12 ms·
FTA: > The tricky task for policymakers is to restrain them without unduly stifling innovation. This suggests a profound lack of understanding of the power im
by titzer 9y ago
FTA:
> The tricky task for policymakers is to restrain them without unduly stifling innovation.
This suggests a profound lack of understanding of the power imbalance between the Tech Giants(TM) and the rest of the world. The fact that these big companies operate what amounts to mini-surveillance states and face little to no scrutiny about it, and this is not even mentioned in the article, is proof this person has not thought deeply about this problem. The additional fact that these huge Titans dominate vast monocultures puts us all at risk of catastrophic failure or the vulnerability of cyber attack and should scare the bejesus out of policymakers, militaries, and agencies tasked with securing national infrastructure.
People need to think harder about how bad it would be if, e.g. Apple or Google actually _were_ evil, or were co-opted into evil overnight. Or what if they were just evil _to you_.
Some of these companies essentially possess "kill switches" over vast parts of the computing landscape. Laptops are a bad software update from being bricks; the cloud is divided up into huge chunks that could go dark; one provider holds more than a third of the world's email; 90% of the world's search traffic.
These entities don't need to be somehow (gently) "restrained", but as a civilization we need to rethink the power we've ceded to them at a very fundamental level, or we risk growing ever weaker and more dependent on them.
- jlos 9y ago>>if , e.g. Apple or Google actually _were_evil Sean Parker on Facebook (and other Social Media giants) exploiting dopamine triggers and psychological drives for social validation: "[We're] exploiting a vulnerability in human psychology ... [The inventors] understood this, consciously, and we did it anyway." [0] https://www.axios.com/sean-parker-unloads-on-facebook-god-only-knows-what-its-doing-to-our-childrens-brains-1513306792-f855e7b4-4e99-4d60-8d51-2775559c2671.html https://www.axios.com/sean-parker-unloads-on-facebook-god-on...
- tzs 9y agoIsn't that a fancy way of saying they are making their product do things that people enjoy, so that people will use the product? This reminds me of the time I once had a chance encounter with Richard Feynman and was able to solve right there for him a particular instance of the local labeling problem in applied chronometrics that had stumped him. (Less fancy version: Feynman asked what time it was. I looked at my watch and told him).
- zepto 9y agoNo it’s not. Unless you think of a heroin addict as simply ‘enjoying a well designed product’.
- nerfhammer 9y agosharing photos with your aunt is not like heroin
- wu-ikkyu 9y agoFacilitating mass consumerism in the face of ecological self-destruction by manipulating billions of people's emotions and consciousness using the most powerful advertising machine in history, is a little bit like the self-destruction caused by heroin
- Chaebixi 9y ago> sharing photos with your aunt is not like heroin That's missing the point entirely. You can say heroin is a "well designed products" because it's users enjoy its immediate effects and keep coming back for more. That characterization is misleading because it leaves out all the downsides, including addiction. Similarly... >> Isn't that a fancy way of saying they are making their product do things that people enjoy, so that people will use the product? ...is a misleading characterization for exactly the same reason.
- leggomylibro 9y agoTry flipping it; they could be trying to make their people enjoy things that their product does.
- trevyn 9y ago>Isn't that a fancy way of saying they are making their product do things that people enjoy Humans have a tendency (called "hyperbolic discounting" in the literature) to choose a small immediate reward over a larger delayed reward. In this case, the small immediate reward is reading an interesting post on Facebook, and the delayed reward is... pretty much anything else. If we're lucky, people will become aware of this bias and start making better decisions, by designing their life to align their available immediate rewards with their choice of distant rewards. This is basically what things like Fitbits do -- provide small immediate rewards (number of steps going up!) that align with your desired larger distant reward (being in shape). Or the very notion of "getting off Facebook" -- increasing the personal effort/mental distance required to claim a small reward that does not align with a more distant goal. The reason this is particularly challenging is that "the Internet" is very useful for doing things that do align with our legitimate, long-term goals, but once the Internet is available, the distance to "Facebook rewards" is low. It might be interesting if Facebook, as a response to this backlash, finds a way to offer short term rewards that do align with your long-term goals...
- fredgrott 9y agobut than Sean Parker never gave back the millions he earned via past Facebook impl's...so his point is somewhat entirely hollow.. Its like a gun manufacturer saying automatics are bad but still making them
- Chaebixi 9y ago> but than Sean Parker never gave back the millions he earned via past Facebook impl's...so his point is somewhat entirely hollow.. That's not true at all. His explicit confession makes what once could only be speculation something much closer to a believable truth, which means people can do more about it. Chiding him for not donning sack-cloth in penance just undermines what good his statements could do. > Its like a gun manufacturer saying automatics are bad but still making them Does he even still work for them?
- r00fus 9y agoInstead of giving back, I'd agree if he paid (even some of) it forward and created an anti-FB/Goog/etc group that fought and lobbied for changes.
- rhizome 9y agoFB can withstand occasional bad press, but they can't withstand divestiture. I imagine Zuck's knives would come out in full force if Parker announced he was engaging your suggestion.
- rhizome 9y ago
- Bartweiss 9y ago> these big companies operate what amounts to mini-surveillance states and face little to no scrutiny about it Cynically, the reason for this is that their mini-surveillance states are contributors to a larger, more literal surveillance state; their would-be regulator is benefitting from this part of their behavior. Some (Yahoo, Verizon, possibly Amazon) look to be actively complicit. But even 'resisters' like Apple are better for surveillance than a decline in online communication or a move to decentralized, E2EE approaches. And in the apocalyptic case, it's useful to encourage reliance on a primary communication channel that can be disabled on demand. The 'kill switch' power is another one that can be borrowed by the actual state. I agree that rethinking this power distribution is an important move, but it's worth at least retaining an awareness of the cynical narrative: that regulation efforts against tech giants won't touch the areas where these companies are government proxies.
