3 ms·
The Navy's ‘fast, agile’ warship has been stuck in ice since Christmas Eve
- dogma1138 9y agoWarships don’t operate in frozen water regardless of how much they cost you have ice breakers for that and even those can only break fairly thin and cracked ice. it’s not worth the risk of getting the ship into the high seas and it’s not like the US is short on combat vessels.
- 650REDHAIR 9y agoNot short on combat vessels and it's not ready anyway. The crew isn't up to speed or certified yet. There are plenty of legitimate reasons to rag on the USN right now. This isn't really newsworthy at all.
- dogma1138 9y agoHas any LCS completed it’s shakedown and is in full service? I though even the first (freedom and independence?) 2 were still in trials.
- Someone1234 9y agoIt is outside the mission scope of the littoral class of ship. They're not ice breakers, and frankly would be terrible ice breakers due to their tonnage. They're designed to sit close off of someone's coastline and "discourage" small boats (e.g. piracy, terrorism), detect submarines, and destroy mines. And definitely fits a niche some of the US's larger ships struggle to fulfil. They're who you'd send in to deal with Somali Pirates for one example. Just have it patrol up and down the coast.
- dtparr 9y agoYeah, I'm not sure why this is big news. The headline reads to me like "Man buys McLaren P1 for $1M. Doesn't take it out of garage after winter storm covers roads in sheets of ice".
- dsfyu404ed 9y ago"Navy is not exited to be hard on it's $440m taxpayer funded new toy by using it as an icebreaker. Millions of taxpayers are outraged." (sarcasm should be obvious)
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jfoutz 9y agoTaxpayers wonder why the initial voyage went somewhere where the ship could be stuck for 3 months. Sure, they can train in port and that's probably a good move for an all new ship and crew, but losing even the option to go out to sea seems, well, odd. i'm not a sailor, maybe this is the best way to go.
- GCU-Empiricist 9y agoPart of it is there is a large body of officers below flag rank, and a few notable ones at flag rank(maybe the current CNO) who think the LCS is a waste of procurement resources, especially at half the cost of a major combatant. That and the Australians are getting a lot more bang for less buck.
- megaman22 9y agoIt sounds like it's designed to fulfill the roles of the inexpensive WW2 PT boats, or Vietnam-era swift boats. I'm not sure why that role necessitates a half-billion dollar, complicated vessel... You could build quite a swarm of cheap, disposable craft for the same price tag.
- GCU-Empiricist 9y agoThe big price driver on it was the 50kt speed requirement. There's a big trade off between the threat of swarming small boats that can go that fast and the fact that the big boys fight with supersonic cruise missiles or naval gunfire.
- fludlight 9y agoIt sounds like the Navy wanted a Coast Guard cutter with better sensors but got carried away. Now they have a giant floating Bradley.
- megaman22 9y agoWhose bright idea was it to sail it down the St. Lawrence Seaway in December?
- pivo 9y agoMaybe someone who'd rather enjoy the excellent Montreal cuisine instead of what can be had in Buffalo?
- freehunter 9y agoPoutine and wings are both pure magic. I'd buy a $440m boat just to make sure I could get between Buffalo and Montreal to have the best of both worlds.
- Aloha 9y agoThis would be news if the headline read "Icebreaker stuck in Ice since Christmas Eve"
- dogma1138 9y agoIce breakers often get stuck in ice more so than any other ship they can clear only very thin surface ice basically they are used to clear the ice which is too thin for supply ships to offload onto so they clear a path towards the thicker ice shelf or land.
- vidanay 9y agoIf by "very thin" you mean up to 2.5 meters thick, then yeah. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear-powered_icebreaker https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear-powered_icebreaker
- dogma1138 9y agoThat’s thin, ice shelfs are 100m to over 1KM in thickness, sea ice can be over 3m thick, or at less used to be more than 3.5m thick on average these days it’s below 1.5m. Ice breakers used to be limited to periods where the sea ice would be thin enough to break these days they pretty much go all year around but they still break only relatively thin sea ice and can’t do shit to an ice shelf.
- cr1895 9y agoYou didn’t quantify “very thin” but certain ice-class vessels are designed to encounter meters-thick ice. See pg. 20, table A1: https://rules.dnvgl.com/docs/pdf/DNV/rulesship/2005-07/ts501.pdf https://rules.dnvgl.com/docs/pdf/DNV/rulesship/2005-07/ts501...
- ChuckMcM 9y agoSo clearly this is the build up for the dystopian post apocalyptic novel where our protagonist finds a completely functional and "brand new" warship frozen solid in the ice. They use primitive tools to defrost it and using it in a daring and surprising raid, defeat the evil warlord who has enslaved the former population of New York :-) Of course it isn't really all the much different than people in Boston who leave the 'good car' in the garage all winter because of the risk of damage associated with operating it in icy conditions.
- bargl 9y agoI just re-evaluated some of the times I've read a book and thought "No way would there be a _________ lying around and abandoned by the government. I bet they're too cheap to do that."
- TeMPOraL 9y agoGiven the name (Little Rock), it smells of nominative determinism :).