4 ms·
> The current main incentive against cheating is that miners will lose their invested PoW (compute time + electricity) if they cheat and get their block thrown
by yorwba 9y ago
> The current main incentive against cheating is that miners will lose their invested PoW (compute time + electricity) if they cheat and get their block thrown out. However, with a useful PoW, this calculus changes. Now, the PoW is no longer "wasted" when the miner cheats and gets caught as the PoW is now useful for something besides mining.
So you spend $x on (compute time + electricity) to mine a useful PoW worth $y outside the blockchain and an additional mining reward of $z. If you cheat, you don't get to collect the $z reward. Although your original $x are not completely wasted, you still only have $y instead of the $y + $z you could have had.
How is that not incentive enough?
- beaner 9y ago$y + $z must be greater than $x. If $y is money and $z is scientific contributions... $y is most likely not something people are offering money for. So in an open market its value is at or near $0. So $z by itself must exceed $x. To not care about the $z, $y must exceed $x by itself and that seems really unlikely for the types of things that OP suggested instead of proof-of-work.
- mygo 9y ago>If $y is money ... $y is most likely not something people are offering money for. scrathes head
- maldeh 9y agoIf $y is the useful PoW, would that not make $y the scientific reward while $z is the (monetary) token reward by way of mining? Edit: silly question on my part. y and z should be trivially interchangeable. Your argument appears to rest on the idea that the monetizeable scientific worth of the work would dominate the worth of the crypto token itself, since there would be limited value in an already-mined result beyond standard blockchain speculation - is that the case?
- ric2b 9y ago> Although your original $x are not completely wasted, you still only have $y instead of the $y + $z you could have had. That just makes $x grow to $previous_x + $y.