5 ms·
I think the idea of a (near) 50/50 split is that if there were absolutely no biases or differences then you would see approximately this distribution. But we d
by godelski 9y ago
I think the idea of a (near) 50/50 split is that if there were absolutely no biases or differences then you would see approximately this distribution.
But we don't. We do know there are social biases, and thus these are being scrutinized much more. Certainly there can biological biases, but is is absurd to believe that is the only factor involved. My guess is that there is a whole complicated mess of problems and not an easy one (or even dozens) answer that accounts for these differences.
- blattimwind 9y agoWhy is it a problem if men and women aren't doing the exact same thing on average (i.e. professions distributed 50/50 by sex)?
- _jal 9y agoThere tend to be self-reinforcing trends in human behavior. Jobs that are highly gendered frequently stay that way, making it harder for the categorically-challenged to partake for purely social reasons. So there are two easily identifiable reasons: One, we should want a society more free from constraints on individual self-realization than less[1]. And for those who lean less cuddly, two, it is economically inefficient to exclude market participants on factors unrelated to performance[2]. [1] Well, I think we should want to optimize that; if you disagree, we have a far more fundamental disconnect. [2] Ironically, this is also an argument people use to claim that sexism and racism in the work place can't exist, in that annoying way some economists do.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y ago> One, we should want a society more free from constraints on individual self-realization than less. I don't think pushing women into a field that they overall don't want to do will help them earn self-realization. How would this work? > it is economically inefficient to exclude market participants on factors unrelated to performance The cynical side of me thinks that this is the real reason for the widespread push for diversity. A larger labor pool deleverages some of the highest paid employees in the world, thus increasing profits.
- blattimwind 9y ago> There tend to be self-reinforcing trends in human behavior. But we also know how quickly human behaviour changes and adapts to new circumstances. > Jobs that are highly gendered frequently stay that way, making it harder for the categorically-challenged to partake for purely social reasons. I can think of many jobs where this is true (for either sex), but software engineering doesn't seem to fit in this category. In STEM about 30-40 % of students are female; less at trade schools (=lower educational attainment). About 25 % of the IT workforce is female. > One, we should want a society more free from constraints on individual self-realization than less. Absolutely. > Ironically, this is also an argument people use to claim that sexism and racism in the work place can't exist, in that annoying way some economists do. I think the classical Friedmann argument was that there is a cost to biasing against competent people. It doesn't really say anything about what people will actually do (like much of economic theory), since they might be (1) not aware of the cost [and indeed it would be difficult to quantify] (2) valuing their *isms above that that cost. As far as classic economic theory goes, the argument seems to be correct, it's just a poor predictor for what humans will do.
- _jal 9y ago> but software engineering doesn't seem to fit in this category I was casting a significantly wider net, but you're correct wrt software-related fields. Moreover, women used to be far more prevalent in early-"IT"/operations than today, a shift that happened really quickly - a generation or two, depending on where you like to start counting. Shifts like this (they've happened elsewhere, too) is one massive argument against the "women just don't like math" silliness that always pops up. > As far as classic economic theory goes, the argument seems to be correct, it's just a poor predictor for what humans will do. Absolutely agree. That's the general thrust of my point overall.
- godelski 9y agoI didn't say that it is a problem. I said you'd expect to see it (ASSUMING NO BIASES). I think you are reading more into my comment that what I wrote.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoWhy does it matter if the differences are biological, cultural, or both? If women have the option to go into STEM without risking social exclusion(which is arguably the case in most developed countries) yet they choose to do something else, shouldn't that be their choice? Wouldn't these unequal trends naturally result in an environment with equal opportunities among people with different overall desires?
- godelski 9y agoI think you answer your own question > Why does it matter if the differences are biological, cultural, or both? > If women have the option to go into STEM without risking SOCIAL (ie: culture) exclusion yet they choose to do something else, shouldn't that be their choice? I'd say it matters if it is social exclusion. If a bias is caused by biology, then that's fine. But clearly there shouldn't be a cultural bias, because that prevents people from making that choice. I see the problem solved when there are no cultural or political barriers.
- TheAdamAndChe 9y agoThere is a big difference between social exclusion and cultural forces. In the 50's, it was nearly impossible for a woman to gain any power. Those who went against the gender norms of the time were ostracized and shunned. Nowadays, while there are cultural norms that guide how the majority of certain groups think, people who go against the norm are tolerated. That is okay with me. I think it's fine that cultural norms guide women into certain fields and men into another, as long as everyone has the equal opportunity to choose to go against the cultural grain. Which they do.