5 ms·
And it was a very stupid thing to do, and I say that as an European. If the Chinese Government and its citizens want to subsidize clean energy production in Eur
by paganel 9y ago
And it was a very stupid thing to do, and I say that as an European. If the Chinese Government and its citizens want to subsidize clean energy production in Europe by selling us subsidized solar panels why should we say no? A similar question was posed by Jean-Baptiste Say about 200 years ago end since then no protectionist politicians were able to come up with a valid answer, they just go "by their instinct" or "it's best for our home industry that we behave this way", both answers that don't stand on any solid rational grounds.
- monob 9y agoBecause it destroys the local industry which you will need at some point. As simple example: the British supported the German chemicals industry prior to WWI. At the start of WWI, the money the British spent had been turned into German chemical expertise. This lead to the development of the Haber process, poison gas, and generally making Germany a powerhouse in chemicals in the same way Britain was in mechanical manufacturing. If a tariff had been put in place on German imports to Britain the German chemical industry would have been much smaller, with much less capability and WWI would have finished in 6 months because Germany would have run out of nitric acid for their explosives.
- averagewall 9y agoAre you saying it's better to keep underdeveloped countries technologically disadvantaged in case your own country worries they're becoming too powerful and so starts a war with them to keep them underdeveloped? Another way to stop wars is to accept that somebody else is more economically productive and let the whole world benefit from that instead of trying to destroy it.
- monob 9y agoThat's a very naive way of looking at the world. Economics is only allowed a free reign so long as it meets the goals of those currently in power in a given political unit. Try selling nuclear technology to Iran if you don't think that it applies to the US as much as to China. Doing it strategically to prevent a nuclear war 30 years down the line is the lesser of two evils.
- Spivak 9y agoProtectionist politicians have always had an answer. * Manufacturing them at home is better for local workers and provides a straightforward path for dispaced workers from other plant work. * Trying to compete on even terms with what is essentially slave labor overseas drags us all down. * There is value in economic independence, especially when you're importing from a fairweather ally. You don't want to wipe out a local industry that you might need to lean on someday. The reasons for having tarriffs are apparently obvious to everyone except economists.
- sauwan 9y ago* Increased pricing is bad for local installation workers and creates additional displaced workers. Installer jobs greatly exceed manufacturing jobs. * Innovate on automation. * Then subsidize our industry, rather than tax imports. Taxing imports simply hurts the industry as a whole. Minnesota solar is a good case study [1] 1 http://midwestenergynews.com/2016/02/15/solar-job-growth-expected-to-continue-in-minnesota/ http://midwestenergynews.com/2016/02/15/solar-job-growth-exp...
- mschuster91 9y ago> If the Chinese Government and its citizens want to subsidize clean energy production in Europe by selling us subsidized solar panels why should we say no? Because European know-how and industry, and thus competitive advantage, gets lost. I don't want a dictatorship like China having the massive amount of leverage it already has. China has brought European solar, steel and electronics production to its knees by a combination of slavery-backed price dumping, industrial espionage, knowledge-transfer extortions (aka "to do business in China you have to find a local partner and work with them") and outright buying of the shells of doomed European companies. Especially the stranglehold China has over the West when it comes to electronics will bite the West more sooner than later. By the way, China is doing a similar thing to Africa: with all the money the West gave to them for cheap electronics they're building (and thus taking operational control) rail and road infrastructure. From Chinese perspective it's the perfect ultra long game... the rest of the world is in for a massive shock once they run afoul of Chinese goals wherever and whenever that might be.
- qiqing 9y agoNot to be inflammatory, but are you stating that building rail and road infrastructure is morally worse than European actions on that continent (as recently as our own lifetimes)? Just seeking clarification.
- mschuster91 9y ago> but are you stating that building rail and road infrastructure is morally worse than European actions on that continent No, and that's why I said "long game". For now, of course, African countries selling themselves out to China will profit - but the countries are, basically, binding their future on the goodwill of China. Just imagine the countries decide one day that they're done with cheap low quality China crap, that they want to incentivize local production or that they want to show solidarity with Tibet or Taiwan... say goodbye to your traffic infrastructure, that will be the Chinese response. The West made Africa totally dependent on mitumba (cheap second-hand clothing that all but destroyed local textile industry) and other foreign aid (after all, Africa is a nice dumping ground for overproduced European milk and other food - do "something good" and keep European prices high at the same time), and the Chinese are doing the same with their money. Colonialism at its finest.
- civilitty 9y agoYou literally cannot have an effective national security apparatus without massive amounts of protectionist economic policy that guarantees that the resources your armed forces depend on (and the resources those resources depend on, and so on) aren't immediately cut off when you enter a conflict. Every politician this side of Hammurabi has understood this basic fact of sovereignty and in this day and age of military mega-alliances, that kind of control becomes more important than ever. With the way the electrical generation industry is going, it won't be long before solar panel manufacturing is critical to our national security.