3 ms·
I found this contradictory. Galleries set prices, but "desirable collectors are well educated consumers and won’t blatantly overpay." What are collectors educ
by TheOtherHobbes 9y ago
I found this contradictory. Galleries set prices, but
"desirable collectors are well educated consumers and won’t blatantly overpay."
What are collectors educated in, exactly? Is it reading the collective market and understanding the pricing signals it generates? Is it marking new art to this market?
If the latter, how does that work if the art has no intrinsic value?
- fsloth 9y agoI suppose this means formal or accidental training in art and shared taste with the art market community. I presume the minimal level of skill is identifying famous artists' work from similar pieces of not-so-famous artists, recognizing influences and obvious pastiches, and so on. I.e. someone who had credibility among the art crowd and whos purchase of a work will function as social proof of the gallerists' brand.
- galfarragem 9y agoGood answer. I don't invest in art but I have a friend (an aspiring artist) who advises art investors. He knows the art scene, the trends and the local young artists so he has educated guesses on what to choose.
- jaclaz 9y agoThere is also another effect, which I call recursive over-valuation. The "high-end" art collectors tend to be extremely wealthy, and - with of course some exceptions - wealthy people are wealthy also because they care about money. So, imagine that you are a wealthy art collector and you have just paid - let's say - 100,000 US$ for a painting by an "emerging" artist. It is only human to show off your new painting, and the people you frequent are likely to be also wealthy and art collectors. So, if you have a name as an art collector, that painting soon becomes in your elite a "set point" for the value of the new artist work. The year later, a gallerist that is selling at 115,000 US$ another similar painting of the same artists can well say "Last year TheOtherHobbes bought a similar one for US$ 100,000, and you know him, he wouldn't pay that kind of money if it hadn't this value". And this sets a second precedent, and it goes on. BTW it is all in your interest to "defend" and "promote" the artist (because you defend your investment into it) even if the painting is awful. In a couple of years this way you will be able to re-sell the painting for - still say - US$ 200,000 while having - besides the profit - reinforced your fame as good investor and educated art expert, capable to see the potentiality of the artist ahead of all others...
- CPLX 9y agoSure but this dynamic is always true for all markets for things. You're just loosely describing a Keynesian beauty contest. At the core there's still someone or some group of people making some kind of fundamental aesthetic valuation. It's really more the severe lack of liquidity and impossibility of commoditizing of the market that creates the effect you're seeing.