3 ms·
> Why do people push for rail? Because well-done High Speed Rail (HSR) is a blast over long distances. Certainly for city/metro areas a combination of light ra
by mschuster91 9y ago
> Why do people push for rail?
Because well-done High Speed Rail (HSR) is a blast over long distances. Certainly for city/metro areas a combination of light rail + buses as a web is the best option (light rail having the advantage of running emissions free), but the longer the distances are the better HSR is. The new ICE line Munich-Berlin with 4h one-way is so fast that it's actually threatening flight.
Also, traveling long distances by bus is really bad. Cramped seats, cramped everything.
- adrianN 9y agoThere are electric buses that run emission free. They have the additional benefit of not needing extremely expensive new infrastructure for starting a new line. I think they would work much better in low density settings like American suburbia.
- majewsky 9y ago> They have the additional benefit of not needing extremely expensive new infrastructure for starting a new line. Only because of the sunk cost of building all those interstates. At some point, you're going to need to repair or rebuild them. Which makes me wonder: What is the cost of a new kilometer of rail vs. a new kilometer of highway? And which one is cheaper to maintain? I don't have any intuition there.
- jschwartzi 9y agoI can attest to how awesome rail is. I recently took the shinkansen from Tokyo station to Sendai in Japan, and it turned an 8-hour car trip into a two hour train ride. The seats were as large as business-class airplane seats. It would likely have taken much longer by bus because of all the stops and transfers.