3 ms·
> If the Chinese Government and its citizens want to subsidize clean energy production in Europe by selling us subsidized solar panels why should we say no? Be
by mschuster91 9y ago
> If the Chinese Government and its citizens want to subsidize clean energy production in Europe by selling us subsidized solar panels why should we say no?
Because European know-how and industry, and thus competitive advantage, gets lost. I don't want a dictatorship like China having the massive amount of leverage it already has. China has brought European solar, steel and electronics production to its knees by a combination of slavery-backed price dumping, industrial espionage, knowledge-transfer extortions (aka "to do business in China you have to find a local partner and work with them") and outright buying of the shells of doomed European companies.
Especially the stranglehold China has over the West when it comes to electronics will bite the West more sooner than later.
By the way, China is doing a similar thing to Africa: with all the money the West gave to them for cheap electronics they're building (and thus taking operational control) rail and road infrastructure.
From Chinese perspective it's the perfect ultra long game... the rest of the world is in for a massive shock once they run afoul of Chinese goals wherever and whenever that might be.
- qiqing 9y agoNot to be inflammatory, but are you stating that building rail and road infrastructure is morally worse than European actions on that continent (as recently as our own lifetimes)? Just seeking clarification.
- mschuster91 9y ago> but are you stating that building rail and road infrastructure is morally worse than European actions on that continent No, and that's why I said "long game". For now, of course, African countries selling themselves out to China will profit - but the countries are, basically, binding their future on the goodwill of China. Just imagine the countries decide one day that they're done with cheap low quality China crap, that they want to incentivize local production or that they want to show solidarity with Tibet or Taiwan... say goodbye to your traffic infrastructure, that will be the Chinese response. The West made Africa totally dependent on mitumba (cheap second-hand clothing that all but destroyed local textile industry) and other foreign aid (after all, Africa is a nice dumping ground for overproduced European milk and other food - do "something good" and keep European prices high at the same time), and the Chinese are doing the same with their money. Colonialism at its finest.
- qiqing 9y ago> say goodbye to your traffic infrastructure I'm not sure how you're proposing that would happen. Like ripping up roads? Or like, not renewing a contract for future repairs? And would that be different from the abandoned projects from NGO's? > the Chinese are doing the same with their money. Colonialism at its finest. I think there's some projection here... Although I grew up in the U.S., I've visited relatives frequently enough to come at this with a different perspective. In Chinese culture (and perhaps some other cultures as well), there is a notion that nations that have economic ties with one another are highly disincentivized from going to war with each other. And also, that nations with hard infrastructure, such as roads, a stable power grid, and soft infrastructure, including high literacy rates, low rates of religion, and dual-income households being the norm, have the ability to grow their GDP more effectively, and less likely to give into religious fundamentalism, civil wars, and general unrest. In American culture, I've heard it said that no two countries that both have a McDonalds would go to war with one another. So I don't think this is really so different. > cheap low quality China crap um... I'm not sure whether to call this conscious bias or unconscious bias. A lot of high quality products come out of China these days, and the last time I visited (in 2017), Shanghai seemed way more high tech than the SF Bay Area. One area in which there is a lack of talent is in brand marketing, and I'll explain what the problem is with two scenarios: 1) U.S. brand wants to get a particular product made. Gets quotes from X suppliers. Chooses the lowest cost estimate, which happens to cut corners, reinforcing the low image of Chinese exports. 2) Chinese manufacturers release their own products into a Chinese market. Manufacturers compete against each other for consumer preference, and high quality products are rewarded. That's where the good stuff is. Problem is, these companies don't tend to have a lot of in-house marketing talent for making the right kind of ads for the West, despite having lots of technical / manufacturing / design expertise.
- mschuster91 9y ago> I'm not sure how you're proposing that would happen. One way, for example: Have only Chinese nationals operate the railway equipment or the dispatching. In case of conflict, forbid the personnel from working, order the personnel back home - or, in severe cases, to activate a hidden killswitch on the IT equipment (which can be done even from remote). A railroad network without a working dispatch is useless, dito for airports. In today's world where nothing operates without massive amounts of computers the unspoken threat alone is enough to coerce any country into doing what China wants. > In Chinese culture (and perhaps some other cultures as well), there is a notion that nations that have economic ties with one another are highly disincentivized from going to war with each other. And also, that nations with hard infrastructure, such as roads, a stable power grid, and soft infrastructure, including high literacy rates, low rates of religion, and dual-income households being the norm, have the ability to grow their GDP more effectively, and less likely to give into religious fundamentalism, civil wars, and general unrest. Indeed, indeed - and exactly this is what makes me afraid. Who is going to oppose China when they try to annex Taiwan for good? I'd be surprised if the US actually follows through on their decades of pledges to Taiwan. Or when they will turn into that massive monster of a surveillance state enabled by modern technology? When everyone has ties to China, China has leverage. (Just as the US has, yes, but at least the US are a democracy and bound to human rights at their core.) > um... I'm not sure whether to call this conscious bias or unconscious bias. Combination of both, I'd say - the "conscious bias" backed by countless stories of faked high-quality Western products ending up even in legitimate supply chains and sometimes endangering lives.
