11 ms·
I do not understand your sense of ethics at all. If the lawyer is in some way writing a will that benefits the friend more than the other wills the lawyer writ
by geofft 9y ago
I do not understand your sense of ethics at all.
If the lawyer is in some way writing a will that benefits the friend more than the other wills the lawyer writes, or (worse) benefits the lawyer, that's unethical. If the lawyer is writing the will but just not charging, that doesn't seem ethically questionable.
If the doctor is stealing flu shots from the clinic that could have gone to people who couldn't pay for them except via insurance or another program, that is definitely unethical. If the doctor ... happens to have flu shots lying around? does this happen?? ... and has nothing else to do with them, healing people is part of the doctor's mission.
Letting people go after they have committed a misdemeanor is not part of a police officer's mission. It's rather the opposite of it. If a lawyer takes up a client's case, and argues weakly in court because the other side is a friend of the lawyer's, that is absolutely unethical. If a doctor prescribes a medication that the patient doesn't need because a family member works for the pharmaceutical company, that is absolutely unethical. And these things don't happen on a regular basis.
I'm sure that the doctor in your example would love to give flu shots to everyone, or the lawyer would love to make sure everyone has a will - they just don't have the time to write wills for everyone without pay. But the situation with the cop is the opposite: the cop spends less time not pulling someone over. The cop does not have a limited amount of tickets they can overlook; the cop actually has a limited amount of tickets they can write. If the cop wants to give everyone a pass on speeding tickets, that seems great. But they clearly don't - they are saying "I have one set of standards for my friends, and another for everyone else," which is unethical. The doctor and lawyer aren't saying that.
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoBarter is supposed to be taxed. Its tax evasion. A small matter, but so is not writing a ticket. After all, officers have discretion - the public safety is their concern, not making money for the city. I've been stopped a couple of times, only gotten a ticket once. Because I'm not a public menace, and that's clear once the officer talks to me. No special card involved.
- colanderman 9y agoWho's bartering? Your original example was of a gift. Gifts under $14,000 don't need to be reported. [1] If bartering is involved, then yes, it ought to be reported as taxable, or it's unethical for the reasons you state. [1] https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/frequently-asked-questions-on-gift-taxes https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employe...
- geofft 9y agoHuh, I've been stopped a few times, it's been clear I'm not a public menace, and I still get ticketed. Maybe it's because I'm not white?
- JoeAltmaier 9y agoLikely - I'm tall, white, middle-European looking and educated. I'm polite to the policeman too. All that gives me an edge, undeserved or not I guess.