- jacksmith21006 9y agoApple appears to have sold out to the China government and at least Google chose instead to leave. http://money.cnn.com/2018/01/10/technology/apple-china-icloud/index.html http://money.cnn.com/2018/01/10/technology/apple-china-iclou... Apple: iCloud in China will be run by a state-owned company - Jan ...
- mrep 9y agoSo did AWS: https://techcrunch.com/2017/11/13/aws-exits-china/ https://techcrunch.com/2017/11/13/aws-exits-china/ If you want to have any technology business in china, that is your only option. Facebook, Google, Uber and many more have all failed because china won't let a foreign company win own huge technological market/data.
- dsacco 9y agoThis is a great comment. I don’t necessarily agree with the conclusions, but I like the argument and I’m impressed it’s being presented dispassionately. It’s tiring to see breathless anti-big company rants or conspiracy theories about dystopian surveillance state involvement. But I find your point about power imbalances to be pretty compelling - both in principle and in your neutral presentation.
- indigochill 9y agoAm I mistaken in my impression that the bulk of innovation actually happens outside of titans, which the titans then buy? So even hamstringing them wouldn't actually stifle innovation?
- jonathanyc 9y agoIt would seem like it. In terms of innovative research, it doesn’t seem like, say, Google Research is so much more productive than your average prestigious research university (albeit possessing perhaps a different set of focus areas). Similarly, when it comes to improvements on technical infrastructure, it seems Google plays a large role, but not an exceptionally large one, which makes sense by virtue of their massive deployments and having the capital to hire good engineers. Still, this doesn’t seem so outsized—Meltdown/Spectre weren’t discovered solely by Google, for example. On the other hand, when it comes to product innovation, it definitely seems like the bulk of it happens, as you said, outside titans. Again picking on Google (sorry), V8, Google Docs, Google Maps, YouTube, and Android were all acquisitions! And though Google acquiring them might certainly have given them large amounts of resources to expand (e.g. subsidizing YouTube), there is definitely the question of stifling innovation and competition. Consider TinEye, who first published reverse image search; later Google just poured engineers onto their own reverse image search platform and copied it. I think you can see the same dynamic with Facebook copying Snapchat features. It doesn’t seem like a healthy market. EDIT: V8 might be better characterized as the product of an acquihire, actually. It might not fit with the rest of the list, which were all literally acquisitions of products developed outside Google.
- ohtwenty 9y ago> Consider TinEye, who first published reverse image search; later Google just poured engineers onto their own reverse image search platform and copied it. I occasionally need to reverse-look-up images (mostly album covers without names) and tineye, in my personal experience, is vastly better. It finds matches for the exact image, with good context, etc. Google usually does pretty OK at finding similar images, but is less fantastic on matches, and if so those are joined in the noise of other 'close images'. To get back on topic: google is best at pretending they're the best. in my experience there's better reverse lookups. ddg is less 'fuzzy', but offers a much better experience with !bangs, and because of the non-fuzziness they're quite good at finding things when you know more or less what text you're looking for. OSM is often better at local details, especially in smaller/rural areas. Point being: google can throw whatever they want out there, and people will use it, and google says it's the best so people believe it. Because it's on their phones, because google suggests it, etc. I think the EU has a good point with their anti-trust/android business.
- ataturk 9y agoIn my opinion, Google already is evil--they are pushing collectivism, which I wholeheartedly disagree with. And they using mass surveillance in a grossly unwholesome manner. It would make the East Germans blush, quite frankly. Nobody in human history has gone this far. Plus, their collectivism is a least-common-denominator approach to the Chinese market! It's dangerous for all kinds of reasons. They are trying to crush dissent internally, too. I don't care to live like the average Chinese person, sorry Google. Apple is a weird case, too. Corporations optimize around profit and don't concern themselves with individuals. Mass market items are one-size-fits-most, and if you look at Apple products, you still see that. There's not much left in the tech world other than Linux for people who don't care to be a counter-party to tyranny.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Gatsky 9y agoThis argument is misapplied to tech companies. Replace Google with Exxon or Coca Cola or Boeing and the actual threat is greatly magnified. The point about cyber attack is a good example - in the real world, it is decidely non-tech companies and government institutions that suffer the most harmful cyber attacks. Your central point about power is sound however. The reason we should be worried is these companies actually shape how we live in many ways, and we are not in control, or rather nobody is.
- yazan94 9y ago> These entities don't need to be somehow (gently) "restrained", but as a civilization we need to rethink the power we've ceded to them at a very fundamental level, or we risk growing ever weaker and more dependent on them. I wholeheartedly agree with you on all the points you made, but I'm a bit weary for this one, especially using the term 'ceded'. Have we really ceded power to Apple/Google/Amazon/Facebook or have they simply 'won' the capitalism game? If they won, do we penalize them for winning? Can we force a breakup of these Tech Titans into independent companies (something akin to the Glass-Steagall Act of 1932 [1] or the breakup of Standard oil in 1911 [2]) or would that stifle the amazing innovation these companies put out regularly? If we have indeed ceded power, then what is our recourse? Legislation? By whom? Many of these companies are arguably working for the same government that is in the best place to enact such regulations, as shown in the Snowden leaks. I don't know what the best answer is, perhaps we need to wait out a few generations to get policy makers that actually understand what the internet is and the implications of digital monopolies. Perhaps the answer is less pessimistic. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_legislation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Glass%E2%80%93Steagall_legisla... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_D._Rockefeller https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_D._Rockefeller