- throwawayjava 9y ago> Because European know-how and industry, and thus competitive advantage, gets lost 1. This assumes that the way we build solar panels (or whatever) never changes. We lost a lot of steel-making knowledge in the early 20th century. Of course, all that "expertise" was replaced by machines, so it was mostly a loss of obsolete knowledge. 2. The solution is to pocket a fraction of the savings and keep that in your back pocket to maintain a teaching/research corps and to ramp up internal expertise when/if the subsidies stop flowing. Of course, this assumes a level of competence, self-control, and foresight that may be missing in modern legislatures.
- mschuster91 9y ago> 1. This assumes that the way we build solar panels (or whatever) never changes. Yeah but the Chinese basically took the European process, scaled it up and dumped the prices by using extremely low cost labor and massive state subsidies both at construction of the plants and at selling the product. There's no invention there, only the aim of totally destroying the competition. The only inventions happening are in research labs - and as there are no more notable fabs left in Europe or the US, that research will be applied in China. Our taxes basically funding our continued downfall... > Of course, this assumes a level of competence, self-control, and foresight that may be missing in modern legislatures. The only country which ever had this is Norway with its ultra massive oil fund. The Arabian countries are playing catch-up there with their recent investments but... well... building a fully air conditioned soccer stadium right in the midst of a hot desert isn't exactly a wise (or environment friendly) investment, much less a dozen of them. In addition, engaging in more-or-less pointless turf and proxy wars all over Arabia (and parts of Northern Africa too) are a totally unneeded drain on their resources.
- qiqing 9y ago> There's no invention there A common bias amongst Westerners who have never visited China. Actually, a lot of "home-grown" innovation happens in China, but is not really covered by Western media. You don't get double digit GDP growth without research into R&D across a broad range of sectors. The solar panels that were produced a decade ago are also not as efficient as the ones produced today, and are productized in very different ways. For instance, light-weight solar panel kits that include a battery pack and LED lighting have a very high product-market-fit for ethnic Mongolian nomads (who follow their herds) and sell like hotcakes over there. You can get another add-on kit for charging your smartphone.
- coliveira 9y ago> Chinese perspective it's the perfect ultra long game... the rest of the world is in for a massive shock For centuries this has just been called plain capitalism. Now that China is doing the same, Europeans and Americans are in a shock? How interesting.
- ksk 9y ago>Because European know-how and industry, and thus competitive advantage, gets lost. Is your assumption here that no non-europeans (including the Chinese) have contributed to solar research? >by a combination of slavery-backed price dumping, industrial espionage, knowledge-transfer extortions (aka "to do business in China you have to find a local partner and work with them") and outright buying of the shells of doomed European companies. You will need to provide massive objective evidence (i.e. not 2-3 links from googling "china solar" ) before anyone believes that giant assertion. Personally, I neither want a $5000 made in USA iPhone or a $99 bottom of the barrel chiPhone, but YMMV.
- mschuster91 9y ago> You will need to provide massive objective evidence (i.e. not 2-3 links from googling "china solar" ) before anyone believes that giant assertion. * "slavery-backed price dumping": There have been more than enough reports on the gruesome working conditions in Chinese factories. They are so widespread and notorious, they got dedicated their own Simpsons "couch gag" (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEki-IBdop8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XEki-IBdop8). And yes, I consider this dumping - because a company that operates to Western working conditions has no way of competition against people with 80-hour workweeks, armies of children and adhering to safety protocols. * For industrial espionage, the same (e.g. Nortel, Dupont, Transrapid, Volkswagen/First Automotive Works, plus countless cases in the German Mittelstand - even the German Constitution Protection Bureau warns about this: https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/verfassungsschutz-china-spionage-101.html https://www.tagesschau.de/inland/verfassungsschutz-china-spi...). According to a (bit dated, though) report, up to half of Mittelstand companies have reported Chinese cyber-espionage: http://www.sueddeutsche.de/wirtschaft/industriespionage-was-chinas-hacker-versprechen-wert-ist-1.2715745 http://www.sueddeutsche.de/wirtschaft/industriespionage-was-... * For buying shells of doomed European companies, have a look at e.g. https://www.morgenpost.de/wirtschaft/article207409333/Chinesische-Investoren-auf-Einkaufstour-in-Europa.html https://www.morgenpost.de/wirtschaft/article207409333/Chines... - companies from as humble as trash burner EEW to such household names as Krauss-Maffei and Syngenta.
- ksk 9y ago