terms I've used were "Yuan dollar relationship" I'm not entirely sure if these are the best terms to use in this case but these were the ones with the least amount of confirmation bias, so you'll only have to deal with the usual search engine bias.
- ameister14 9y agoI think a lot of the problem is I can't trust your reputation unless I know you or you have some other proven characteristics to help create that trust. There are a few people on HN like that, but it's rare. In real life if you present an opinion I know what you do for a living and potentially how educated that opinion is. On the internet I don't. That means that if you're an econ PhD and you tell me a basic statement, I'll trust it in real life. On the internet you'd have to prove you're a PhD first. It really does limit the conversation we can have. A lot of the time I find myself talking to someone (or arguing with them) and realizing they don't have the framework to hold the conversation - they'd need to read a half dozen books and do some intensive study because they want to work through problems that have already been solved.
- dogma1138 9y agoNo one said anything about trusting an opinion or a presented fact, you should always do your own research that's the point. On a more anecdotal side the people I tend to "trust" the least at least on the internet are those who often come out with citations for everything and dump a huge wall of text. The problem with the internet is that you can find a citation for everything, I can find that enough citations that lizard aliens are actually the ones who control the exchange rate of the Yuan to the Dollar using a weather machine. The credibility of sources is also extremely hard to determine these days especially in subjects which are not your primary proficiency it's too easy to publish anything you want these days even in reputable sources.
- muninn_ 9y agoGDP isn't a good way to measure economic output. Nor is it relevant here.
- dmichulke 9y ago> Europe can buy all the yuan in the world and it won’t have any effect. That is entirely wrong. There is only a limited amount of Yuan, so by definition the supply of Yuan is affected, no matter in which currency it is bought. Therefore, the price is affected as well. Will wheat in USD get more expensive if I buy all your wheat with Ruble? You bet it will.
- Symmetry 9y agoThe amount of Yuan isn't literally infinite but China can print new Yuan a lot faster than Europe can buy it up and, in practice, would absolutely need to in response to extra European demand so as to not suffer from a deflation induced depression.
- gcb0 9y agothe amount EU can buy increases as they print more Yaun. not the other way around as you suggested on the first sentence.
- dogma1138 9y agoThe supply of the Yuan is controlled by China, but In this case the limit isn't the available supply of the Yuan at all. For Europe to buy Yuan it needs to exchange something for it, usually another currency likely in this case the dollar rather than EUR. The hard limit is more on how much EUR does China wants to hold and how much USD Europe is willing to spend on buying Yuan. Beyond that you also go into the realm of would China allow Europe to hold large amounts of Yuan, countries tend to be protective of their currency and restrict any single entity from holding amounts large enough to do substantial damage if dumped. Basically they would allow you to buy enough currency for them to benefit but not enough for you to hold it over their head.
- freeflight 9y ago> China prints money to buy US debt it allows China to devalue its own currency without devaluing its assets and this deal allowed the US to pretty much generate as much currency as they want through cheap debt without devaluing it. So China is printing money to buy up the debt generated by the US printing money? I'm not an economist, but that does not sound like a reasonable way for a world economy to run on.
- dogma1138 9y agoThings are much more complicated than this, but essentially China as a primary exporter wants to keep the value of it's currency as low as possible since the exporters then benefit on exchange rates. It also wants stability so it basically pegs the Yuan to the dollar, historically directly and more recently in directly (the Chinese central bank sets more or less of a fixed exchange rate but it does allow it to deviate somewhat these days). Now to prevent the Chinese economy from being effectively run on and by foreign currency China heavily restricts the ownership and settlement in foreign currency internally. It basically forces the exporters/manufactures to exchange the foreign currency they paid in (usually USD) back to Yuan for any internal use (or alternatively if you want to do business in china you basically have to exchange your currency in Yuan it's the same thing). It then uses that surplus of foreign currency to buy other assets, primarily dollar bonds such as US treasury bonds which basically brings back all those dollars that came from the US and everywhere else in the world back to the US. And even this is like very very basic overview of things. On some level the US economy or at least the dollar economy is basically based on the fact that the dollars used in international trade have to come back to the US. Basically you buy dollars from the US, you use those dollars to buy something e.g. goods from China then those dollars go straight back to the US in exchange usually for "cheaper" dollar bonds. The debt economy a side the scheme is when viewed on a global scale is almost like you never actually own a dollar you simply rent it out.
- gcb0 9y agobut isn't buying bonds only useful if you want to return those USD with the prospect of getting more back later on (ideally above inflation)
- Symmetry 9y agoYou could make the claim that China was devaluing its currency in 1995 but since then the Yuan has been gaining in value relative to the dollar.[1] I think that became a talking point back when it was true and people have just been repeating it ever since without reexamining. [1]http://www.macrotrends.net/2575/us-dollar-yuan-exchange-rate-historical-chart http://www.macrotrends.net/2575/us-dollar-yuan-exchange-rate...
- dogma1138 9y agoThose aren't mutually exclusive, this isn't as bad as the "currency wars" of the mid 90's where the US wen't crying all the time to the WTO about China at least publicly. But China very much still controls the exchange rate of the Yuan to the dollar and still devalues it's currency in order to boost exports.
- Symmetry 9y agoHow can you say China is devaluing its currency to boost when the price of the currency is increasing in dollar terms? And generally speaking you can't keep exports inflated for long by currency devaluation any more than you can use inflation to keep unemployment low. In the end the trade balance will revert to what you'd expect from the savings rates of the two countries, and in this case China's higher savings rate means it exports a lot more to the US than vice versa.
- jessaustin 9y agoClearly GP means that the price would be increasing more quickly without the hypothesized devaluation. Like most economic questions, this isn't binary.
- cryptonector 9y agoChina could abandon mercantilism, or the U.S. as its main export market. That would have an effect for sure.
- olefoo 9y agoDid somebody say tariffs and trade wars? http://www.bbc.com/news/business-42784380 http://www.bbc.com/news/business-42784380 Not to mention which the post-world-war-II international order is falling apart politically which suggests there will be a monetary realignment in the not too distant future. This isn't a big deal because of the relative size of the flow; it's a big deal in the way that a dam suddenly spouting water around the edges is a big deal.